Exhibit 10.19
RELEASE AND SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT
This Release and Settlement
Agreement (“Settlement Agreement”) is made by and
between US LEC Corp., US LEC Communications Inc., US LEC of Alabama
Inc., US LEC of Florida Inc., US LEC of Georgia Inc., US LEC of
Maryland Inc., US LEC of North Carolina Inc., US LEC of South
Carolina Inc., US LEC of Pennsylvania Inc., US LEC of Tennessee
Inc., and US LEC of Virginia LLC (collectively, “US
LEC”) and Qwest Communications Corporation
(“Qwest”). US LEC and Qwest are referred to herein
individually as a “Party,” or collectively as the
“Parties.” The Parties enter into this Settlement
Agreement on this 4th day of August, 2006.
RECITALS
WHEREAS, disputes have arisen
between US LEC and Qwest regarding charges billed by US LEC to
Qwest for wireless-originated interstate and intrastate toll free
(8YY) traffic (“Wireless-Originated 8YY Traffic”)
(the disputes referred to hereafter as the “Wireless Access
Dispute”) that were included in invoices issued by US LEC for
switched access services (“Switched Access
Traffic”)
WHEREAS, Qwest contends that through
usage periods ending June 30 2006, US LEC billed Qwest
approximately [***] in disputed charges for Wireless-Originated 8YY
Traffic (the “Wireless Access Charges”);
WHEREAS, through usage periods
ending June 30, 2006, Qwest contends that Qwest withheld
approximately [***] for charges by US LEC (excluding late payment
charges) for Wireless-Originated 8YY Traffic, and US LEC does not
agree (the “Withheld Payments”). Between October 2003
and April 2006, Qwest also contends that Qwest withheld
approximately [***] in late payment charges assessed by US LEC on
the Withheld Payments, and US LEC does not agree (the “Late
Payment Charges”). The Withheld Payments plus all Late
Payment Charges related to the Withheld Payments shall be referred
to hereafter as the “Disputed Withholdings”;
WHEREAS, in June 2004, Qwest
commenced a lawsuit in the District Court, City and County of
Denver, Colorado, Case No. 04-CV-4507 (filed June 14,
2004), concerning the Wireless Access Dispute and the Wireless
Access Charges (the “Colorado Lawsuit”);
WHEREAS, US LEC removed the Colorado
Lawsuit to the Federal District Court for the District of Colorado,
and the Colorado Lawsuit (Civil Action No. 04-K-1447) was
dismissed on June 6, 2005;
WHEREAS, in January 2005, US LEC
commenced a lawsuit in the United States District Court for the
Western District of North Carolina, Civil Action
No. 3:05-CV-11-MU (filed January 11, 2005), concerning
the Switched Access Traffic Invoices, which included the Wireless
Access Dispute and the Withheld Payments (the “North Carolina
Lawsuit”);
|
[***]
|
These portions
of this exhibit have been omitted and filed separately with the
Commission pursuant to a request for confidential
treatment.
|
CONFIDENTIAL
TREATMENT
WHEREAS, Qwest filed counterclaims
against US LEC in the North Carolina Lawsuit concerning the
Wireless Access Dispute and the Wireless Access Charges;
WHEREAS, the Parties desire to avoid
the uncertainties, risks and expenses attendant in the North
Carolina Lawsuit, and to settle and release claims related to the
Wireless Access Dispute, the Wireless-Originated 8YY Traffic, the
Withheld Payments, and the Wireless Access Charges (collectively
“the Claims”), as set forth herein.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of
the mutual promises and covenants provided herein, and other good
and valuable consideration, the sufficiency and receipt of which
are hereby acknowledged, the Parties agree as follows:
AGREEMENT
|
|
1.
|
Waiver of
Withheld Payments and Late Payment Charges
|
In resolution of all disputes
regarding the Disputed Withholdings, US LEC and Qwest mutually
agree that US LEC shall forgive and permanently waive any right to
collect the Disputed Withholdings, and US LEC will take the actions
necessary to credit Qwest’s accounts to implement the
Settlement Agreement.
|
|
2.
|
Execution
of New Wholesale Services Agreement
|
Simultaneously with the execution of
this Settlement Agreement, the Parties shall execute a new
Wholesale Services Agreement (“WSA”) in the form
attached hereto as Exhibit 1.
In resolution of all disputes
regarding the Wireless Access Charges and other written disputes
submitted by Qwest prior to August 4, 2006 in connection with
the Switched Access Traffic Invoices not relating to Wireless
Access Charges, US LEC and Qwest mutually agree that:
a. US LEC shall pay Qwest Three
Million Dollars ($3,000,000) (the “Settlement
Payment”). The Settlement Payment shall be payable by US LEC
to Qwest as set forth in Paragraph 3.f, below.
b. US LEC agrees to purchase
services from Qwest in the total amount of [***] under the terms
and conditions of the new WSA (the “Purchase
Commitment”). In accordance with the terms and conditions of
the WSA, the Parties agree that should US LEC fulfill the Purchase
Commitment prior to the end of the Purchase Commitment Period, then
any obligations hereunder with respect to the Purchase Commitment
will be deemed satisfied. US LEC agrees that any shortfall or
deficiency in purchases as required under the Purchase Commitment
will require a cash payment (the “Deficiency Charge”)
of a proportionate amount of the “Liquidated Settlement
Value.” The parties agree that the Liquidated Settlement
Value of this Purchase Commitment is [***] and that the sum of all
purchases under the Purchase Commitment is
|
[***]
|
These portions
of this exhibit have been omitted and filed separately with the
Commission pursuant to a request for confidential
treatment.
|
deemed to provide marginal value to Qwest equal
to the Liquidated Settlement Value. The means and method of
calculating such alternative cash payments are described in
paragraphs 3.4(a) through 3.4(d) of the Purchase Commitment, and
are incorporated herein by reference. The Parties agree that the
Purchase Commitment and Deficiency Charge of Liquidated Settlement
Value are alternative means of meeting US LEC’s obligations
under this paragraph, and that the Liquidated Settlement Value is
not a penalty.
c. Commencing with the usage period
beginning July 1, 2006, Qwest agrees to pay US LEC for
intrastate wireless-originated 8YY traffic in accordance with the
terms set forth in the Intrastate Wireless-Originated 8YY Services
Settlement Agreement between Qwest and US LEC, dated August 4,
2006.
d. Commencing with the usage period
beginning July 1, 2006, Qwest agrees to pay US LEC in the
ordinary course of business for all Switched Access Traffic that is
not governed by the terms of the Intrastate Wireless-Originated 8YY
Services Settlement Agreement between Qwest and US LEC pursuant to
the rates, terms and conditions of US LEC’s applicable
Federal or state tariff or price list on file with the applicable
regulatory agency as of the effective date of the Settlement
Agreement, and as from time to time revised by US LEC.
Notwithstanding anything in this Settlement Agreement to the
contrary, Qwest retains all rights to dispute US LEC’s
charges for such Switched Access Traffic under the applicable US
LEC tariff, federal and state law, and federal and state regulatory
rules and procedures.
e. The Parties acknowledge and agree
that the settlement terms contained in Paragraphs 2, 3.a, 3.b, 3.c
and 3.d, together with the waiver of the Disputed Withholdings
pursuant to Paragraph 1, constitutes the full and final settlement
of the Wireless Access Dispute.
f. No later than ten business days
from the date on which the last Party executes the Settlement
Agreement US LEC shall pay Qwest the Settlement Payment by wire
transfer to:
[ *** ]
|
|
4.
|
Dismissal
With Prejudice
|
Within five business days after the
Settlement Payment described in Paragraph 3.a above is made, the
Parties shall file a Stipulated Motion to Dismiss the North
Carolina Lawsuit, with prejudice, with each Party to pay its own
costs and attorney’s fees.
|
|
5.
|
Limited
Mutual Release
|
For and in consideration of the
performance by the Parties of their obligations under this
Settlement Agreement, the other agreements identified in paragraph
3, and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and
sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, US LEC on the one
hand, and Qwest on the other hand, for themselves and their parent
companies, subsidiaries, owners, affiliates, predecessors,
successors, shareholders, partners, principals, insurers and
assigns and their past, present and future employees, officers,
directors, attorneys, agents and representatives do hereby
absolutely, unconditionally, completely, and without
|
[***]
|
These portions
of this exhibit have been omitted and filed separately with the
Commission pursuant to a request for confidential
treatment.
|
reservation, release each other and their parent
companies, subsidiaries, owners, affiliates, predecessors,
successors, shareholders, partners, principals, insurers and
assigns and their past, present and future employees, officers,
directors, attorneys, agents and representatives from and against
each and every past, present and future action, claim, demand,
charge, invoice, complaint, petition, right, liability, damage,
loss, expense, obligation, potential action, cause of action, suit,
judgment, offset, or decree in controversy of any kind and nature
whatsoever, at law, in equity or