|
Exhibit 10.41
Confidential treatment has been requested for portions of this
exhibit. The copy filed herewith omits the information subject to
the confidentiality request. Omissions are designated as [*]. A
complete version of this exhibit has been filed separately with the
Securities and Exchange Commission.
LICENSE AGREEMENT
This License Agreement is made and entered into simultaneously
with the accompanying Settlement Agreement as of the Effective Date
by and among the following:
CIBA Vision AG, a Swiss corporation, with its principal place of
business at Hardhofstrasse 15, CH-8424 Embrach, Switzerland;
CIBA Vision Corporation, a Delaware corporation, having its
headquarters at 11460 Johns Creek Parkway, Duluth, Georgia
30097-1518; and
CooperVision, Inc., a New York corporation, having headquarters
at 6140 Stoneridge Mall Road, Suite 590, Pleasanton, California
94588-3772.
WITNESSETH
WHEREAS, the Parties are involved in various legal disputes
relating to intellectual property rights and the enforcement
thereof;
WHEREAS, CooperVision acknowledges that there was a long felt
need in the Contact Lens industry dating back to at least the 1970s
to develop an ophthalmically compatible, high oxygen permeability
silicone hydrogel Contact Lens suitable for extended wear;
WHEREAS, CooperVision further acknowledges that for more than
two decades, numerous researchers in the Contact Lens field sought
to develop extended wear silicone hydrogel Contact Lenses without
success;
WHEREAS, CooperVision further acknowledges that Contact Lenses
made from CIBA’s lotrafilcon A material represent the first
successful silicone hydrogel Contact Lenses suitable for extended
wear;
WHEREAS, CooperVision further acknowledges that CIBA’s
development of silicone hydrogel Contact Lenses represent a
breakthrough in Contact Lens technology and is a pioneering
invention in the Contact Lens field;
WHEREAS, CooperVision further acknowledges that CIBA’s
patent rights asserted in the various legal disputes are valid and
enforceable; and
WHEREAS, CIBA further acknowledges that CooperVision’s
patent rights asserted in the various legal disputes are valid and
enforceable;
NOW, THEREFORE, the Parties hereby agree as
follows:
ARTICLE I – DEFINITIONS
1.01 "Affiliate" shall mean any Person that, on or after
the Effective Date, directly or indirectly controls, is controlled
by, or is under common control with another Person. As used in this
definition, "control" shall mean direct or indirect ownership of,
or other beneficial interest in, at least fifty percent
(50%) of the voting stock, other voting interest, or income of
such Person. A Person shall be an Affiliate only during the period
of time that such Person meets the definition set forth in this
Section 1.01, and shall have no rights or obligations under
this Agreement if and when such Person ceases to be an
Affiliate.
1.02 "Biomedics Toric" shall mean the cast molded Contact
Lens for treating astigmatism currently marketed by CooperVision
under the trade name "Biomedics ® Toric" comprising forty-five
(45) percent ocufilcon D and fifty-five (55) percent
water.
1.03 "CIBA" shall mean CIBA Vision AG, corporation
organized and existing under the laws of Switzerland, having its
principal place of business at Hardhofstrasse 15, CH-8424 Embrach,
Switzerland; and CIBA Vision Corporation, a corporation organized
and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, having its
headquarters at 11460 Johns Creek Parkway, Duluth, Georgia
30097-1556.
1.04 "CIBA Licensed Products" shall mean all Contact
Lenses (including, but not limited to, O 2 Optix/AIROptix spherical and
toric Contact Lenses), Contact Lens molds, and tools for making
Contact Lens molds that (i) in the absence of the license
granted under this Agreement would infringe at least one Valid
Claim of the CooperVision Patent Rights; or (ii) are made
using a process or machine that, in the absence of the license
granted under this Agreement, would infringe at least one Valid
Claim of the CooperVision Patent Rights; provided, however, that
CIBA Licensed Products shall not encompass or include:
[*]
1.05 "CIBA Patent Rights" shall mean United States Patent
Nos. 5,760,100; 5,789,461; 5,849,811; 5,766,999; 5,965,631; and
6,951,894; all other patents and patent applications in all
countries of the world corresponding thereto, having priority
derived therefrom; all divisional, continuation and
continuation-in-part applications derived from any of the above
applications or patents; all patents issuing as a result of the
above patent applications; and all patents of addition, reissues,
reexaminations, and extensions of any of the above patents.
|
[*]
|
Certain information on this page
has been omitted and filed separately with the Securities and
Exchange Commission. Confidential treatment has been requested with
respect to the omitted portions.
|
2
1.06 "Contact Lens" shall mean a lens
designed for placement on the cornea of the eye above the
epithelium. Contact Lens shall not include solutions for and/or
methods for cleaning, disinfecting, or conditioning Contact Lenses;
or a lens designed to be surgically implanted in the eye below the
epithelium.
1.07 "CooperVision" shall mean CooperVision, Inc., a
corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of
New York, having its headquarters at 6140 Stoneridge Mall Road,
Suite 590, Pleasanton, California 94588-3772.
1.08 "CooperVision Licensed Products" shall mean all
Contact Lenses (including, but not limited to, Contact Lenses made
from comfilcon A and CooperVision’s forthcoming Dk100
product), Contact Lens molds, and tools for making Contact Lens
molds that (i) in the absence of the license granted under
this Agreement would infringe at least one Valid Claim of the CIBA
Patent Rights; or (ii) are made using a process or machine
that, in the absence of the license granted under this Agreement,
would infringe at least one Valid Claim of the CIBA Patent Rights;
provided, however, that CooperVision Licensed Products shall not
encompass or include: [*]
1.09 "CooperVision Patent Rights" shall mean United
States Patent Nos. 6,923,538; 6,431,706; 6,467,903; 6,857,740;
6,971,746; 7,133,174; and 7,134,753; all other patents and patent
applications in all countries of the world corresponding thereto,
having priority derived therefrom; all divisional, continuation and
continuation-in-part applications derived from any of the above
applications or patents; all patents issuing as a result of the
above patent applications; and all patents of addition, reissues,
reexaminations, and extensions of any of the above patents.
1.10 "Effective Date" shall mean November 19,
2007.
1.11 "Final Judgment" shall mean a judgment, order, or
decree entered by a court, tribunal, agency, or governmental entity
that becomes not further reviewable through the exhaustion of all
permissible applications for rehearing or review by a superior
body, or through the expiration of time permitted for such
applications.
1.12 "Financial Terms" shall mean [*].
1.13 "Future Agreement" shall mean an agreement made
after the Effective Date that grants a license under any of the
CIBA Patent Rights for products competitive with the CooperVision
Licensed Products.
|
[*]
|
Certain information on this page
has been omitted and filed separately with the Securities and
Exchange Commission. Confidential treatment has been requested with
respect to the omitted portions.
|
3
1.14 [*] .
1.15 [*].
1.16 "Licensed Products" shall mean CooperVision Licensed
Products and CIBA Licensed Products.
1.17 "Net Sales" shall mean the [*] where a CooperVision
Licensed Product is sold or commercially disposed of for value in
an arm’s length transaction with a Third Party in any
geographic location.
|
|
(a)
|
As used in this definition,
[*].
|
|
|
(b)
|
Notwithstanding any other provision
of this Section 1.17, Net Sales shall not include
[*].
|
|
|
(c)
|
The sale of a single unit of
CooperVision Licensed Product may be considered only once in
calculating Net Sales.
|
1.18 "Party" shall mean CIBA or
CooperVision, and when used in the plural shall mean both of
them.
1.19 "Patent Rights" shall mean the CIBA Patent Rights
and the CooperVision Patent Rights.
1.20 "Person" shall mean an individual, trust,
corporation, partnership, joint venture, limited liability company,
association, unincorporated organization or other legal or
governmental entity.
1.21 "Third Party" shall mean a Person other than a Party
or any of such Party’s Affiliates.
1.22 "Valid Claim" shall mean a claim of an unexpired,
issued patent falling within the definition of Patent Rights that
has not been abandoned, disclaimed, or donated to the public, or
held unenforceable, not patentable, or invalid by a decision of a
court, tribunal, agency, or other governmental entity of competent
jurisdiction as to which all appeals (if available) have been
exhausted or the time to appeal has expired.
|
[*]
|
Certain information on this page
has been omitted and filed separately with the Securities and
Exchange Commission. Confidential treatment has been requested with
respect to the omitted portions.
|
4
ARTICLE II – GRANTS OF
LICENSES
2.01 By CIBA . CIBA, on behalf of itself and its
Affiliates, hereby grants to CooperVision and its Affiliates a
royalty bearing, irrevocable, worldwide, non-exclusive license,
with no right to sublicense, under the CIBA Patent Rights to make,
have made, import, export, use, sell, and offer to sell
CooperVision Licensed Products. The license granted to an Affiliate
of CooperVision shall terminate if and when such Person ceases to
be an Affiliate of CooperVision under this Agreement.
2.02 By CooperVision . CooperVision, on behalf of
itself and its Affiliates, hereby grants to CIBA and its Affiliates
a [*] worldwide, irrevocable, non-exclusive license, with no
right to sublicense, under the CooperVision Patent Rights to make,
have made, import, export, use, sell, and offer to sell CIBA
Licensed Products. The license granted to an Affiliate of CIBA
shall terminate if and when such Person ceases to be an Affiliate
of CIBA under this Agreement. [*].
2.03 License Registration and Recordal .
Notwithstanding the generality of the restrictions imposed by
Article V, either Party shall have the right, at its sole cost and
expense, to register, record and otherwise document the license
granted under this Agreement in any country. Each Party agrees to
take, at the other Party’s sole cost and expense, all steps
reasonably requested by the first Party, including but not limited
to executing a "short form" license, to effect the foregoing
registration, recordal or other documentation in any country. A
Party may record such short form license, but no short form license
shall in any way alter or otherwise affect the rights and
obligations of the Parties hereunder, and in the event of any
inconsistency, this Agreement shall controls.
ARTICLE III – PAYMENTS
3.01 Royalties. In consideration of the settlement of
litigation and rights granted herein, CooperVision shall pay
royalties to CIBA Vision AG during the term of this Agreement of
[*] of the Net Sales of CooperVision Licensed Products; said
royalties being understood and deemed to constitute a reasonable
net valuation of the license rights and other consideration granted
to CooperVision under this Agreement and the accompanying
Settlement Agreement. Royalties shall be payable in United States
Dollars on a quarterly basis and shall be due within sixty
(60) days following the end of each of CooperVision’s
fiscal quarters. CooperVision shall have no obligation to pay
royalties on the Net Sales of any Contact Lens unless it is made
and/or sold in a country where a Valid Claim of the CIBA Patent
Rights exists, which Valid Claim is or has been infringed by
CooperVision with respect to such Contact Lens. For purposes of
determining CooperVision’s royalty obligation under this
Section 3.01, CooperVision shall not be deemed to have
infringed a Valid Claim of the CIBA Patent Rights in any country
merely by transporting Contact Lenses through such country.
|
[*]
|
Certain information on this page
has been omitted and filed separately with the Securities and
Exchange Commission. Confidential treatment has been requested with
respect to the omitted portions.
|
5
3.02 Bundled Products. If
CooperVision Licensed Products are sold in a single bundled sale
(including a single invoice or transaction) with non-licensed
products, the sales price of CooperVision’s Licensed
Products, for the purposes of calculating the royalty due, shall
[*] .
3.03 Reports. CooperVision shall report
accrued royalties due under Section 3.01 to CIBA Vision AG
(with a copy to CIBA Vision Corporation) by submitting a written
report with its payments to the addresses in Article IX. Each such
report shall include a computation of the royalties accrued during
that fiscal quarter, including the trade designation of each
CooperVision Licensed Product sold; the Net Sales applicable to
each such product in each country; a computation of the total
royalties for the quarter using the applicable royalty rate
(including the currency exchange rates used in such calculations
pursuant to Section 3.05); and any credit against royalties
due CooperVision for returns. An authorized representative of
CooperVision shall certify that such report is computed in
compliance with the contractual requirements of this Agreement.
CooperVision shall pay interest to CIBA Vision AG at the [*] on all
royalties not paid when due. In the event past due royalties, found
by an arbitrator to be due and payable, are collected through
bankruptcy or judicial proceedings by an attorney or placed in the
hands of an attorney for collection, CooperVision shall pay
CIBA’s reasonable attorneys’ fees and other costs of
collection.
3.04 Records and Inspection. CooperVision
shall keep true and accurate records, files, and books of account
containing all data reasonably required for the full computation
and verification of the royalties to be paid and the information to
be given in accompanying reports. Independent certified public
accountants (as chosen by CIBA), upon written request by CIBA to
CooperVision, shall be entitled at CIBA’s sole cost and
expense to inspect pertinent books and records of CooperVision in
Rochester, New York (or such other reasonable location in the
United States that CooperVision may designate), once each calendar
year to determine the accuracy and completeness of any royalty
report made to CIBA. Prior to commencing the inspection, the
independent certified public accountants shall sign a
confidentiality agreement reasonably acceptable to CooperVision. In
the event such inspection reveals any discrepancy between the
royalties actually paid by CooperVision during the period covered
by the examination and the amount actually due under this
Agreement, CooperVision shall pay to CIBA Vision AG the undisputed
amount of such discrepancy in the case of an underpayment and CIBA
Vision AG shall reimburse CooperVision the undisputed amount of the
discrepancy in the event of an overpayment. The independent
certified public accountants shall provide a written statement to
CooperVision describing the findings and the rationale by which any
underpayment was determined. In the event an underpayment
represents ten percent (10%) or
|
[*]
|
Certain information on this page
has been omitted and filed separately with the Securities and
Exchange Commission. Confident
|
|