EXHIBIT 10.2
APX SETTLEMENT AND RELEASE OF CLAIMS AGREEMENT
This Agreement is entered into, as of
January 5, 2007, by and among each of the following:
APX
Inc.
Allegheny Energy Supply Company, LLC
American Electric Power Service Corp.
Aquila Merchant Services, Inc.
Avista Energy, Inc.
BP Energy Company
Calpine Energy Services, L.P.
Commonwealth Energy Corporation (n/k/a Commerce Energy, Inc.)
Constellation NewEnergy, Inc.
El Paso Marketing, LP (f/k/a El Paso Merchant Energy, LP)
Enron Energy Services, Inc.
Enron Power Marketing, Inc.
Sacramento Municipal Utility District
Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and Power District
Merrill Lynch Capital Services, Inc.
Morgan Stanley Capital Group Inc.
Tractebel Energy Marketing, Inc. (n/k/a Suez Energy Marketing NA,
Inc.)
TransAlta Energy Marketing (US) Inc.
Sempra Energy Solutions LLC
UC Davis Medical Center (The Regents of the University of
California)
Sierra Pacific Industries
Each of the above-described entities
is a Sponsoring Party, and collectively are Sponsoring Parties to
this Agreement and, together with the Subject Parties, are
“Parties” to this Agreement. Unless otherwise expressly
provided for herein, each capitalized term used in this Agreement
shall have the meaning set forth for such term in Section 1 or
as defined elsewhere in this Agreement.
RECITALS
Whereas, various of
the Parties are engaged in or have an interest in complex and
disputed proceedings including but not limited to proceedings
before FERC and related appeals pending before the United States
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Enron Bankruptcy
Proceedings, Calpine Bankruptcy Cases, appellate proceedings,
litigation, and investigations regarding numerous issues and
allegations arising from events in the Western electricity markets
in 2000 and 2001, including but not limited to transactions
facilitated by the APX.
Whereas , the
Sponsoring Parties collectively represent approximately 95% of the
value attributable to the APX Transactions during the Settlement
Period;
Whereas, EESI and
EPMI, both participants in the APX, are debtors in the Enron
Bankruptcy Cases;
Whereas, Calpine
Energy Services, L.P. (successor in interest to Calpine Power
Services Company) (“Calpine”), a participant in the
APX, is a debtor in the Calpine Bankruptcy Cases;
Whereas, the Parties
have determined that it is preferable to settle the disputes
addressed herein, rather than engage in costly, protracted and
uncertain litigation and to facilitate distribution of funds
claimed to be owed and owing by and to the Parties;
Whereas, this
Agreement contemplates a comprehensive resolution of all disputes
and other matters between the Parties with respect to the APX
Related Claims, except as expressly reserved in Section 6.7
below, (i) through the settlement of the regulatory
proceedings, bankruptcy proceedings, appellate proceedings,
litigation, proofs of claim, and claims identified herein, solely
as to the portions thereof pertaining to the APX Related Claims
between the Parties, and (ii) by effectuating the
transactions, granting of rights and benefits, and assumption of
obligations specified and provided for herein; and
Whereas , the Parties
believe that the implementation of this Agreement will simplify and
expedite the overall re-settlement of the California centralized
markets during the Settlement Period, avoid potential future issues
with respect to cash clearing and liability arising from the APX
Related Claims, and, therefore, serves the public interest.
Now, Therefore, in
consideration of the mutual covenants and agreements, and other
good and valuable consideration provided for herein, the
sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, intending to be
legally bound, and to resolve definitively and for all time, any
and all present, past and potential differences and disputes
between them related to the APX Related Claims, except as expressly
reserved in Section 6.7, and subject to and upon the terms and
conditions hereof, the Parties agree as follows:
AGREEMENT
1.
DEFINITIONS
The following capitalized terms,
which are in addition to other terms with initial capital letters
defined in the body of this Agreement or by the context in which
they appear in this Agreement, when used in this Agreement shall
have the meanings specified in this Section when used herein.
| |
1.1. |
|
“ Affiliate ” means, with respect to any
person, any other person (other than an individual) that, directly
or indirectly, through one or more intermediaries, controls, or is
controlled by, or is under common control with, such person. For
this purpose, “control” means the direct or indirect
ownership of fifty percent (50%) or more of the outstanding capital
stock or other equity interests having ordinary voting power. |
| |
| |
1.2. |
|
“ Agreement ” means this APX Settlement and
Release of Claims Agreement as the same may be amended, modified,
supplemented, or replaced from time to time by written agreement of
the Parties. |
| |
| |
1.3. |
|
“ APX ” means APX Inc. also having done
business as the Automated Power Exchange. |
2
| |
1.4. |
|
“ APX Escrow Account ” shall have the
meaning provided in Section 4.5. |
| |
| |
1.5. |
|
“ APX Holding Account ” means the account
that APX uses to cash clear PX and ISO amounts for APX
Participants. |
| |
| |
1.6. |
|
“ APX Monetary Reserve ” means one or more
APX accessible accounts maintained with Comerica Bank –
California, or a successor entity appointed by APX, that contains
cash to secure all or a portion of the obligations of certain APX
Participants. |
| |
| |
1.7. |
|
“ APX Participant ” means the entities
identified on Exhibit A attached hereto and their respective
Guarantors. |
| |
| |
1.8. |
|
“ APX Payment Recipients ” mean all APX
Participants entitled to receive a net payment pursuant to this
Agreement, as indicated in Exhibit B attached hereto. |
| |
| |
1.9. |
|
“ APX Related Claims ” means all claims,
demands, causes of action, offsets or setoffs and any resulting
losses, damages, expenses, attorneys’ fees and court costs
that the Parties and their Affiliates or Guarantors have or may
have against each other and their Affiliates or Guarantors in the
FERC Proceedings during the Settlement Period arising out of the
APX’s participation in the PX and ISO centralized markets for
wholesale electricity including, but not limited to (a) ISO
Amendment 51 and/or ISO GFN Adjustments involving APX and included
in the cash clearing for APX Transactions and (b) FERC refunds
for APX Transactions during the Settlement Period. |
| |
| |
1.10. |
|
“ APX Transactions ” means energy and
ancillary services bids, offers, purchases, sales and related
transmission schedules submitted and/or completed by APX in the ISO
and PX centralized markets and all APX Participant bids and offers,
and resulting transactions, that APX cleared among APX
Participants. |
| |
| |
1.11. |
|
“ Authorized Person ” means a representative
of a Party with authority to bind the Party to the terms of this
Agreement. |
| |
| |
1.12. |
|
“ Bankruptcy Code ” means Title 11 of the
United States Code, as the same may be amended from time to
time. |
| |
| |
1.13. |
|
“ Bankruptcy Rule 9019 Motion ” has the
meaning set forth in Section 7.5. |
| |
| |
1.14. |
|
“ Business Day ” means a calendar day
falling within Monday through Friday except for Federal
holidays. |
| |
| |
1.15. |
|
“ California Parties ” means collectively,
Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Southern California Edison
Company, San Diego Gas & Electric Company, the People of the
State of California, ex rel. Bill Lockyer, Attorney General, the
California Department of Water Resources acting solely under
authority and powers created by California Assembly Bill 1 from the
First Extraordinary Session of 2000-2001, codified in
Sections 80000 through 80270 of the California Water Code
(“CERS”), the California Electricity Oversight Board,
and the California Public Utilities Commission. |
3
| |
1.16. |
|
“ Calpine Bankruptcy Cases ” means
collectively, the cases commenced under Chapter 11 of the
Bankruptcy Code by Calpine Corporation and certain affiliates on or
after the initial petition date of December 20, 2005, styled
In re Calpine Corporation, et al. , Chapter 11 Case
Nos. 05-60200 (BRL), et al. , Jointly Administered, pending
before the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District
of New York. |
| |
| |
1.17. |
|
“ Calpine Bankruptcy Court ” means the court
before which the Calpine Bankruptcy Cases are pending: United
States Bankruptcy Court, Southern District of New York. |
| |
| |
1.18. |
|
“ Calpine Bankruptcy Court Order ” means the
Calpine Bankruptcy Court order granting the Required Calpine
Bankruptcy Court Approval regardless of whether such order or
orders are subject to appeal; provided that such order or orders
have not been stayed pending such appeal. |
| |
| |
1.19. |
|
“ Contributing Seller ” has the meaning
given in Section 4.4. |
| |
| |
1.20. |
|
“ EESI ” means Enron Energy Services,
Inc. |
| |
| |
1.21. |
|
“ Enron ” or the “ Enron
Parties ” means EPMI and EESI. |
| |
| |
1.22. |
|
“ Enron Bankruptcy Cases ” means,
collectively, the cases commenced under Chapter 11 of the
Bankruptcy Code by the Enron Debtors and certain affiliates on or
after the Initial Petition Date, styled In re Enron Corp. et
al. , Chapter 11 Case No. 01-16034 (AJG) Jointly
Administered, pending before the Enron Bankruptcy Court. |
| |
| |
1.23. |
|
“ Enron Bankruptcy Court ” means the court
before which the Enron Bankruptcy Cases are pending: United States
Bankruptcy Court, Southern District of New York. |
| |
| |
1.24. |
|
“ Enron Bankruptcy Court Order ” means the
Enron Bankruptcy Court order granting the Required Approval with
respect to the Enron Bankruptcy Proceedings, in accordance with
Sections 7.1 and 7.3 of this Agreement. |
| |
| |
1.25. |
|
“ Enron Bankruptcy Proceedings ” means,
collectively, the Enron Bankruptcy Cases and all related adversary
proceedings, claims objection proceedings, and appeals pending
before the Enron Bankruptcy Court and the United States District
Court for the Southern District of New York, and any proceedings on
remand. |
| |
| |
1.26. |
|
“ Enron-California Parties Settlement Agreement
” means that certain settlement between Enron, the California
Parties, and the FERC’s Office of Market Oversight and
Investigations (“OMOI”) approved by FERC in an order
dated November 15, 2005. |
| |
| |
1.27. |
|
“ Enron Debtors ” means EPMI and EESI,
together with their Affiliates, all as debtors in possession (or
reorganized debtors) on behalf of themselves and their respective
estates. |
| |
| |
1.28. |
|
“ Enron Non-Settling Parties ” has the
meaning given in Section 2.2.1. |
4
| |
1.29. |
|
“ Enron Plan ” means the Supplemental
Modified Fifth Amended Joint Plan of Affiliated Debtors Pursuant to
Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code confirmed by the Enron
Bankruptcy Court on or about July 15, 2004, in the Enron
Bankruptcy Cases as it may be amended, modified, or supplemented
from time to time in accordance with the terms thereof. |
| |
| |
1.30. |
|
“ Enron PX Collateral ” means the cash
collateral and letter of credit proceeds held in the Enron PX
Collateral Account totaling one hundred forty five million four
hundred fifty two thousand nine hundred forty seven dollars and no
cents ($145,452,947) as of November 30, 2006 and including any
additional accrued interest prior to distribution as required
herein. |
| |
| |
1.31. |
|
“ Enron PX Collateral Account ” means the
Bank of New York Trust company, N.A. segregated escrow sub-accounts
Number 028269 identified to EPMI. |
| |
| |
1.32. |
|
“ Enron Settlement Amount ” means eleven
million dollars and no cents ($11,000,000). |
| |
| |
1.33. |
|
“ Enron Settlement Reserve ” has the meaning
given in Section 2.2.1. |
| |
| |
1.34. |
|
“ EPMI ” means Enron Power Marketing,
Inc. |
| |
| |
1.35. |
|
“ Execution Date ” means, with respect to a
Sponsoring Party, the date upon which this Agreement has been
executed by such Party, including execution by any Party in
accordance with Section 9.2 of this Agreement. |
| |
| |
1.36. |
|
“ Existing Global Settlements ” are those
listed on Exhibit F. |
| |
| |
1.37. |
|
“ FERC ” means the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission. |
| |
| |
1.38. |
|
“ FERC Proceedings ” means the Refund
Proceeding and any related appeals and/or petitions for review and
any proceedings on remand relating to the foregoing proceeding
insofar and only to the extent that such proceedings are related to
the APX Transactions. |
| |
| |
1.39. |
|
“ FERC Settlement Order ” means a FERC order
meeting the requirements for a Required FERC Approval in accordance
with Section 7 of this Agreement, regardless of whether such
order is subject to requests for rehearing or appeals and
regardless of whether such order is subsequently modified or
reversed by FERC or a court subsequent to the Settlement Effective
Date; provided that on the Settlement Effective Date, such order
has not been stayed by FERC or a reviewing court pending such
rehearing or appeal. |
| |
| |
1.40. |
|
“ Final and Non-Appealable ” with respect to
an order of the Enron Bankruptcy Court, shall mean such order has
not been reversed, stayed, modified, amended or vacated and as to
which (a) any appeal taken, petition for certiorari or motion
for rehearing or reconsideration that has been filed, has been
finally determined or dismissed or (b) the time to appeal,
seek certiorari or move for reconsideration or rehearing has
expired and |
5
| |
|
|
no appeal, petition for certiorari or motion for
reconsideration or rehearing has been timely filed. |
| |
| |
1.41. |
|
“ Final Staff Report ” means the final
report entitled “Final Report on Price Manipulation in
Western Markets — Fact-Finding Investigation of Potential
Market Manipulation of Electric and Natural Gas Prices”
issued by FERC staff on March 26, 2003 in FERC Docket
No. PA02-2. |
| |
| |
1.42. |
|
“ FPA ” means the Federal Power Act, as
codified at 16 U.S.C. §791a et. seq., as the same may be
amended from time to time. |
| |
| |
1.43. |
|
“ Governmental Authority ” means any
“governmental unit” as defined in Section 101 of
the Bankruptcy Code. |
| |
| |
1.44. |
|
“ Guarantor ” means with respect to a Party,
one who guarantees the payment obligations of the Party pursuant to
the applicable ISO tariff, the PX tariff or the APX Participant
agreement. |
| |
| |
1.45. |
|
“ Initial Distribution ” has the meaning
given in Section 4.5. |
| |
| |
1.46. |
|
“ Initial Petition Date ” means
December 2, 2001, the date certain that the Enron Debtors,
including EPMI and EESI, filed petitions for relief under
Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code and commenced the Enron
Bankruptcy Cases in the Enron Bankruptcy Court. |
| |
| |
1.47. |
|
“ Initial Staff Report ” means the Initial
Report released by FERC staff on August 13, 2002 in connection
with the FERC investigation in FERC Docket No. PA02-2. |
| |
| |
1.48. |
|
“ ISO ” means the California Independent
System Operator Corporation, a California public benefit
corporation, and any successor thereto. |
| |
| |
1.49. |
|
“ ISO Amendment 51 ” means the system
recalculation performed by the ISO pursuant to procedures described
by the ISO in filings made in FERC Docket No. ER03-746, the
purpose of which was to establish the appropriate baseline against
which to apply the mitigated market price methodology to applicable
APX Transactions during the Refund Period. |
| |
| |
1.50. |
|
“ ISO GFN Adjustments ” means ISO
adjustments for the April 1998 to June 20, 2001 timeframe
made pursuant to an approved good faith negotiation that are to be
cash cleared in connection with the Refund Proceeding. |
| |
| |
1.51. |
|
“ Material Change Notice ” has the meaning
given in Section 7.4. |
| |
| |
1.52. |
|
“ Net Buyers ” mean all APX Participants
that, on a net basis and without regard to Short Payments owed to
them, are entitled to refunds for APX Transactions during the
Refund Period, as indicated in Exhibit B by the designation
“NB”. |
6
| |
1.53. |
|
“ Net Sellers ” mean all APX Participants
that, on a net basis and without regard to Short Payments owed to
them, are identified as potential refund payers for APX
Transactions during the Refund Period, as indicated in
Exhibit B by the designation “NS”. |
| |
| |
1.54. |
|
“ Party ” and “ Parties ”
have the meanings set forth in the preamble to this Agreement and
is inclusive of their Affiliates and Guarantors. |
| |
| |
1.55. |
|
“ Pre-Refund Period ” means the period from
May 1, 2000 through October 1, 2000. |
| |
| |
1.56. |
|
“ PX ” means the California Power Exchange
Corporation, a California public benefit corporation. |
| |
| |
1.57. |
|
“ Refund Period ” means the period from
October 2, 2000 through June 20, 2001. |
| |
| |
1.58. |
|
“ Refund Interest Reserve ” has the meaning
set forth in Section 4.1.3. |
| |
| |
1.59. |
|
“ Refund Proceeding ” means San Diego Gas
& Electric Co., et al. , FERC Docket No. EL00-95, et
al. |
| |
| |
1.60. |
|
“ Required Approvals ” means the Required
FERC Approval and Required Enron Bankruptcy Court Approval. |
| |
| |
1.61. |
|
“ Required Calpine Bankruptcy Court Approval
” means an order issued by the Calpine Bankruptcy Court
approving this Agreement, as described in Section 7.4,
authorizing the Calpine to grant releases in Section 6 below
and authorizing the allocation of the Calpine Short Payments and
associated interest and the release of collateral as set forth in
Section 4.3. |
| |
| |
1.62. |
|
“ Required Enron Bankruptcy Court Approval ”
means issuance of an Enron Bankruptcy Court Order that is Final and
Non-Appealable. |
| |
| |
1.63. |
|
“ Required FERC Approval ” means an order
issued by FERC approving this Agreement as required herein in
Section 7. |
| |
| |
1.64. |
|
“ Retained Enron PX Collateral ” has the
meaning given in Section 4.2. |
| |
| |
1.65. |
|
“ Scheduled Liabilities ” means the
liability schedules prepared and filed by the Enron Debtors with
the Enron Bankruptcy Court at or about the time the Enron Debtors
filed the Enron Bankruptcy Cases, reflecting sums owed to various
third parties. |
| |
| |
1.66. |
|
“ Seller Contribution Funding Agreement ”
has the meaning given in Section 4.4. |
| |
| |
1.67. |
|
“ Seller Funding Amount ” has the meaning
given in Section 4.4. |
| |
| |
1.68. |
|
“ Settlement Effective Date ” has the
meaning set forth in Section 2.3. |
| |
| |
1.69. |
|
“ Settlement Period ” means the combined
Pre-Refund Period and Refund Period. |
7
| |
1.70. |
|
“ Shortpay Interest Reserve ” has the
meaning set forth in Section 4.1.3. |
| |
| |
1.71. |
|
“ Short Payments ” means all funds owed to
any APX Participant by the ISO or PX in connection with its APX
Transactions during the Settlement Period, inclusive of unpaid soft
cap reversals and PX default payment funds held in escrow by the PX
as well as $234,799 of CAISO Short Payments due APX Participants
for the period July-August 2001. |
| |
| |
1.72. |
|
“ Sponsoring Party ” means all signatories
to this Agreement, including those Parties first identified above
together with those Parties that elect to become a Sponsoring Party
pursuant to Section 9.2. |
| |
| |
1.73. |
|
“ Subject Parties ” means those entities
identified in Exhibit A that are not Sponsoring Parties. |
| |
| |
1.74. |
|
“ Supporting Parties ” means Puget Sound
Energy, Inc. (“Puget”), Avista Energy, Inc.
(“Avista”), and Coral Power, L.L.C.
(“Coral”). Avista is both a Sponsoring Party and a
Supporting Party. Puget and Coral are signatories to this Agreement
as Supporting Parties for the sole purpose of acknowledging and
supporting its provisions as a means to resolve such parties’
objections to EPMI’s July 20, 2006 motion for release
the Enron PX Collateral in FERC Docket Nos. EL00-95-000 and
EL00-98-000. |
|
|
|
| 2. CONDITIONS TO
EFFECTIVENESS; SETTLEMENT EFFECTIVE DATE; TERMINATION |
| |
2.1. |
|
Agreement Binding as of the Execution Date. Except as
provided in Section 2.4 and Section 4.1.1.2, this
Agreement shall be a binding obligation of each Party immediately
upon the Execution Date. |
| |
| |
2.2. |
|
Conditions Precedent to Certain Obligations. The
occurrence of the Settlement Effective Date is a condition
precedent to: the obligation of a Party to make payments or to
allow or release claims or defenses under Sections 4, 5 and 6
hereof, and the effectiveness of all such obligations, allowances,
or releases specified hereunder. It shall also be a condition to
the effectiveness of this Agreement that Enron and the California
Parties reach agreement in accordance with Section 13.6 of the
Enron-California Parties Settlement Agreement to modify the
Enron-California Parties Settlement Agreement with respect to APX
refunds and associated interest from CERS set forth in
Section 4.1.4, 4.1.5 and 4.3.3 such that the
Enron–California Parties Settlement Agreement is consistent
with Section 4.1.1.1 of this Agreement with respect to the
rights of Enron Non Settling Parties; provided this condition may
be waived by Enron subject to Enron’s full and complete
performance of the Enron-California Parties Settlement Agreement
including sections 4.1.4, 4.1.5, and 4.3.3 thereof. It shall be a
further condition to the effectiveness of this Agreement, unless
expressly waived by Enron, that, in accordance with Section 7
and unless the FERC Settlement Order makes an express, specific
finding to the contrary, the FERC Settlement Order shall be deemed
and construed as an order finding and concluding: |
8
| |
2.2.1. |
|
The following funds are sufficient and adequate to protect the
interests of Enron Non-Settling Parties: (a) the Enron
Settlement Amount, plus (b) the Retained Enron PX Collateral,
to create a total fund of fourteen million five hundred thousand
dollars and no cents ($14,500,000.00) in the Enron PX Collateral
Account (the “Enron Settlement Reserve”), plus
(c) the funds already set aside in escrow (approximately
$2.8 million) pursuant to the Enron-California Parties
Settlement Agreement for “Non-Settling Participants”
(as that term is defined in the Enron-California Parties Settlement
Agreement) so long as they remain “Non-Settling
Participants” (the “Enron Non-Settling Parties”),
such funds totaling approximately $17.3 million, provided,
however, that the Enron Settlement Reserve shall be used, if and
only if, any refund amounts due to the Enron Non-Settling Parties
from Enron (as determined by FERC) resulting from participation in
the ISO and PX markets are unpaid directly as a result of
EPMI’s bankruptcy or otherwise. |
| |
| |
2.2.2. |
|
The allocation of the Enron Settlement Reserve for the Enron
Non-Settling Parties set forth in Exhibit D is appropriate to
protect the interests of the Supporting Parties, as well as the
other Enron Non-Settling Parties, as described in Exhibit D, if and
only if, any refund amounts due to the Enron Non-Settling Parties
from Enron (as determined by FERC) resulting from participation in
the ISO and PX markets are unpaid directly as a result of
EPMI’s bankruptcy or otherwise. |
| |
| |
2.2.3. |
|
Subject to the terms and conditions of this Agreement,
EPMI’s motion for release of the Enron PX Collateral is
reasonable and the PX is ordered to immediately release from the
Enron PX Collateral Account to EPMI, for payment to its creditors
under the Enron Plan, the balance of EPMI’s assets held by
the PX in excess of the Enron Settlement Reserve, plus applicable
interest, in the amount of one hundred forty one million nine
hundred fifty two thousand nine hundred forty seven dollars and no
cents ($141,952,947.00) (which amount reflects the balance in the
Enron PX Collateral account as of November 30, 2006 plus the
Enron Settlement Amount less the Enron Settlement Reserve), plus
interest accrued on the Enron PX Collateral after November 30,
2006. |
| |
2.3. |
|
Settlement Effective Date. The “Settlement
Effective Date” shall occur on the beginning of the third
Business Day following the latest of the following dates:
(i) the date when the Required FERC Approval (as defined in
Section 7) has been issued, provided that a Material Change
Notice has not been timely and properly given by a Sponsoring Party
as to such approval in accordance with Section 7.4 (unless the
other Sponsoring Parties agree in writing, on or before
March 1, 2007, that the Settlement Effective Date has occurred
notwithstanding any such Material Change Notice), and (ii) the
date when the Required Enron Bankruptcy Court Approval has been
received provided that no Material Change Notice has been timely
and properly given by a Sponsoring Party as to such approval in
accordance with Section 7.4 (unless the other Sponsoring
Parties agree in writing, on or before March 1, 2007, that the
Settlement Effective Date has occurred notwithstanding any such
Material Change Notice). On |
9
| |
|
|
the Settlement Effective Date, Enron shall provide the
Sponsoring Parties and the PX with written notice of the occurrence
of the Settlement Effective Date. |
| |
| |
2.4. |
|
Termination. This Agreement shall terminate in the event
any of the following occurs, and not otherwise: (a) unless
waived by Enron, if a fully-executed Agreement constituting part of
an offer of settlement pursuant to Rule 602 of FERC’s
Rules of Practice and Procedure, along with a motion for expedited
approval, is not filed with FERC on or before January 5, 2007;
(b) unless waived by Enron, if FERC has not issued an order
approving the Agreement by March 1, 2007; (c) as to the
FERC Settlement Order, FERC issues an order denying approval of
this Agreement, or a Sponsoring Party provides to the other
Sponsoring Parties with a Material Change Notice and the other
Sponsoring Parties do not agree in writing on or before
March 1, 2007 that the Settlement Effective Date has occurred
notwithstanding the Material Change Notice; (d) as to the
Enron Bankruptcy Court Order, the Enron Bankruptcy Court issues an
order denying approval of this Agreement, or a Sponsoring Party
provides to the other Sponsoring Parties with a Material Change
Notice and the other Sponsoring Parties do not agree in writing on
or before March 1, 2007 that the Settlement Effective Date has
occurred notwithstanding the Material Change Notice; or
(e) the Settlement Effective Date has not occurred by the
third Business Day after March 1, 2007, unless all Sponsoring
Parties consent voluntarily in writing to an extension of such
date. Upon the occurrence of the Settlement Effective Date, this
Agreement shall not thereafter terminate for any reason. The
Sponsoring Parties agree that from and after the Settlement
Effective Date (i) they shall be bound by the terms of this
Agreement notwithstanding any order or ruling reversing, remanding
or otherwise modifying this Agreement on rehearing,
reconsideration, appeal or remand of the Enron Bankruptcy Court
Order and/or the FERC Settlement Order, and (ii) they shall
use reasonable efforts to defend and preserve the terms of this
Agreement against any such order or ruling. |
| |
| |
2.5. |
|
Effect of Termination. In the event of termination
pursuant to Section 2.4, this Agreement shall be of no further
force or effect, with all rights, claims, defenses, duties, and
obligations of the Parties thereafter restored as if this Agreement
had never been executed. |
|
|
|
| 3. SETTLEMENT AND
ACKNOWLEDGMENT |
| |
3.1. |
|
Acknowledgement of Compromise. The payments and other
consideration agreed to in this Agreement, along with the covenants
and obligations herein, settle and compromise the APX Related
Claims and/or defenses of the Parties against each other in the
various proceedings described in Exhibit C attached hereto and
avoid costly, protracted and uncertain litigation and ensure
expedient release of payments under the Agreement. |
10
4.
MONETARY CONSIDERATION PROVIDED BY THE PARTIES
| |
4.1. |
|
Monetary Consideration. The monetary settlement
consideration exchanged by the Parties shall be comprised of the
following terms pursuant to the FERC Settlement Order: |
| |
4.1.1. |
|
The Parties shall pay and be paid the amounts set forth on
Exhibit B attached hereto, subject to the following
adjustments: |
| |
4.1.1.1. |
|
Enron shall be paid the Enron Settlement Amount
($11,000,000.00) from the APX Escrow Account within ten
(10) Business Days of the Settlement Effective Date, which
funds shall be used to establish the Enron Settlement Reserve as
described in Section 4.2 below. Notwithstanding any other
provision in this Agreement and subject to Section 2.2 of this
Agreement with regard to Sections 4.1.4, 4.1.5 and 4.3.3 of
the Enron-California Parties Settlement Agreement, the Enron
Settlement Amount is not subject to any adjustment for any reason
as of the Settlement Effective Date. |
| |
| |
4.1.1.2. |
|
Calpine’s rights and obligations under this Agreement
shall be null and void unless the Required Calpine Bankruptcy Court
Approval is received on or before February 28, 2007. Calpine
shall provide written notice to the Sponsoring Parties immediately
upon the receipt of the Required Calpine Bankruptcy Court Approval.
In the event that Calpine does not obtain the Required Calpine
Bankruptcy Court Approval by February 28, 2007, then Calpine
shall be excluded from this Agreement and the amounts to be paid to
Net Buyers, as reflected in Exhibit B shall be reduced on a
pro rata basis, by the amount of Calpine’s contribution to
the settlement, as reflected in Exhibit B and APX shall
proceed to make proportional assignment of its rights, title and
interest in Proof of Claim No. 3655 in the Calpine Bankruptcy
Cases to the Net Buyers reflected on Exhibit B. In this event,
the Parties retain all rights and claims otherwise available to
them against Calpine, including but not limited to, in the FERC
Proceedings and the Calpine Bankruptcy Case, and this Agreement
shall have no effect on those rights and claims. |
| |
| |
4.1.1.3. |
|
In the event that any Party is excluded from this Agreement
pursuant to Section 9.3, then the amounts to be paid to Net
Buyers, as reflected in Exhibit B shall be increased or
decreased on a pro rata basis by the amounts allocated to such
Party as reflected in Exhibit B. |
| |
| |
4.1.1.4. |
|
In the event that amounts due and owing to the APX from the ISO
and/or PX are reduced or not paid for any reason, the amounts to be
paid to Net Buyers, as reflected in Exhibit B, shall be
decreased on a |
11
| |
|
|
pro rata basis by the amount the ISO and/or PX fail to pay APX.
Tractebel will waive its cost recovery filing as moot upon the
Settlement Effective Date and will file to withdraw its filing with
prejudice as of the date the FERC Settlement Order becomes final
and non-appealable. The ISO and PX shall not reduce the refunds to
be paid to APX on account of Tractebel’s cost recovery
filing. |
| |
| |
4.1.1.5. |
|
Within five (5) Business Days following the Settlement
Effective Date, APX shall initiate the necessary actions to opt-in
to the Existing Global Settlements set forth on Exhibit F, and
thereafter use its best efforts to successfully complete such
opt-ins. APX shall provide status reports of its efforts in this
respect to the Net Buyers at no less than monthly intervals. Within
two (2) Business Days following the filing of this Agreement
with FERC, APX will supply a copy of this Agreement and all
Exhibits to each of the named sellers in the Global Settlement
Agreements listed in Exhibit F of this Agreement, and
specifically advise each such seller of the existence of this
Section 4.1.1.5. To the extent that the California Parties and
the named sellers under the Existing Global Settlements agree to
waive the deadline provisions for opting into those Global
Settlements, APX will opt-in to the Existing Global Settlements
within five (5) Business Days of the Settlement Effective
Date, or as soon thereafter as any such waivers are provided. All
amounts, including interest, paid to APX as a result of it opting
into the Existing Global Settlements will be paid to APX in
accordance with the terms of those Settlements, and will be flowed
through to the Net Buyers listed on Exhibit B on a pro rata
basis in accordance with the terms of Section 4.5. |
| |
| |
4.1.1.6. |
|
Within two (2) Business Days following the Settlement
Effective Date, APX shall pay or debit, as appropriate, to the APX
Participants the net collateral listed on Exhibit J, provided
however, the collateral shown for EESI on Exhibit J shall be
paid as directed in Section 4.5. |
| |
4.1.2. |
|
Subject to any adjustments pursuant to Section 4.1.1, and
pursuant to the procedures set out in Section 4.5, APX shall
be ordered to pay and distribute to APX Payment Recipients, in
accordance with the amounts shown on Exhibit B (a) all
refunds owed to and received by APX from the ISO and PX, including
such refunds resulting from APX’s successful opt-in efforts
pursuant to Section 4.1.1.5 of this Agreement, plus interest;
plus (b) all Short Payments, including those arising from
payment defaults, owed to APX from the ISO and PX, to the extent
received from the ISO and PX, including interest subject to
Sections 4.1.3 and Section 4.3; plus (c) five million one
hundred sixty one thousand one hundred seventy eight dollars and
ninety six cents ($5,161,178.96) held in the APX Holding Account;
plus (d) two million forty five thousand eight hundred twenty
two dollars and no cents |
12
| |
|
|
($2,045,822.00) held as collateral for EESI, which amount shall
be released by APX from the APX Monetary Reserve to the APX Escrow
Account; plus (e) the Seller Funding Amount under
Section 4.4. |
| |
| |
4.1.3. |
|
The ISO and PX will include interest on the refunds and Short
Payments that they will provide APX pursuant to Section 4.5(a)
of this Settlement Agreement. The interest will be determined in
accordance with the Commission’s applicable rulings in this
proceeding. To the extent that either the ISO or PX has an interest
short-fall below the interest rates otherwise required by the
Commission’s regulations and rulings in this proceeding
related to either the refunds and Short Payments owed APX for APX
Transactions in the PX and ISO centralized markets during the
Refund Period, they will be permitted to hold-back, as necessary,
25 percent of the interest otherwise owed to APX on the
refunds (“Refund Interest Reserve”) and Short Payments
(“Shortpay Interest Reserve”), and subject to
Section 4.3 pertaining to Calpine. APX shall distribute all of
the interest that it receives from the ISO and PX to the Net Buyers
on Exhibit B on a pro rata basis in accordance with the
provisions of Section 4.5. At the conclusion of the FERC
Proceedings, to the extent that FERC does not require the ISO or PX
to utilize any or all of the Shortpay Interest Reserve and/or the
Refund Interest Reserve to cover interest short-falls related to
APX Transactions, the ISO and PX shall distribute such amounts
(inclusive of any actual additional interest that may accumulate
thereon) to APX, and APX shall distribute any such amounts within
five (5) Business Days of receipt to the Net Buyers listed on
Exhibit B on a pro rata basis. |
| |
| |
4.1.4. |
|
To the extent any net refunds, including interest related
thereto, are paid by the ISO and/or PX to the APX for APX
Transactions during the Pre-Refund Period, those amounts shall be
paid and distributed to the Net Buyers on Exhibit B in
proportion to their pro rata share of APX Transactions during the
Pre-Refund Period. This Agreement does not address who is
responsible for any refunds (if any) that FERC may hereafter direct
be paid to the ISO and/or PX in respect of APX Transactions for the
Pre-Refund Period; provided, however, that in no event will
EPMI/EESI or APX itself have any responsibility for paying any such
refunds. All Parties reserve their rights to contest any proposal
that refunds are owed in respect of APX Transactions refunds for
the Pre-Refund Period and to appeal any finding by FERC that such
refunds are owed for the Pre-Refund Period; provided, however, that
with respect to the Settlement Period in its entirety, no claim for
intra-APX market refunds will be advanced by any Party. Under no
circumstances will the operation of this Section 4.1.4 alter,
decrease, increase or otherwise change the fixed amounts due Enron
pursuant to Section 4.1.1.1 hereof. |
| |
4.2. |
|
Enron Settlement Reserve. The Enron Settlement Amount
shall be transferred from the APX Escrow Account to the Enron PX
Collateral account. In addition, Enron hereby agrees to set aside
an additional three million five hundred thousand dollars
and no cents ($3,500,000.00) in funds from the Enron PX Collateral
(the “Retained Enron |
13
| |
|
|
PX Collateral”) to establish the Enron Settlement Reserve
in the total amount of fourteen million five hundred thousand
dollars and no cents ($14,500,000.00) to be held in the Enron PX
Collateral Account as described in Section 2.2.1. The Enron
Settlement Reserve is available to settle the claims of the Enron
Non-Settling Parties, if and only if, any refund amounts due to the
Enron Non-Settling Parties from EPMI (as determined by FERC)
resulting from Enron’s participation in the PX and ISO
markets are unpaid for any reason directly as result of
EPMI’s bankruptcy or otherwise. In the event that the Enron
Settlement Reserve for Enron Non-Settling Parties is not needed for
the Enron Non-Settling Parties and/or Supporting Parties for the
purpose stated, then the balance plus accrued interest shall be
paid to EPMI by the PX at the earliest possible date without
further action by EPMI. |
| |
| |
4.3. |
|
Calpine Monetary Consideration. Of the Short Payments
plus interest owed to Calpine, Calpine hereby agrees, subject to
receipt of the Required Calpine Bankruptcy Court Approval on or
before February 28, 2007, to release and contribute on the
Settlement Effective Date two million five hundred eighty nine
thousand two hundred fifty one dollars and no cents ($2,589,251.00)
plus interest accrued on this amount to the APX Escrow Account. So
long as the Required Calpine Bankruptcy Court Approval has been
received on or before February 28, 2007, upon receipt of
amounts owed to it by the PX and ISO the APX shall, within ten (10)
days of the Settlement Effective Date, pay to Calpine the sum of
(a) the remaining two million five hundred eighty nine
thousand two hundred fifty one dollars and no cents ($2,589,251.00)
of Short Payments, plus (b) interest accrued on this amount,
plus (c) the Calpine collateral shown on Exhibit J.
Subject to receipt of the Required Calpine Bankruptcy Court
Approval on or before February 28, 2007, APX, the Enron
Parties, and Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. agree to withdraw with
prejudice their proofs of claims against Calpine in the Calpine
Bankruptcy Cases, in the form and substance of the notices of
withdrawal attached as Exhibit E hereto including without
limitation, Proof of Claim Nos. 3655 filed by APX, 2998 filed by
Constellation NewEnergy, Inc., and 4079 and 4087 filed by the Enron
Parties. Calpine, APX, Constellation NewEnergy, Inc. and the Enron
Parties agree that each shall act reasonably and in good faith to
cooperate and to take all reasonable steps to secure satisfaction
of the terms specified in this Section 4.3. Upon the
Settlement Effective Date and subject to the Required Calpine
Bankruptcy Court Approval being received no later than
February 28, 2007, that part of Proof of Claim No. 5285
filed by FERC concerning APX Transactions and APX Related Claims
and the claims of the Subject Parties in the Calpine Bankruptcy
Cases concerning APX Transactions and APX Related Claims, if any,
shall be deemed to have been satisfied. Other than the claims
identified in this Section 4.3, the Sponsoring Parties
represent that no other claims have been filed by the Sponsoring
Parties in the Calpine Bankruptcy Cases for APX Related Claims. No
claim filed in the Calpine Bankruptcy Cases by any of the Parties
for non-APX Related Claims shall be affected in any way by this
Agreement. |
| |
| |
4.4. |
|
Seller Contributions. As part of the aggregate
consideration paid for the settlement, certain Net Sellers (each a
“Contributing Seller” and together the
“Contributing Sellers”) have entered into a written
payment agreement with APX (the “Seller Contribution Funding
Agreement”) that (a) directs APX to function as agent
for the net |
14
| |
|
|
payees under the settlement and (b) prohibits disclosure
of the identity of any of the Contributing Sellers or their
respective payment amounts. Pursuant to the terms of the Seller
Contribution Funding Agreement, the Contributing Sellers will
forward to APX fixed dollar amounts totaling in the aggregate of
one million two hundred fifty thousand dollars and no cents
($1,250,000.00) (the “Seller Funding Amount”), with
such payments to be made by each such Contributing Seller via wire
transfer to APX within five (5) Business Days of the date of the
Settlement Effective Date in compliance with the terms of
Section 4.5 of this Agreement. APX shall provide all
Sponsoring Parties with written confirmation that the APX has
received the aggregate Seller Funding Amount within seven
(7) Business Days of the date of the Settlement Effective
Date. In the event that a Contributing Seller does not comply with
its obligation under the Seller Contribution Funding Agreement to
make a required payment, APX shall disclose, to any APX Payment
Recipient hereunder requesting such disclosure, the identity of
such noncompliant Contributing Seller and the amount of such
Contributing Seller’s required payment under the Seller
Contribution Funding Agreement, and any such APX Payment Recipient
hereunder has standing to and may seek to enforce such payment
obligation directly against any such noncompliant Contributing
Seller. |
| |
| |
4.5. |
|
Payments. Within five (5) Business Days of the
Settlement Effective Date, in order to facilitate the distribution
of funds by APX to the APX Payment Recipients, (a) the ISO and
PX shall release to APX all funds owed to APX, including refunds
and Short Payments for APX Transactions during the Refund Period,
plus interest thereon, subject to the provisions of
Section 4.1.3 regarding interest, (b) the Parties
required to release receivables reflected in Exhibit B shall
provide such releases to APX; (c) APX shall release five
million one hundred sixty one thousand one hundred seventy eight
dollars and ninety six cents ($5,161,178.96) in the APX Holding
Account; (d) APX shall release from the APX Monetary Reserve
two million forty five thousand eight hundred twenty two dollars
and no cents ($2,045,822.00) held as collateral for Enron; and
(e) the Contributing Sellers shall pay the Seller Funding
Amount. All amounts referred to in the preceding sentence shall be
placed in a segregated account to be established by the APX at its
expense for purposes of effectuating this Agreement (the “APX
Escrow Account”). Within ten (10) Business Days of the
Settlement Effective Date, APX shall distribute all of the monies
contained in the APX Escrow Account to the APX Payment Recipients
shown on Exhibit B on a pro rata basis in accordance with
Exhibit B, as may be adjusted pursuant to Section 4.1.1
(the “Initial Distribution”). All funds, if any, owed
to APX related to APX’s opt-in to the Existing Global
Settlements in accordance with Section 4.1.1.5, shall be
placed in the APX Escrow Fund immediately upon receipt. APX shall
thereafter provide notice to the Parties of the amount and source
of such funds received, and shall distribute all such funds to Net
Buyers shown on Exhibit B on a pro rata basis within five
(5) Business Days of receipt. Any failure or delay in receipt
of payments, or the timing of the receipt of any funds related to
APX’s opt-in to the Existing Global Settlements, shall not
alter or prevent in any manner the immediate release of the balance
of the Enron PX Collateral, as contemplated in Section 2.2.3
and the FERC Settlement Order. To the extent that APX receives
additional funds covered by this Agreement from the ISO and/or the
PX after the Initial Distribution, APX shall immediately
notify |
15
| |
|
|
the Parties of such receipt and distribute such additional
funds within two (2) Business Days of receipt to the APX
Payment Recipients shown on Exhibit B on a pro rata basis in
accordance with Exhibit B. |
5.
NON-MONETARY CONSIDERATION
| |
5.1. |
|
Additional Consideration Exchanged . Simultaneous with
the Settlement Effective Date, additional non-monetary
consideration shall be, and shall be deemed to have been, exchanged
in the form and substance of the mutual releases set forth in
Section 6. |
| |
| |
5.2. |
|
UC Davis Medical Center. The UC Davis Medical center
represents that the generation unit at the University of California
Davis Medical Center only sold ancillary services to the ISO during
the Refund Period. APX submitted unit-specific bids and schedules
on behalf of the Regents of the University of California
(“Regents”) to the ISO and APX received unit-specific
dispatch instructions and ancillary service awards from the ISO.
Settlement statements from the ISO clearly identify all UC Davis
Medical Center schedules and transactions by unit designation for
instructed energy, deviations and ancillary service award. If the
Regents and the California Parties reach a settlement of refund
issues related to APX Transactions prior to the Settlement
Effective Date, the Regents shall be excluded from this Agreement.
The APX Participants will not impede the Regents from settling
issues directly related to |
|