|
Exhibit 10.3
SETTLEMENT AND LICENSE AGREEMENT
AND
MUTUAL GENERAL RELEASE
This Settlement and License Agreement and Mutual General Release
(the "Agreement") is made and entered into by and between MCKESSON
INFORMATION SOLUTIONS LLC ("McKesson"), a Delaware Corporation with
its principal offices at 5995 Windward Parkway, Alpharetta, Georgia
30005, and THE TRIZETTO GROUP, INC. ("TriZetto"), a Delaware
corporation with its principal offices at 567 San Nicolas Drive,
Suite 360, Newport Beach, California 92660. The Agreement is
effective as of the date last executed by the parties as set forth
next to its signature below, whichever date is later (the
"Effective Date"). Where appropriate, McKesson and TriZetto are
collectively referred to herein as the "Parties."
RECITALS
A. On October 12, 1993, U.S. Patent No. 5,253,164 (the
"‘164 patent"), titled "System and Method For Detecting
Fraudulent Medical Claims Via Examination Of Service Codes," was
issued by the United States Patent and Trademark Office, naming Don
C. Holloway, Robert D. Hertenstein, George A. Goldberg, and Kelli
A. Dugan as inventors. The ‘164 patent has an effective
filing date of September 30, 1988, and it will expire on
October 12, 2010. The ‘164 patent was assigned to Health
Payment Review, Inc. ("HPR") by the named inventors.
B. HPR was acquired by HBO & Company ("HBOC") effective
December 1997. HBOC previously acquired Gabrieli Medical
Information Systems, Inc. ("GMIS") effective December, 1996.
McKesson Corporation completed a merger with HBOC in January 1999.
McKesson is a subsidiary of McKesson Corporation and is the current
assignee of the ‘164
patent. References herein to McKesson shall
include its predecessors in interest, HPR, HBOC and
GMIS.
C. TriZetto acquired Erisco Managed Care Technologies, Inc.
("Erisco") effective October 2000. TriZetto acquired Resource
Information Management Systems, Inc. ("RIMS") effective December
2000. TriZetto makes and sells in the United States software
products under the names ClaimFacts, Facets, and QicLink.
References herein to TriZetto shall include its predecessors in
interest, Erisco and RIMS.
D. On September 13, 2004, McKesson filed a complaint
against TriZetto in the District Court for the District of Delaware
captioned McKesson Information Solutions LLC v. The TriZetto
Group, Inc., Civil Action No. 04-1258-SLR (the "Action"),
alleging one cause of action for infringement of the ‘164
patent (the "Complaint").
E. On November 1, 2004, TriZetto answered the Complaint,
denying the material allegations therein, and filed a counterclaim
for declaratory judgment of non-infringement, invalidity, and
unenforceability of the ‘164 patent (the "Answer and
Counterclaim"). The Complaint, Answer and Counterclaim and all
submissions made by the Parties in the Action are hereinafter
referred to as the "Pleadings and Filings."
F. The Parties desire to settle and resolve the Action and enter
into a settlement agreement which provides for dismissal of the
Action. This Settlement is made to avoid the uncertainty, time, and
expense associated with further litigation and appeals, and neither
party makes any admissions whatsoever, including without limitation
any admissions or acknowledgements of liability, infringement, or
validity of the ‘164 Patent.
2
G. In connection with the settlement of the
Action, TriZetto desires to obtain, and McKesson is willing to
grant, a non-exclusive license to the ‘164 Patent, subject to
all of the terms and conditions of this Agreement.
NOW THEREFORE, it is understood and agreed by the Parties that
in full, sufficient, and complete consideration of the mutual
promises and covenants contained herein, the Parties hereby agree
as follows:
AGREEMENT
-
For purposes of this Agreement, all terms not
otherwise defined are defined below, which definitions are
expressly incorporated herein by this reference.
1.1 Clinical Editing Database . A database containing
information on medical procedure codes, including relationships
among two or more medical procedure codes defining whether selected
ones of the medical procedure codes are appropriate for payment
when input with other selected ones of the medical procedure
codes.
1.2 Clinical Editing Product. Software that includes
and/or uses a Clinical Editing Database in connection with the
processing of medical claims for payment. For purposes of this
Agreement, and without limiting the foregoing, software that does
not include or use a Clinical Editing Database shall not be
considered a Clinical Editing Product even if such software
includes or performs code validation and/or duplicate code
functionality.
1.3 Covered Products . The terms "Covered Facets
Product," "Covered QicLink Product," and "Covered ClaimFacts
Product" (collectively, "Covered Products") refer to any version of
Facets, QicLink, or ClaimFacts (including successor products
thereto), respectively, that contains a TriZetto Clinical Editing
Product.
3
-
1.4 Enhancements . Modifications,
revisions, additions, or supplements to a TriZetto Clinical Editing
Product (including, without limitation, its Clinical Editing
Database) which enables the TriZetto Clinical Editing Product to
provide or perform material services or functions it could not
previously perform, or materially improves the manner in which the
TriZetto Clinical Editing Product performs existing functions.
Enhancements shall not include updates to a TriZetto Clinical
Editing Product that are made to stay current with industry coding
changes (e.g., changes to the CPT and ICD codes and/or rules),
regulatory requirements, as well as other minor upgrades, minor
improvements, and/or fixes to such Product. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, the term Enhancements shall include any modification,
revision, addition or supplementation to a TriZetto Clinical
Editing Product that results in the addition, incorporation,
inclusion or use of any part of or functionality from a
non-TriZetto Clinical Editing Product, including, without
limitation, its source code and/or some or all of the contents of
its Clinical Editing Database.
1.5 Existing TriZetto Customer . This definition includes
two categories of customers: (1) any and all ClaimFacts,
QicLink or Facets customers that have acquired rights as of the
Effective Date to use ClaimFacts, QicLink, or Facets on a licensed
and/or hosted basis; and (2) any prospective customer of
ClaimFacts, QicLink, or Facets that is included in a TriZetto sales
cycle as of the Effective Date and which customer enters into a
license and/or hosting agreement for ClaimFacts, QicLink, or Facets
with TriZetto on or prior to October 31, 2006. The customers
in the first category are identified on Exhibit 1 hereto, and
prospective customers included in a TriZetto sales cycle as of the
Effective Date are identified on Exhibit 2 hereto. Exhibit 2
of this Agreement shall be replaced by a final list of customers in
the second category that will be provided by TriZetto to McKesson
no later than November 30, 2006. When
4
-
referring to Existing TriZetto Customers of a
particular product, such customers shall be referred to as Existing
ClaimFacts Customers (in the case of ClaimFacts), Existing Facets
Customers (in the case of Facets), and Existing QicLink Customers
(in the case of QicLink).
1.6 Facets-ClaimCheck Interface . The software that
enables transmission of data between Facets and ClaimCheck
(including ClaimReview).
1.7 McKesson Products . McKesson’s products known
individually as ClaimCheck, ClaimReview, Clear Claim Connection,
and ClaimsXten; provided, however, that ClaimsXten shall be
included in the definition of McKesson Products only in the event
that an interface is developed by TriZetto as set forth in
Section 5.2 of this Agreement.
1.8 Net Licensing Revenue . The money actually received
by TriZetto for licensing (including on a hosted basis) a Covered
QicLink Product or Covered Facets Product. Net Licensing Revenue
includes only base QicLink or Facets license fees actually paid by
customers to TriZetto; i.e., Net Licensing Revenue shall include
fees paid by customers to use and access the Covered Products
(including access provided on a hosted basis), but not fees paid
for other products and services provided by TriZetto, including the
portion of hosted services related to the provision of servers,
equipment and other infrastructure. For purposes of clarification
only, and not as a limitation, Net Licensing Revenue does not
include fees or expenses paid by customers for (i) other
products offered by TriZetto, such as Sybase, NetworX, Workflow,
and/or Care Advance Enterprise, or (ii) any services provided
by TriZetto, such as hosting, support, consulting, and/or
maintenance services. For purposes of this Agreement, fees or
expenses for hosting services provided by TriZetto excludes fees
for licensing a Covered QicLink Product or Covered Facets Product
on a hosted basis.
5
-
1.9 New Facets or ClaimFacts Customer. Any
customer that is sold Facets or ClaimFacts on a licensed and/or
hosted basis during the Term and that is not an Existing Facets or
ClaimFacts Customer or a Small Facets Customer.
1.10 New QicLink Customer . Any customer that is sold
QicLink on a licensed and/or hosted basis during the Term and that
is not an Existing QicLink Customer.
1.11 Term . The period commencing on the Effective Date
and ending on October 12, 2010, unless the Agreement is
terminated earlier as permitted herein. This Agreement and all the
rights and obligations set forth herein shall remain in effect
notwithstanding that the ‘164 Patent may be held invalid
and/or unenforceable in any other proceeding at a later date.
1.12 Small Facets Customer . Any customer other than an
Existing Facets Customer that, at the time of first contracting
with TriZetto, contracts to use Facets for only those of its
affiliates, divisions and/or product lines with aggregate
membership at such time of 100,000 active medical lives or less. If
a customer subsequently modifies its initial contract with TriZetto
to allow for the use of Facets by additional affiliates, divisions
and/or product lines, and the total membership of all such
contracted affiliates, divisions and/or product lines exceeds
100,000 active medical lives at the time of such modification, then
none of the additional affiliates, divisions and/or product lines
will be deemed to be a Small Facets Customer.
1.13 TriZetto Clinical Editing Product . A Clinical
Editing Product developed by TriZetto, including, without
limitation, ClinicaLogic (also sometimes referred to as, among
other things, Clinical Editing, Clinical Editor, and Clinical
Edits). In the event TriZetto assigns or otherwise transfers this
Agreement pursuant to Section 2.3(b) below, the term TriZetto
Clinical Editing Product shall be limited to those TriZetto
Clinical Editing Products that existed
6
-
prior to said assignment or transfer and shall
not include any Clinical Editing Product owned by the assignee or
transferee at the time of the assignment or transfer or thereafter
acquired or developed by said assignee or transferee.
1.14 ‘164 Patent . The ‘164 patent as well as
all foreign counterparts, continuations, divisionals, reexams, and
reissues thereof, if any.
|
|
2.
|
License Grant and
Royalties
|
-
2.1 In exchange for the promises, covenants, and
obligations set forth in this Agreement, TriZetto will pay McKesson
a one-time royalty fee of fifteen million dollars ($15,000,000)
(the "Upfront Royalty Fee") to license the ‘164 Patent with
respect to all TriZetto’s sales of ClaimFacts, Facets, and
QicLink as permitted herein. The Upfront Royalty Fee shall be
payable in two equal installments of $7,500,000 each, the first to
be paid by September 30, 2006, and the second to be paid by
September 30, 2007.
2.2 (a) McKesson hereby grants to TriZetto a non-exclusive,
non-transferable (except as provided herein), non-assignable
(except as provided herein), and non-sublicensable license under
the ‘164 Patent to make, have made, use, import, license,
sell, lease, offer for sale, support, host, maintain, and otherwise
transfer within the United States and its territories
(i) Covered ClaimFacts, Facets, and QicLink Products to or for
Existing ClaimFacts, Facets, and QicLink Customers;
(ii) Covered Facets Products to or for Small Facets Customers;
and (iii) Covered QicLink Products to or for New QicLink
Customers; and
2.2 (b) McKesson hereby grants a non-transferable (except
as provided herein), non-assignable (except as provided herein),
non-sublicensable and non-exclusive license under the ‘164
Patent within the United States and its territories to
(i) Existing ClaimFacts, Facets, and QicLink Customers to use
Covered ClaimFacts, Facets, and QicLink Products; (ii)
7
-
Small Facets Customers to use Covered Facets
Products; and (iii) New QicLink Customers to use Covered
QicLink Products.
2.3 (a) The licenses set forth in Section 2.2(b) are
non-assignable and non-transferable by TriZetto’s customers
except (i) with the prior written consent of McKesson which
shall not be unreasonably withheld; (ii) in connection with
the sale of all or substantially all of the stock or assets of a
TriZetto Customer; or (iii) to a purchaser of all or
substantially all of the assets of the business relating to the
license. By way of clarification, and not as a limitation, if an
Existing TriZetto Customer sells the business that is utilizing a
licensed TriZetto product for the processing of medical claims for
payments, such license shall be transferable and/or assignable to
the purchaser of such Customer’s business.
2.3 (b) This Agreement is assignable and transferable by
TriZetto (i) with the prior written consent of McKesson which
shall not be unreasonably withheld; (ii) in connection with
the sale of all or substantially all of the stock or assets of
TriZetto; or (iii) to a purchaser of all or substantially all
of the assets of the TriZetto business relating to the Agreement.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, this Agreement is not assignable and
not transferable by TriZetto to Ingenix, Inc. or iHealth
Technologies, Inc., including their respective parents,
subsidiaries, affiliates, successors and assigns (each, a
"Restricted Transferee"), under any circumstances. In the event a
Restricted Transferee acquires substantially all of the stock or
assets of TriZetto, and TriZetto desires to transfer this Agreement
to such Restricted Transferee, McKesson shall have the option to
consent to or reject such a transfer. If McKesson elects to reject
the transfer, this Agreement shall terminate and the provisions of
Section 9 shall apply. If TriZetto desires to transfer this
Agreement to such Restricted Transferee, TriZetto shall give
McKesson written notice of its intent to transfer the Agreement.
Within 15 calendar days of its
8
-
receipt of such notice, McKesson shall give
TriZetto written notice of its election to consent to or reject the
transfer. If McKesson does not respond within said 15 days,
TriZetto will give McKesson a second written notice. If McKesson
does not provide TriZetto with its written election within 15
calendar days after the second notice, it will be deemed to have
rejected the transfer and this Agreement will terminate and the
provisions of Section 9 shall apply. In connection with an
assignment or other transfer of this Agreement by TriZetto under
this Section 2.3(b), the assignee or transferee must expressly
assume in writing all of TriZetto’s obligations hereunder.
This Agreement is assignable and transferable by McKesson
(i) with TriZetto’s prior written consent, which shall
not be unreasonably withheld; (ii) in connection with the sale
of all or substantially all of the stock or assets of McKesson;
(iii) to a purchaser of all or substantially all of the assets
of the McKesson business relating to this Agreement; or
(iv) to any direct or indirect wholly owned subsidiary of
McKesson Corporation including McKesson Health Solutions,
LLC.
2.4 As of the Effective Date, TriZetto (i) shall not sell
or offer for sale on a licensed and/or hosted basis any TriZetto
Clinical Editing Product (whether alone or with another product) to
any New ClaimFacts or New Facets Customer within the United States
of America and its territories; and (ii) shall remove any
TriZetto Clinical Editing Product from any version of ClaimFacts or
Facets (or any product that replaces Facets) that is sold on a
licensed and/or hosted basis to any such New Facets or New
ClaimFacts Customer within the United States of America or its
territories. Such removal shall be performed prior to the delivery
of ClaimFacts or Facets to the New Facets or New ClaimFacts
Customer. This Section 2.4 shall not preclude TriZetto from
selling or licensing Facets with a TriZetto Clinical Editing
Product to an Existing ClaimFacts Customer if that Customer was
licensed to use ClinicaLogic as of the date
9
-
of this Agreement, and the royalty fee in
Section 2.5 shall not apply to any such sales or licenses.
Nothing in this Agreement shall preclude Existing ClaimFacts or
QicLink Customers who convert to Facets from electing to license
ClaimCheck or ClaimsXten.
2.5 In addition to the Upfront Royalty Fee, in the event that
TriZetto (whether on its own or through its vendor, distributor,
partner, subsidiary, agent, or other representative) transfers,
sells, hosts, or licenses a Covered Facets Product to a Small
Facets Customer or a Covered QicLink Product to a New QicLink
Customer, TriZetto will pay McKesson a royalty of five percent
(5%) of the Net Licensing Revenue from such Small Facets
Customer or New QicLink Customer. Such royalties will be payable
within forty-five (45) days after the close of the calendar
quarter in which such Net Licensing Revenue is actually received by
TriZetto.
2.6 During the Term, TriZetto agrees that it will not make any
Enhancements to any TriZetto Clinical Editing Product.
2.7 Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement,
nothing in this Agreement shall preclude TriZetto from making,
having made, using, importing, licensing, selling, leasing,
offering for sale, supporting, hosting, maintaining, and otherwise
transferring any version of Facets that does not include a Clinical
Editing Product. In the event TriZetto does sell versions of Facets
described in this Section 2.7, McKesson shall not be entitled
to any portion of the resulting revenue received from such
customer(s).
2.8 All royalty payments hereunder shall be noncreditable and
nonrefundable, except in connection with an overpayment of such
royalties. All royalty payments hereunder shall be in United States
dollars in immediately available funds and shall be made by wire
transfer to such bank account as may be designated from time to
time by McKesson.
10
-
2.9 If TriZetto fails to timely make any payment
due to McKesson under this Agreement, then interest shall accrue on
a daily basis at a compound annual rate of ten percent
(10%) or at the maximum rate permitted by applicable law,
whichever is lower, thirty (30) days from the time the payment
was due until the time the payment is made.
2.10 Other than the licenses granted in this Section 2 of
this Agreement, nothing in this Agreement shall grant to TriZetto,
its customers, or any other person, by implication, estoppel, or
otherwise, any right or license to the ‘164 Patent in
general, or any other intellectual property rights owned by
McKesson.
2.11 TriZetto shall mark any new versions of the Covered
Products with the word "Patent" or the abbreviation "Pat.," and the
full number of the ‘164 patent (or, if marking the Covered
Products cannot be done, by affixing to the Covered Products or
their packaging a label with such information). All such versions
of Covered Products shall be marked permanently and legibly in the
manner as reasonably practical and directed by McKesson. Within
sixty (60) days of the Effective Date or the release of any
new version of a Covered Product (whichever is sooner), TriZetto
shall certify to McKesson in writing that it has complied with this
Section 2.11.
2.12 The Parties grant each other limited permission to use the
trademarks of the other Party solely to identify themselves as
working with the other Party pursuant to this Agreement and to
advertise and promote the McKesson Products, the Facets-ClaimCheck
Interface, and (if applicable) the Facets-ClaimsXten Interface to
New and Existing Facets Customers. Each Party shall provide to the
other Party a sample of any proposed use of the other Party’s
trademarks pursuant to this Section prior to such use. If the other
Party objects to such
11
-
use, said Party must provide its objection and/or
any proposed revisions to the Party proposing such use within
fifteen (15) business days of service.
2.13 THE LICENSES GRANTED HEREUNDER BY MCKESSON ARE PROVIDED
WITHOUT WARRANTY OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR
PURPOSE OR ANY OTHER WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED. EXCEPT AS SET
FORTH IN THIS AGREEMENT, MCKESSON MAKES NO WARRANTY THAT
TRIZETTO’S ACTIVITIES UNDER SAID LICENSES WILL NOT INFRINGE
ANY PATENT OR OTHER PROPRIETARY RIGHT. MCKESSON WILL NOT BE LIABLE
FOR ANY SUCH INFRINGEMENT, OR ALLEGATION THEREOF.
2.14 EXCEPT AS SET FORTH IN THIS AGREEMENT, NEITHER PARTY SHALL
BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER PARTY, ITS CUSTOMERS, THE USERS OF ANY
PRODUCT, OR ANY THIRD PARTIES FOR INDIRECT, SPECIAL, CONSEQUENTIAL,
OR PUNITIVE DAMAGES, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY DAMAGE OR
INJURY TO BUSINESS EARNINGS, PROFITS, OR GOODWILL SUFFERED BY ANY
PERSON ARISING FROM ANY BREACH OF THIS AGREEMENT OR WARRANTY
THEREIN, ANY EXERCISE OF RIGHTS UNDER THIS AGREEMENT, OR ANY USE OF
THE ‘164 PATENT OR ANY PRODUCT, IN EACH CASE EVEN IF SUCH
PARTY IS ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE OR INJURY.
2.15 TriZetto shall keep and maintain proper books and records
as are required accurately to determine the royalties payable to
McKesson for two (2) years following the calendar quarter on
which such royalties were paid or reported. Once a year, and upon a
two-week written notice to TriZetto, McKesson may have an
independent third-party accountant, at McKesson’s expense,
examine TriZetto’s books and records solely for the purpose
of verifying
12
-
the accuracy of royalties paid or reported by
TriZetto. TriZetto shall assist the accountant in conducting such
examination, without charge, and shall make such documents
available for inspection and copying, shall make TriZetto’s
personnel available for interviews, and shall make TriZetto’s
facilities available for inspection as may be reasonably necessary
to allow the accountant to perform the examination. If such
examination reveals an underpayment by TriZetto, then TriZetto
shall promptly make up such underpayment with interest pursuant to
Section 2.8, and, if the underpayment exceeds ten percent
(10%) of the amount actually owed to McKesson under this
Agreement during the period under examination, TriZetto shall
reimburse McKesson for the actual cost of the examination. If such
examination reveals an overpayment by TriZetto, then McKesson shall
promptly refund such overpayment without interest to
TriZetto.
2.16 As part of each royalty payment made pursuant to
Section 2.5, TriZetto shall provide McKesson with a quarterly
report identifying each product sold and the date of such sale. If
any Net Licensing Revenue has been received by TriZetto for such
sale, the report shall also identify the amount of such Revenue and
the date on which TriZetto received such Revenue.
2.17 Each Party receiving monies under this Agreement shall be
solely responsible for all withholding, sales, use, excise and
property taxes, and all duties, levies and assessments (other than
those based on the net income of the other paying Party) imposed
with respect to such receiving Party’s receipt of payments
pursuant to this Agreement.
|
|
3.
|
Promotion of McKesson Products to TriZetto
Customers
|
13
-
will have no obligation to promote McKesson
Products to ClaimFacts, QicLink or Small Facets Customers, unless
such customers become Facets Customers.
3.2 Provided that TriZetto is in compliance with its obligations
set forth in this Agreement, including Sections 2.4, 3, 4 and 5,
TriZetto bears no responsibility and incurs no liability for the
decision made by any TriZetto customer to purchase or license a
Clinical Editing Product from any third-party source.
3.3 TriZetto will not be entitled to share any revenue derived
by McKesson relating to McKesson Products, including revenue
derived as a result of any sale or license of McKesson Products to
any TriZetto customers, provided however, that TriZetto may charge
reasonable, standard and customary fees to license and support the
Facets-ClaimCheck Interface and (if applicable) the
Facets-ClaimsXten Interface for any Existing TriZetto Customer that
acquires ClaimCheck or ClaimsXten.
3.4 McKesson agrees that all fees and service charges charged to
any Facets customer for the sale or license of a McKesson Product
will be consistent with the fees and services generally charged and
provided to similar non-TriZetto customers.
3.5 McKesson will be solely responsible for all selling,
contracting and collection efforts associated with the sales of
McKesson Products to Facets customers.
3.6 As of the Effective Date, McKesson will become a TriZetto
"Preferred Alliance Partner." As a "Preferred Alliance Partner,"
McKesson shall be invited and provided a bona fide
opportunity to exhibit McKesson Products at TriZetto’s annual
payor conference at TriZetto’s standard exhibition cost,
which may vary based upon level of customer exposure and publicity
sought by McKesson. Such costs shall be payable by McKesson in
accordance with TriZetto’s standard exhibitor payment
policy.
14
-
3.7 This Agreement shall not affect the four
current TriZetto customers that use ClaimCheck as of the Effective
Date; the Parties shall continue their current relationship and
practices with regard to those four customers. All interfaces
developed under this Agreement will, however, be made available to
those customers.
|
|
4.
|
TriZetto Promotional
Efforts
|
|