Confidential
portions of this exhibit have been omitted and filed separately
with the Securities and Exchange Commission with a request for
confidential treatment pursuant to Rule 24b-2 under the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. The location of an omitted
portion is indicated by an asterisk within brackets
(“[*]”).
MASTER MERIAL VENTURE
AGREEMENT
DATED as of
May 23, 1997, BY AND AMONG:
RHÔNE-POULENC S.A., a société
anonyme organized under the laws of France
(“Rhône-Poulenc”),
INSTITUT
MÉRIEUX S.A., a société anonyme organized
under the laws of France (“IM”),
RHÔNE-MÉRIEUX S.A., a
société anonyme organized under the laws of France
(“RM”),
MERCK &
CO., INC., a corporation organized under the laws of the state of
New Jersey (“Merck & Co.”),
MERCK SH INC.,
a corporation organized under the laws of the state of Delaware
(“Merck SH”), and
MERIAL LIMITED,
an English private company limited by shares (and, after the
domestication contemplated by Section 1.3(a)(B), also a
Delaware limited liability company)
(“Merial”).
WHEREAS, both the
RP Group and the Merck Group are engaged, among other activities,
in the research and development, manufacturing, marketing
and sale of Animal Health Products and of Poultry Genetics Products
throughout the world;
WHEREAS, RP and
Merck wish to combine their respective Animal Health Businesses and
Poultry Genetics Businesses into a worldwide venture owned and
controlled 50% by each of them and IM has created Merial as the
parent company of the group of companies which will conduct these
businesses;
WHEREAS, IM will
contribute the entirety of RM’s share capital to Merial on or
prior to the Closing Date;
WHEREAS, RP,
Merck, and certain of their respective Subsidiaries, on the one
hand, and RM or an RM Subsidiary or Merial, on the other hand, have
entered into or will, prior to or concurrently with the Closing,
enter into the Ancillary Agreements, including research and
development, manufacturing and supply, license and various other
agreements to enable the Merial Venture to conduct these combined
activities;
WHEREAS, the terms
and conditions of this Agreement and the Ancillary Agreements do
not limit Merial’s (and Merial has) full independence and
commercial autonomy, such terms and conditions not being intended
to limit Merial’s independence and commercial autonomy in
marketing, selling, negotiating and determining customers and
resale prices for Animal Health Products and Poultry Genetics
Products.
WHEREAS, prior to
or at the Closing, pursuant to the terms of this Agreement and the
applicable Ancillary Agreements, the Parties will take further
steps to implement the Merial Venture, including the domestication
of Merial as a limited liability company in the State of Delaware,
and the transfer (by merger or otherwise) to Merial and/or its
Subsidiaries of the entirety of the Merck Contributed Assets;
and
2
WHEREAS, upon
completion of the Transactions at the Closing, the Merial Venture
will commence the Merial Venture Business and IM and (subject to
Section 5.1(a)(iii)) Merck SH will each hold a 50% ownership
interest in Merial;
NOW, THEREFORE, in
consideration of the respective representations and covenants of
the Parties as set forth below, the Parties agree as
follows:
OBJECTIVES AND STRATEGIES,
BUSINESS SCOPE
AND OVERVIEW OF TRANSACTION
SECTION 1.1.
Objectives and Strategies
The Merial Venture
is being formed with the following objectives and
strategies:
(a) The
principal objective of the Merial Venture is to combine, on the
terms and conditions of this Agreement and the Ancillary
Agreements, the complementary strengths of the RP Group and the
Merck Group to create a global leader in the Animal Health Business
and Poultry Genetics Business industries, committed to satisfying
the needs of its customers, employees and members worldwide. Within
the Merial Venture, the Animal Health Business and the Poultry
Genetics Business will maintain their own identity and
organization.
(b) While
maintaining close links with both Groups, the Merial Venture will
function as a self-contained independent entity with a single
globally responsible management and will establish its own unique
identity and culture, built on the best available talents and
practices.
(c) In the
Animal Health Business, the Merial Venture will, with the support
of the research and development capacities of the two Groups and/or
other persons party to the Ancillary Agreements (on the terms and
conditions of this Agreement and the
3
Ancillary
Agreements), have a unique blend of biological and pharmaceutical
expertise that will enable it to respond more effectively to new
threats to animal health as they arise. In cooperation with both
Groups, which are expected to remain important sources of new
compounds and technologies, the objective of the Merial Venture
will be to discover and develop a broad range of innovative
pharmaceutical and biological Animal Health Products.
(d) The
Merial Venture will offer a broad differentiated line of Animal
Health Products and related services in markets around the world.
It will target those markets where products for the prevention and
treatment of animal diseases provide the economic opportunity to
sustain innovation and yield sufficient return on investment. The
Merial Venture will distribute its products in a manner which best
meets the strategic needs of each market.
(e) The
Merial Venture will maintain its position as a global leader
through continued investment in new markets, technologies, people
and facilities with the objective, among other things, of
delivering the highest quality products in the most cost efficient
manner.
(f) In the
Poultry Genetics Business, the Merial Venture will be the leader in
the development and production of poultry breeding stock providing
full service to the chicken, turkey and egg market
segments.
(g) The
rights, powers, obligations and duties of the Parties with respect
to the Merial Venture are only those set forth in this Agreement
(other than this Section 1.1), the Ancillary Agreements, the
Association Documents and the LLC Agreement, each as amended from
time to time, and any Future Agreements.
SECTION 1.2.
Business Scope
(a) The
business activities to be conducted by the Merial Venture (the
“Merial Venture Business”) will include:
4
|
|
•
|
|
the
discovery and development, manufacturing, marketing and sale of
Animal Health Products throughout the world (the “Animal
Health Business”); and
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
•
|
|
the
discovery and development, manufacturing, marketing and sale of
Poultry Genetics Products throughout the world (the “Poultry
Genetics Business”).
|
(b) “Animal
Health Products” are defined to include all pharmaceutical,
biological and medicinal, including in-feed, products intended to
enhance the health or performance of any and all species of animals
(including livestock and companion animals but excluding humans),
but to exclude (i) any products with a different intended
utility, (ii) nutritional additives, (iii) chemical
intermediates, and (iv) the inhalational anaesthetics
Isoflurane, Halothane, Sevoflurane and Desflurane.
(c) “Poultry
Genetics Products” are defined to include all products
developed using genetic techniques (including selective breeding)
to improve poultry, whether for meat production, egg production or
any other purpose. Such products are commonly, but not exclusively,
sold in the form of hatching eggs or day-old poultry. For the
purposes of this definition, “poultry” includes
chickens, turkeys, ducks, geese, guinea fowl, pheasants, partridges
and quail.
(d) Merial
shall, and shall cause each Merial Venture Company, to use or sell
all bulk materials or products supplied by the Merck Group or the
RP Group only in the Merial Venture Business.
SECTION 1.3.
Overview of Transaction
The Parties intend
to create a viable, independent entity, capable of successfully
competing globally in the Merial Venture Business industries. To
that end, and upon the terms and conditions set forth herein and in
the Ancillary Agreements:
5
Merial has been
formed as an English private company limited by shares for the
purpose of conducting the Merial Venture Business. On the date
hereof Merial is wholly owned by IM and Rhône-Poulenc Finance
S.A., a wholly owned Subsidiary of RP (“RP Finance”),
with IM owning one million shares of Merial and RP Finance holding
one share of Merial as nominee for IM. Merck SH has been created as
a Delaware corporation, and is wholly owned by Merck and Company
Incorporated (“MACI”).
(i) On or prior to
the Closing Date, the Parties shall cause the following corporate
actions to be taken:
(A) IM shall
(w) form a single member Delaware limited liability company
(“IM LLC”) which satisfies the statutory requirements
under French law to be a shareholder of a société par
actions simplifiée (“SAS”), including the
requirement that IM LLC have a share capital of at least the
equivalent of FF 1,500,000; (x) sell one of IM’s shares of RM
to IM LLC and contribute the remainder of IM’s shares of RM
to Merial; (y) cause RM to be converted into a SAS with Merial
and IM LLC as its shareholders; and (z) sell (without any net
profit to IM from all of the transactions contemplated by this
clause (A)) the entirety of its ownership interest in IM LLC to
Merial for an amount in cash equal to the fair market value of such
ownership interest (equal to the cash held by IM LLC and the cash
value of one share of RM);
(B) Merck shall
(u) cause Merck SH and MACI to form a Delaware limited
liability company (“Merck Transitory LLC”) owned 99% by
Merck SH and 1% by MACI; (v) cause Merck Holdings, Inc. to
contribute the entirety of its share capital in Hubbard Farms, Inc.
to MACI; (w) cause MACI to contribute the entirety of the
share capital of Hubbard Farms, Inc. to Merck SH; (x) cause
Hubbard Farms, Inc. to be converted into Hubbard Farms LLC, a
Delaware limited liability company;
6
(y) cause
Merck SH to contribute its interest in Hubbard Farms LLC to Merck
Transitory LLC; and (z) cause Hubbard Farms LLC to be merged with
Merck Transitory LLC, with Merck Transitory LLC being the surviving
company; and
(C) Merck shall,
in accordance with Section 5.1(a)(i), transfer (or cause to be
transferred) the remainder of the Merck Contributed U.S. Assets
(other than the limited liability company interests in Hubbard
Farms LLC) to MACI (except to the extent MACI already holds any
such assets), and shall cause MACI to transfer all of the Merck
Contributed U.S. Assets (other than the limited liability company
interests in Hubbard Farms LLC) to Merck SH, which will in turn
transfer them to Merck Transitory LLC.
(ii) On the
Closing Date, the following steps shall be taken:
(A) Meetings of
the members and directors of Merial at such time shall take place
(v) to amend the memorandum of association and articles of
association of Merial so as to adopt a memorandum of association
and articles of association in the form (with certain provisions
thereof to be completed prior to Closing as indicated therein, it
being understood that to the extent there are any inconsistencies
between the attached form and the provisions of this Agreement, the
attached form shall be modified to be consistent herewith) provided
as Exhibit I hereto (the “Memorandum of
Association” and the “Articles of Association”,
respectively), (w) to approve the domestication of Merial as a
limited liability company in the State of Delaware, (x) to
approve and execute the limited liability company agreement of
Merial in the form provided as Exhibit II hereto, (y) to
approve the merger of Merck Transitory LLC with and into Merial,
and (z) to approve the transfer by RP Finance of its one share
to IM, the increase in the authorized share capital of Merial, the
redesignation of the shares owned by IM as B Ordinary Shares and
the issuance of one million and one A Ordinary Shares to Merck SH
in
7
consideration
for its agreement to transfer the Merck Contributed Assets to
Merial, each such class of Merial shares to be governed by the
provisions of the Association Documents, with the effect that,
after all such actions are taken, each Principal shall own,
directly or indirectly, exactly the same number of Ordinary Shares
of Merial and have exactly the same general ownership interest in
Merial except for the differences between A Ordinary Shares and B
Ordinary Shares as set forth in the Association
Documents;
(B) Merial shall
be domesticated as a limited liability company in the State of
Delaware; and
(C) Merck
Transitory LLC shall merge with and into Merial in accordance with
Delaware Law, with Merial being the survivor company (such that
Merial shall own all of the assets, and be subject to all of the
Liabilities, of Merck Transitory LLC, Merck Transitory LLC
thereupon ceasing to exist).
(i) The following
Ancillary Agreements are being entered into concurrently herewith,
and are conditional upon, and shall come into effect as of, the
Closing:
(A) The Supply
Agreement between Merck and Merial, provided as Exhibit III
hereto (the “Merck Supply Agreement”).
(B) The Research
and Future Products License Agreement between Merck, Merial and RM,
provided as Exhibit IV hereto (the “Merck Research
Agreement”).
8
(C) The Existing
Products License Agreement between Merck and Merial, provided as
Exhibit V hereto (the “Merck License
Agreement”).
(D) The Supply
Agreement between Merial and Rhône-Poulenc Agrochimie S.A.,
provided as Exhibit VI hereto (the “RP Ag Supply
Agreement”).
(E) The Research
and Future Products License Agreement between Merial and
Rhône-Poulenc Agrochimie S.A., provided as Exhibit VII
hereto (the “RP Ag Research Agreement”).
(F) The Fipronil
and Existing Products License Agreement between Merial and
Rhône-Poulenc Agrochimie S.A., provided as Exhibit VIII
hereto (the “RP Ag Licence Agreement”).
(G) The Research
and License Agreement between Merial and Rhône-Poulenc Rorer
Inc., provided as Exhibit IX hereto (the “RPR Research
Agreement”).
(H) The Research
and License Agreement between Merial and Pasteur Mérieux
Sérums et Vaccins S.A., provided as Exhibit X hereto the
“PMSV Research Agreement”).
(ii) The following
Ancillary Agreements shall be negotiated and executed prior to or
at the Closing:
(A) The RP
Transfer Agreement among Merial, RP and IM, to implement the
transactions involving the contribution of RM and its Subsidiaries
and assumption of the RM Contributed Liabilities on the terms and
conditions specified in this Agreement (the “RP Transfer
Agreement”).
9
(B) The Merck
Transfer Agreement among Merial, Merck, MACI, Merck Transitory LLC
and Merck SH, to implement the transactions involving the
contribution of the Merck Contributed Assets and assumption of the
Merck Contributed Liabilities on the terms and conditions specified
in this Agreement (the “Merck Transfer
Agreement”).
(C) The Avermectin
and Existing Products Sublicense Agreement between Merial and
RM.
(D) The Merck
Trademark (Dual Use) License Agreement between Merck and Merial, a
form of which is provided as Exhibit XI hereto.
(E) The Fipronil
Sublicense Agreement between Merial and RM.
(F) The Merck
Transition Services Agreement between Merck and Merial, consistent
with the provisions set forth in Section 11.8(b) of this
Agreement.
(G) The RP
Transition Services Agreement between RP and Merial, consistent
with the provisions set forth in Section 11.8(b) of this
Agreement.
(H) The Merck
Employee Leasing Agreement, substantially in the form provided as
Exhibit XII hereto.
(c)
Contribution of Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets . Merck
shall, in accordance with Sections 5.1 (a)(ii) and 5.2(a) and
the Merck Transfer Agreement, contribute enough cash to Merial ,
and/or accept (or cause its Subsidiaries to accept) a promissory
note or notes issued by Merial or that Merial Venture Company that
is purchasing such assets (which promissory notes constitute part
or all of the Debt that Merck is to contribute to the Merial
Venture), to enable Merial or an appropriate Merial
10
Subsidiary to
purchase each of the Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets in
accordance with Section 5.1(a)(ii). The Principals may also agree,
based on relevant criteria including tax-efficiency, on another
method to transfer certain Merck Non-U.S. Contributed Assets to the
Merial Venture, which method may involve the creation of a new
direct or indirect wholly-owned Subsidiary of Merial which shall
purchase such assets or the transfer or merger of one or more
Subsidiaries of Merck to or with Merial or one of its Subsidiaries.
In the absence of such agreement in writing, but subject to
Section 5.4, the foregoing provisions of this
Section 1.3(c) shall apply.
(d) Each
Party’s obligation to take any of the actions contemplated by
this Section 1.3 to occur on or prior to the Closing Date is
conditioned upon contemporaneous completion of all such actions no
later than the Closing Date.
11
As used in this
Agreement, capitalized terms have the meanings set forth
below:
“Action”
means any claim, action, suit, arbitration, inquiry, proceeding or
investigation by or before any Public Authority.
“Affiliate”
means, with respect to any Person, (i) a Person which is a
Subsidiary of such Person, (ii) a Person of which such Person
is a Subsidiary, or (iii) any other Person which is a
Subsidiary of a third Person of which such Person is also a
Subsidiary.
“Ancillary
Agreements” means, collectively, the agreements referred to
(and as each is defined in) Section 1.3(b).
“Animal
Health Business” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.2(a).
“Animal
Health Products” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.2(b).
“Association
Documents” means, collectively, the Memorandum of Association
and the Articles of Association, each as defined in
Section 1.3(a)(ii)(A), as the same may be amended, modified,
supplemented or restated from time to time.
“Avermectin
Products” means all those Merial Venture Products containing
one of the Avermectin class of compounds, including, but not
limited to, products containing abamectin, ivermectin, eprinomectin
or emamectin.
“Benefit
Plan” means each plan, program, policy, payroll practice,
contract, agreement or other arrangement (including plans
maintained both inside and outside of the U.S. and excluding
Governmental Plans) providing for compensation, severance
(including termination indemnities, long service leave obligations
and similar obligations), termination pay, performance awards,
stock or stock-related awards, fringe benefits or
12
other employee
benefits of any kind, whether formal or informal, funded or
unfunded, written or oral and whether or not legally binding,
including, without limitation, each “employee benefit
plan,” within the meaning of Section 3(3) of ERISA and
each “multi-employer plan” within the meaning of
Sections 3(37) or 4001(a)(3) of ERISA.
“Biological
Products” means all RM Existing or Pipeline Products (other
than diagnostic products, including the products included in the
Diagnostic Disposal) that are vaccines, whether preventive or
therapeutic, as well as any immunological products (except the GnRH
vaccine), together with electronic identification products and
vaccinating equipment, including injectors and sprayers.
“Board of
Directors” has the meaning set forth in
Section 4.3(a).
“Business
Day” means any day which is not a bank holiday in any of
London, New York or Paris.
“Business
Plan” has the meaning set forth in
Section 4.4(c).
“Central
Biologics” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.1(b)(iii).
“CEO”
has the meaning set forth in Section 4.4(e).
“CFM
Agreement” shall refer to the Consolidation Fiscale
Mondiale or worldwide tax consolidation agreement, dated
February 7, 1994, between RP and the French Taxing Authority,
as the same may be supplemented, amended, modified or restated from
time to time, or any successor agreement thereto.
“Change of
Control” means, with respect to either RP or Merck, the
acquisition by any Person or Group, directly or indirectly,
beneficially or of record, of shares or options or other rights to
purchase shares representing in the aggregate more than fifty
percent (50%) of the aggregate ordinary voting power represented by
the issued and outstanding capital stock of RP or Merck, as the
case may be. Notwithstanding the
13
foregoing, the
following transactions shall be deemed not to constitute a Change
of Control: any merger or other business combination with another
entity (x) solely to reincorporate RP or Merck, as the case
may be, in a different form or under the laws of a different
jurisdiction, (y) in connection with an internal
reorganization which results in RP or Merck, as the case may be,
being a direct or indirect wholly-owned Subsidiary of such entity
or (z) any other transaction or series of transactions which
results in RP or Merck, as the case may be, being a direct or
indirect wholly-owned Subsidiary of any such entity, only if in the
case of clauses (x), (y) or (z): the shareholders of RP or
Merck, as applicable, immediately prior to the consummation of such
transaction(s) own, in the aggregate, immediately after such
transaction(s), shares representing more than fifty percent (50%)
of the aggregate ordinary voting power represented by the issued
and outstanding capital stock of such entity (or any parent company
thereof). A “Successor Entity” means any entity which
satisfies the conditions set out in any of clauses (x), (y) or
(z) of the preceding sentence and which has executed a deed in
the form of Exhibit XIII under which it agrees to be bound by
the obligations of that party in respect of which it is a Successor
Entity. Following any transaction(s) referred to in such clauses
(x), (y) or (z), all references to RP or Merck shall be deemed
to refer to the applicable Successor Entity, including the
references in clauses (x), (y) or (z). For purposes of this
definition only, “Group” means two or more Persons who
agree to act together for the purpose of acquiring, holding, voting
or disposing of equity securities of an issuer.
“Closing”
means the completion of the merger of Merck Transitory LLC with and
into Merial.
“Closing
Date” has the meaning set forth in
Section 12.3.
“Closing
Meeting” means the meetings of Merial’s members or
board of directors, as appropriate, held on the Closing
Date.
“Code”
means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended and any
regulations promulgated or proposed thereunder.
14
“Combination”
means any Animal Health Product that contains more than one active
ingredient.
“Companies
Act” means the United Kingdom Companies Act of
1985.
“Control,”
whether used as a noun or verb, refers to the possession, directly
or indirectly, of the power to direct, or cause the direction of,
the management or policies of a Person, whether through the
ownership of voting securities, by contract or
otherwise.
“Damages”
means any liability (whether arising out of fault, strict liability
or otherwise), obligation, loss, fine, damage, judgment,
arbitration award, settlement amount, penalty, claim, or
Environmental Liability, and all reasonable costs and expenses
related thereto (including reasonable costs of investigation, fees
and expenses payable to outside counsel, independent accountants
and similar professional advisors or consultants, but not including
any corporate allocation for management time or for the use of
similar in-house services or facilities), in each case whether or
not incurred in connection with a Third Party Claim.
“Debt”
has the meaning set forth in Section 5.1(c).
“Delaware
Act” means the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, 6
Del. C. § 18-101, et seq ., as amended from time to
time, including, without limitation, any amendments to
Section 18-109 thereof.
“Delayed
Purchase Assets” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(A)(4).
“Diagnostic
Disposal” means the contemplated sale by RM of its diagnostic
product business.
“Director”
has the meaning set forth in Section 4.3(b).
15
“Dissolution”
or “Dissolve” or “Dissolved”, as applied to
the Merial Venture, means either (i) the sale of the Merial
Venture Interest of one Principal to the other Principal pursuant
to Sections 16.3, 16.4, 16.5, 17.2(c)(ii) or otherwise or
(ii) the sale of all or substantially all of the Merial
Venture to a Third Party pursuant to Sections 16.3, 16.4,
17.2(c)(i) or otherwise.
“Dissolution
Date” has the meaning set forth in
Section 16.6(a).
“Distributable
Profits” has the meaning set forth in Section 181 of the
Companies Act.
“Economic
Effective Date” has the meaning set forth in
Section 6.3(a).
“Encumbrance”
means any lien, privilege, mortgage, pledge, third-party claim or
right, charge, restriction of use, defect of title, easement,
security interest or encumbrance of any kind, including, without
limitation, obligations resulting from any sublease, tenancy, right
of occupation, easement, preemptive right or privilege in favor of
any person or entity.
“Environmental
Laws” means, at any date, all provisions of law (including
applicable principles of common and civil law), statutes,
ordinances, rules, regulations, published standards and directives
that have the force and effect of Laws, permits, licenses,
judgments, writs, injunctions, decrees and orders enacted,
promulgated or issued by any Public Authority, and all indemnity
agreements and other contractual obligations, as in effect at such
date, relating to (i) the protection of the environment,
including the air, surface and subsurface soils, surface waters,
groundwaters and natural resources, and (ii) occupational
health and safety and exposure of persons to Hazardous Materials.
Environmental Laws shall include the Comprehensive Environmental
Response, Compensation and Liability Act, 42 U.S.C. §§
9601 et seq ., and any other Laws imposing or
creating liability with respect to Hazardous Materials.
16
“Environmental
Liability” means any liabilities, obligations, costs, losses,
payments or damages, including compensatory and punitive damages,
incurred (i) to contain, remove, clean up, assess, abate or
otherwise remedy any actual or alleged release or threatened
release of Hazardous Materials, any actual or alleged contamination
(by Hazardous Materials) of air, surface or subsurface soil,
groundwater or surface water, or any personal injury or damage to
natural resources or property resulting from any such release or
contamination, pursuant to the requirements of any Environmental
Law or in response to any claim by any Public Authority or other
Third Party under any Environmental Law; (ii) to modify
facilities or processes or take any other remedial action in
response to any claim by any Public Authority of non-compliance
with any Environmental Law; (iii) as a result of the
imposition of any civil or criminal fine or penalty by any Public
Authority for the violation or alleged violation of any
Environmental Law; or (iv) as a result of any action, suit,
proceeding or claim by any Third Party under any Environmental Law.
The term “Environmental Liability” shall include:
(i) reasonable fees of counsel and consultants (but not any
corporate allocation for management time or for the use of similar
in-house services or facilities) and (ii) the costs and
expenses of any investigation undertaken to ascertain the existence
or extent of any potential or actual Environmental
Liability.
“ERISA”
means the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as
amended and any regulations promulgated or proposed
thereunder.
“Event of
Insolvency,” with respect to any person, shall occur when
either:
(i) such person
shall (A) voluntarily commence any proceeding or file any
petition seeking relief under Title 11 of the United States Code,
French Law No. 84-148 of March 1, 1984, French Law
No. 85-98 of January 25, 1985 or any other bankruptcy,
insolvency or similar law of the United States, any state thereof,
or France, (B) apply for or consent to the appointment of a
receiver, trustee, custodian, sequestrator, conciliator,
administrator or similar official for it or a substantial part of
its property, (C) file an answer admitting the material
allegations of a petition filed against or in respect of it in any
such proceeding,
17
(D) make a
general assignment for the benefit of creditors, (E) become
unable generally, or admit in writing its inability, to pay its
debts as they become due, or (F) take corporate action for the
purpose of effecting any of the foregoing; or
(ii) an
involuntary proceeding shall be commenced or any involuntary
petition shall be filed in a court of competent jurisdiction
seeking (A) relief in respect of such person, or of a
substantial part of such person’s property, under Title 11 of
the United States Code, French Law No. 84-148 of March 1,
1984, French Law No. 85-98 of January 25, 1985 or any
other bankruptcy, insolvency or similar law of the United States,
any state thereof, or France, (B) the appointment of a
receiver, trustee, custodian, sequestrator, conciliator,
administrator or similar official for such person or for a
substantial part of such person’s property or (C) the
winding-up or liquidation of such person; and such proceeding or
petition shall continue undismissed for sixty (60) days or an
order or decree approving or ordering any of the foregoing shall
continue unstayed and in effect for thirty
(30) days;
(iii) an order is
made by a court of competent jurisdiction, or a resolution is
passed, for the winding up, dissolution or administration of such
person or the appointment of a liquidator, manager, receiver,
administrator, trustee or other similar officer in respect of, or
an encumbrancer taking possession of or selling, any substantial
assets of such person, or such person makes any arrangement or
composition with, or any assignment for the benefit of, its
creditors, or makes an application to a court of competent
jurisdiction for protection from its creditors generally, and such
order, resolution, appointment, arrangement, assignment or
application is not withdrawn or cancelled within sixty
(60) days of its being made.
(iv) anything
analogous to any of the events specified in (i), (ii) and
(iii) above occurs in respect of such person under the laws of
any applicable jurisdiction.
18
“Executive
Chairman” has the meaning set forth in
Section 4.4(a).
“Executive
Officers” has the meaning set forth in
Section 4.4(d).
“Existing
Other JVs” means (a) with respect to RP, those Persons
set forth on Schedule 2-2 and (b) with respect to Merck,
those Persons set forth on Schedule 2-3, in either case only
so long as such Persons are Other JVs.
“Existing
Product” means each Animal Health Product or Poultry Genetics
Product that is marketed in any country on the date of this
Agreement, by RM or its Subsidiaries (including those set forth in
Schedule 2-4) or by the Merck Group (including those set forth
in Schedule 2-5).
“Fipronil
Products” means all those Merial Venture Products containing
Fipronil as an active ingredient.
“Fiscal
Year” has the meaning set forth in
Section 11.4.
“Future
Agreement” means any written agreement (other than an
Ancillary Agreement) between any RP Company or Merck Company, on
the one hand, and any one or more of the Merial Venture Companies,
on the other hand, which may be entered into at any time after the
Closing.
“Future
Product” means any Animal Health Product or Poultry Genetics
Product, other than an Existing Product or a Pipeline Product, as
to which any Merial Venture Company has or may at any time acquire
(through internal research and development efforts and/or from
other persons) any Product Rights, Patents or Know-How relating to
the manufacture, use or sale thereof.
“GAAP”
means, with respect to any country, such country’s generally
accepted accounting practices or the International Accounting
Standards (“IAS”), in either case as in effect from
time to time, consistently applied.
19
“Goubin Book
Value” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.1(b)(i).
“Grandfathered
Merck Employees” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(b).
“Governmental
Order” means any order, writ, judgment, injunction, decree,
stipulation, determination or award entered by or with any Public
Authority.
“Governmental
Plan” means any plan that is sponsored or maintained by a
Public Authority to which either the RP Group or the Merck Group
contributes, or is required to contribute, on behalf of any RM
Employee or Merck Employee.
“Goubin”
means Compagnie Jean Goubin S.A.
“Group”
means the Merck Group or the RP Group, as appropriate.
“Hazardous
Material” means any substance regulated by any Environmental
Law or which may now or in the future form the basis for any
Environmental Liability.
“Health
Cost” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(c).
“HSR
Act” means the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act
of 1976, as amended.
“ICC”
means the International Chamber of Commerce.
“ICE”
means the International Centre for Expertise of the ICC.
“IM”
has the meaning set forth in the introduction to this
Agreement.
“IM
LLC” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.3(a).
20
“Income
Taxes” means income, corporation or franchise taxes or other
Taxes measured in whole or in part by income or by reference to
income, together with any interest or penalties imposed with
respect thereto, levied by any Taxing Authority.
“Indemnified
Party” has the meaning set forth in
Section 14.7(a).
“Indemnifying
Party” has the meaning set forth in
Section 14.7(a).
“Intellectual
Property” of a Person means, collectively, the Product
Rights, Patents and Know-How of such Person.
“Interim
Financing” means the revolving credit facilities provided or
arranged by each of RP and Merck to Merial in accordance with
Section 5.2(d).
“Inventory”
or “Inventories” of any Person means all inventory,
merchandise, partially finished and finished products, and raw
materials, maintained, held or stored by or for such Person and any
prepaid deposits for any of the same; provided that
“Inventories”
of any of Merck or its Subsidiaries shall mean only such
inventories as constitute Merck Contributed Assets.
“Investment
Bank” means a reputable international investment bank with
experience appraising and selling businesses comparable to the
Merial Venture.
“IRS” means the Internal Revenue
Service.
“ISA”
means Institut de Sélection Animale S.A.
“Know-How”
means, in respect of any product, all technical knowledge, ability,
skill or expertise in the manufacture or commercialization of such
product other than knowledge or expertise covered by a
Patent.
21
“Label”
means, in respect of any Merial Venture Product, the packaging,
product brochure or product monograph filed with the appropriate
Public Authority (or Public Authorities) having authority to
approve the marketing of such Merial Venture Product and the
package insert directed to veterinarians or consumers that has been
approved by such Public Authority (or Public Authorities) for such
Merial Venture Product, including, in each case, the indications,
claims, uses and dosages appearing therein.
“Laws”
means any supranational, national, state, local or foreign statute,
law, directive, ordinance, regulation, rule, code, order,
requirement or rule of common law.
“Liabilities”
means any and all debts, liabilities and obligations, whether
accrued or fixed, absolute or contingent, matured or unmatured or
determined or determinable, including those arising under any Law
(including any Environmental Law), Action or Governmental Order and
those arising under any contract, agreement, arrangement,
commitment or undertaking.
“LIBOR”
means, in relation to any unpaid sum, the rate per annum equal to
the arithmetic mean (rounded upwards, if not already such a
multiple, to the nearest whole multiple of one-thirty second of one
per cent.) of the offered quotations in the so-called London
Interbank loan market as displayed on Pages 3740 or 3750 (as
appropriate) on the Telerate Service for the currency in which such
unpaid sum is to be denominated and for the relevant specified
period at or about 11:00 a.m. (London time) on the second
Business Day before the beginning of such specified
period.
“LLC
Agreement” means the limited liability company agreement of
Merial in the form provided as Exhibit II hereto, as the same
may be amended, modified, supplemented or restated from time to
time.
“MACI”
has the meaning set forth in Section 1.3(a).
22
“Material
Adverse Change or Effect” means, with respect to any Person,
a change or effect that materially adversely affects, or (except
with respect to Sections 12.6(b)(vi) or 12.6(c)(vi), as the
case may be) is reasonably likely to materially adversely
affect,
(i) if such
determination is to be made on or prior to the Closing, (A) in
the case of an RP Company, the assets, liabilities, operations,
results of operations or financial condition of RM and its
Subsidiaries, taken as a whole; and (B) in the case of a Merck
Company, the Merck Contributed Assets or the operations, results of
operations or financial condition of the Merck Contributed
Business; or
(ii) if such
determination is to be made after the Closing, (A) in the case
of a Merial Venture Company, the assets, liabilities, operations,
results of operations or financial condition of the Merial Venture;
and (B) in the case of an RP Company or a Merck Company, the
ability of such company to perform any of its material obligations
under this Agreement or any Ancillary or Future Agreement if such
obligations are material to the assets, liabilities, operations,
results of operations or financial condition of the Merial
Venture;
provided that, as used in Articles VIII, IX and X of this
Agreement, the terms “Material Adverse Change”,
“Material Adverse Effect”, “material” or
any similar terms shall mean having an adverse impact or effect or
potential adverse impact or effect on the value of RM and its
Subsidiaries or the value of the Merck Contributed Assets, as the
case may be, or on the aggregate net income of the Merial Venture,
of at least [*].
“Member”
means a shareholder of Merial being either the RP Member or the
Merck Member, which together shall be the
“Members”.
“Members’
Meeting” has the meaning set forth in
Section 4.1.
“Merck”
means Merck & Co. or any Successor Entity thereto.
23
“Merck &
Co.” has the meaning set forth in the introduction to this
Agreement.
“Merck
Accrued Tax Liabilities” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B).
“Merck
Adjustment Products” has the meaning set forth in
Section 6.4(c).
“Merck
Animal Health Executive” means the Merck executive with
direct responsibility for Merial reporting to the Chief Executive
Officer of Merck and any duly appointed successor in such role,
notified in writing by Merck to RP and Merial.
“Merck
Benefit Plan” means each Benefit Plan (other than Merck
Employee Agreements) which is now or previously has been sponsored,
maintained, contributed to, or required to be contributed to, or
with respect to which any withdrawal liability (within the meaning
of Section 4201 of ERISA) has been incurred, by Merck, any of
its Subsidiaries or any Merck ERISA Affiliate for the benefit of
any Merck Employee, and pursuant to which Merck, any of its
Subsidiaries or any Merck ERISA Affiliate has or may have any
liability, contingent or otherwise.
“Merck
Breach” has the meaning set forth in
Section 14.2(b).
“Merck
Company” means any of Merck or its Subsidiaries.
“Merck
Contributed Assets” has the meaning set forth in
Section 10.10.
“Merck
Contributed Business” means all the Merck JV Business
activities and operations immediately prior to the Closing, other
than those activities or operations (i) that Merck will
continue to conduct pursuant to the Ancillary Agreements to which
Merck or any of its Subsidiaries is a party, (ii) conducted
using the assets, properties and rights set forth in
Schedule 2-7, and (iii) relating to “The Merck
Veterinary Manual” and the Annual Authorizations Service
Repertory License Agreement between Copyright Clearance Center,
Inc. and Merck & Co. Inc. dated December 31,
1995.
24
“Merck
Contributed Business Financials” has the meaning set forth in
Section 10.5. The Merck Contributed Business Financials are
attached as Exhibit XVI.
“Merck
Contributed Debt” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.2(a).
“Merck
Contributed Liabilities” means all of the obligations or
Liabilities of Merck or any of its Subsidiaries (whether or not
reflected on the Merck Contributed Business Financials or the books
and records of Merck or any of its Subsidiaries) arising from,
relating to, resulting from or incurred in connection with, the
Merck Contributed Business or any of the Merck Contributed Assets
or the ownership or operation of, or conduct of any activities on
or from, any of the foregoing, including (i) under the
agreements, contracts, leases, licenses and other arrangements
included within the Merck Contributed Assets, (ii) accounts
and other payables, (iii) Environmental Liabilities,
(iv) Taxes, (v) threatened, pending or settled
litigation, (vi) under Merck Benefit Plans, and (vii) all
obligations or Liabilities of the types referred to in the Merck
Contributed Business Financials or that are the subject of any of
the representations in Article X.
“Merck
Contributed Non-U.S. Assets” means all the Merck Contributed
Assets that are not Merck Contributed U.S. Assets.
“Merck
Contributed U.S. Assets” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.1(a)(i).
“Merck
Employee” means each current, former, or retired employee of
a Merck Transferred Subsidiary together with those employees listed
in Schedule 10.19H-2.
“Merck
Employee Agreement” means each management, employment,
severance, consulting, non-compete, confidentiality, or similar
agreement or contract between Merck or any of its Subsidiaries and
any Merck Employee pursuant to which Merck or any of its
Subsidiaries has or may have any liability, contingent or
otherwise.
“Merck ERISA
Affiliate” means each business or entity which is a member of
a “controlled group of corporations,” under
“common control” or an “affiliated
service
25
group”
with Merck within the meaning of Sections 414(b), (c) or
(m) of the Code, or required to be aggregated with Merck under
Section 414(o) of the Code, or is under “common
control” with Merck, within the meaning of
Section 4001(a)(14) of ERISA.
“Merck
Group” means Merck, together with all its
Subsidiaries.
“Merck JV
Business” means, from time to time at any time prior to the
Closing, all the Merial Venture Business activities of the Merck
Group, including of the Merck Transferred Subsidiaries, throughout
the world.
“Merck
Leased Employees” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(a).
“Merck
Manufacturing Supply Price Formula” means the Merck
Manufacturing Supply Price Formula annexed as Exhibit 10 to
the Merck Supply Agreement.
“Merck
Member” means the Member that is a Subsidiary of Merck which
shall, as of the Closing, be Merck SH.
“Merck
Negotiated Supply Price” has the meaning set forth in
Section 6.7(a).
“Merck
Pre-Closing Taxes” has the meaning set forth in
Section 14.12(a).
“Merck
Product Registrations” has the meaning set forth in
Section 10.13.
“Merck
Proprietary Rights” has the meaning set forth in
Section 10.12(b).
“Merck
Restructuring Event” means any transaction or series of
related transactions pursuant to which all or substantially all of
the assets of Merck are sold or otherwise transferred to a Third
Party.
“Merck
Retirement Plans” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(b).
26
“Merck
SH” has the meaning set forth in the introduction to this
Agreement.
“Merck Stock
Option Plan” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(d).
“Merck
Transferred Benefit Plan” means the Merck & Co., Inc.
Employee Savings and Security Plan and each Merck Benefit Plan
sponsored, maintained, or contributed to by a Merck Transferred
Subsidiary.
“Merck
Transitory LLC” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.3(a).
“Merck
Transferred Foreign Pension Plan” means each Merck
Transferred Benefit Plan that is an “employee pension benefit
plan” within the meaning of Section 3(2) of ERISA but
that is not subject to Title I or IV of ERISA pursuant to
Sections 4(b)(4) and 4021(b)(7) of ERISA.
“Merck
Transferred Pension Plan” means each Merck Transferred
Benefit Plan which is an “employee pension benefit
plan” within the meaning of Section 3(2) of ERISA and is
subject to Title IV of ERISA.
“Merck
Transferred Subsidiaries” means each Subsidiary of Merck
listed in Schedule 2-8 hereto.
“Merial”
has the meaning set forth in the introduction to this
Agreement.
“Merial
Merck Employees” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(a).
“Merial
Venture” means the group comprised of all the Merial Venture
Companies.
“Merial
Venture Business” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.2(a).
27
“Merial
Venture Companies” means collectively Merial and (following
its transfer to Merial) each Transferred Subsidiary and any other
Subsidiary of Merial from time to time, and “Merial Venture
Company” means any one of them.
“Merial
Venture Interest” of a Principal means all direct and
indirect equity and other ownership interests of such Principal and
any of its Subsidiaries in the Merial Venture.
“Merial
Venture Product” means, from time to time, any one of the
Existing Products or Future Products.
“Net
Reported Sales” means, in respect of any Avermectin, Fipronil
or Biological Products, as the case may be, the sales amount
calculated in the same manner as Net Sales, but without deducting
from the gross invoice price of such products the items listed in
(iv) and (v) of the definition of Net Sales and
calculated for purposes of Sections 6.4 or 6.5, in the case of
sales made in the currencies set forth therein, based on the
exchange rates set forth in Section 6.4(e).
“Net
Sales” means the gross invoice price (which will not include
any taxes) of Avermectin, Fipronil or Biological Products, as the
case may be, sold by Merial, its Subsidiaries or sublicensees to
the first independent third party after deducting, if not already
deducted in the amount invoiced:
(i) the normal or
customary trade and/or quantity discounts, excluding cash
discounts, that are actually allowed or granted;
(ii) returns,
rebates and allowances that are actually granted;
(iii) retroactive
price reductions applicable to sales of such products that are
actually allowed or granted;
28
(iv) sales
commissions that are actually paid to third party distributors and
selling agents; and
(v) [*] of the
amount invoiced to cover cash discounts, bad debt, freight or other
transportation costs, insurance charges, additional special
packaging, duties, tariffs and other governmental
charges.
With respect to
sales of Avermectin or Fipronil Products sold in Combinations, Net
Sales shall be calculated in accordance with the provisions of the
definition of Net Sales set forth in Exhibit XXI [Avermectin
Products Sales Adjustment] or the RP Ag Research Agreement,
respectively.
“Other
JVs” means Persons that are, in substance, joint ventures in
which (a) the Merck Group or the RP Group, as the case may be,
owns 50% or less of both (x) the outstanding equity, and (y)
the outstanding equity that has the right to elect or appoint the
members of the board of directors or similar governing body of such
Person (the Parties hereby conclusively deem the conditions of this
clause (a) to be satisfied in respect of Banyu Pharmaceutical
Co. Ltd., its Subsidiaries and its and their respective
successors), and (b) the principal business of such Person is
a business or businesses other than the Animal Health Business or
the Poultry Genetics Business.
“Other
Taxes” means all Taxes which are not Income Taxes, including
registration and stamp duties (even if related to real property);
provided , however , that such term shall not include
any real property taxes.
“Parties”
means all the parties to this Agreement and “Party”
means any one of them.
“Patents”
means, in respect of any product, any unexpired patents or patent
applications in any jurisdiction necessary to make, have made, use
or sell such product.
29
“Person”
or “person” means a natural person or any corporation,
partnership, company, limited liability company, association, trust
or other entity of any kind whatsoever.
“Pipeline
Products” means, with respect to RM and its Subsidiaries, the
products listed under the caption “Pipeline” on page 1
of the RM base case attached as Exhibit XIV hereto and, with
respect to the Merck Group, the products listed under the caption
“Pipeline” of the Merck base case attached as
Exhibit XV hereto.
“PMSV”
means Pasteur Mérieux Sérums et Vaccins S.A.
“Poultry
Genetics Business” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.2(a).
“Poultry
Genetics Products” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.2(c).
“Pre-Closing
Benefit Liabilities” means liabilities incurred, suffered or
accrued as of, or otherwise arising out of events or periods
occurring prior to, the Closing Date with respect to a Merck
Transferred Benefit Plan or an RM Transferred Benefit Plan and
calculated as follows: (i) the calculation of liabilities for
“employee pension benefit plans” within the meaning of
§ 3(2) of ERISA and which are defined benefit plans shall be
determined as of the Closing Date using the January 1, 1997
census data of each such plan (unless there have been significant
demographic changes between January 1, 1997 and the Closing
Date, in which case the Closing Date census data of a particular
plan shall be used with respect to such plan) and shall be
determined (on an accumulated benefit obligation basis) based upon
actuarial assumptions used by RM (for RM Transferred Pension Plans)
or Merck (for Merck Transferred Pension Plans) for purposes of
determining pension expense pursuant to FAS 87 for each such plan
for 1997; (ii) the calculation of liabilities for retiree
medical plans shall be determined as of the Closing Date using the
January 1, 1997 census data of each such plan (unless there have
been significant demographic changes between January 1, 1997
and the Closing Date, in which case the Closing Date census data of
a particular plan shall be used with respect to such plan) and
shall be determined (on an accumulated post-retirement benefit
obligation basis)
30
based upon
those actuarial assumptions used by RM (with respect to RM
Transferred Benefit Plans which provide retiree medical benefits)
or Merck (with respect to Merck Transferred Benefit Plans which
provide retiree medical benefits) for calculating the expense for
purposes of FAS 106 for 1997; (iii) the calculation of
liabilities for RM Transferred Benefit Plans and Merck Transferred
Benefit Plans providing post-employment (but pre-retirement)
benefits such as salary and health care continuation, supplemental
unemployment benefits, severance benefits and disability-related
benefits (including workers’ compensation) shall be
determined as of the Closing Date using the January 1, 1997
census data of each such plan (unless there have been significant
demographic changes between January 1, 1997 and the Closing
Date, in which case the Closing Date census data of a particular
plan shall be used with respect to such plan) and shall be
determined based upon those actuarial assumptions used by RM (with
respect to RM Transferred Benefit Plans which provide such
benefits) or Merck (with respect to Merck Transferred Benefit Plans
which provide such benefits) for calculating the expense for
purposes of FAS 112 for 1997; provided , however ,
that the calculation of liabilities for long-term disability plans
shall include liability for any employee who has commenced or is
eligible to commence benefits under a short-term disability plan
maintained by his or her employer as of the Closing Date and
becomes eligible to receive, after the Closing Date, benefits under
a long-term disability plan of the Merial Venture as a result of
such pre-Closing disability, provided that such disability is
continuous in accordance with the terms of the applicable plan;
(iv) the calculation of other liabilities for RM Transferred
Benefit Plans and Merck Transferred Benefit Plans which are medical
or dental plans shall be based on claims for treatment or services
received or other expenses incurred prior to the Closing and
reported prior to December 31, 1997; (v) liabilities for
RM Transferred Benefit Plans and Merck Transferred Benefit Plans
which are bonus plans shall be equal to a pro rata
portion (based on the percentage of the bonus period up to and
including the Closing Date) of the bonus that is paid with respect
to the full bonus period; and (vi) the liability for any RM
Transferred Benefit Plan or Merck Transferred Benefit Plan not
covered by clauses (i) through (v) above including any
and all such plans maintained outside of the U.S., shall be
determined using generally accepted actuarial or accounting
principles, and using such actuarial or other assumptions as may be
necessary, and as agreed to by RP and Merck. Pre-Closing Benefit
Liabilities shall be calculated by
31
the plan
actuary for the plan at issue (or if there is no plan actuary, by
the actuary or accountant appointed by the plan sponsor);
provided , however , that if Merck or RP dispute the
determination of such liabilities made by such actuary (or
accountant, as applicable), Merck and RP shall jointly choose an
actuary or accountant, as applicable, to perform such calculation
and the determination of the jointly chosen actuary or accountant,
as applicable, shall be binding on RP and Merck. Pre-Closing
Benefit Liabilities shall exclude RM Pre-Closing Taxes and Merck
Pre-Closing Taxes.
“Pre-Closing
Tax Period” in relation to a Person means all taxable periods
of that Person ending on or before the Closing Date.
“Principal”
means each of RP and Merck, which are together the
“Principals.”
“Product
Liability” means any Damages that arise as a result of, or in
connection with, the use by a Third Party of a Merial Venture
Product.
“Product
Registration” means, with respect to a product, the product
registration (final and pending) or any other authorizations of
Public Authorities necessary to market such product in any
country.
“Product
Rights” means, with respect to a product and its marketing,
distribution and sale in a country, (i) the Product
Registrations, and (ii) all product trademarks, service marks,
trade dress and copyrights necessary to market, distribute and sell
such product in that country.
“Public
Authority” means any supranational, national, regional, state
or local government, court, tribunal, governmental agency,
authority, board, bureau, instrumentality or regulatory
body.
“Qualified
Future Other JVs ” means Other JVs for so long as no
member or representative of the Merck Group or the RP Group, as
applicable, initiates or takes other affirmative action to cause
such Other JV to commence an Animal Health Business or
32
Poultry
Genetics Business other than (a) de minimis activities that
are incidental to the principal business or businesses of such
Other JV or (b) which result from the exploitation of a
product (including for the Animal Health or Poultry Genetics
Business) invented or developed in the principal business or
businesses (i.e. non Animal Health or Poultry Genetics Business) of
such Other JV.
“Receivables”
of any person means any and all accounts receivable of such person
and all notes and other amounts receivable by such person from
third parties, including, without limitation, customers and
employees, whether or not in the ordinary course of business,
together with any unpaid financing charges accrued thereon;
provided that “Receivables” of any of Merck or its
Subsidiaries shall mean only such receivables as constitute Merck
Contributed Assets.
“Representative”
of a Member has the meaning set forth in
Section 4.2(d).
“Research
Agreements” means, collectively, the Merck Research
Agreement, the RPR Research Agreement, the RP Ag Research Agreement
and the PMSV Research Agreement.
“Retained
Inventory” shall have the meaning set forth in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(C).
“Retained
Receivables” shall have the meaning set forth in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(C).
“Retirement
Cost” shall have the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(b).
“Retroactive
Closing Mechanism” shall have the meaning set forth in
Section 6.3(a).
“Retroactive
Closing Financial Statements” shall have the meaning set
forth in Exhibit XIX hereto.
33
“Returns”
means all returns, reports, declarations, estimates, information
returns, statements and forms of any nature regarding Taxes,
including remittance advice, required to be filed with any Taxing
Authority.
“Rhône-Poulenc”
has the meaning set forth in the introduction to this
Agreement.
“RM”
has the meaning set forth in the introduction to this
Agreement.
“RM Accrued
Tax Liabilities” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.2(b).
“RM Benefit
Plan” means each Benefit Plan (other than RM Employee
Agreements) which is now or previously has been sponsored,
maintained, contributed to, or required to be contributed to, or
with respect to which any withdrawal liability (within the meaning
of Section 4201 of ERISA) has been incurred, by RP, any of its
Subsidiaries or any RM ERISA Affiliate for the benefit of any RM
Employee, and pursuant to which RP, any of its Subsidiaries or any
RM ERISA Affiliate has or may have any liability, contingent or
otherwise.
“RM
Contributed Liabilities” means all of the obligations or
Liabilities of RM or any of its Subsidiaries (whether or not
reflected on the RM Financials or the books and records of RM or
any of its Subsidiaries).
“RM
Employee” means each current, former, or retired employee of
an RM Transferred Subsidiary together with those employees listed
on Schedule 8.18A-2.
“RM Employee
Agreement” means each management, employment, severance,
consulting, non-compete, confidentiality, or similar agreement or
contract between RP or any of its Subsidiaries and any RM Employee
pursuant to which RP or any of its Subsidiaries has or may have any
liability contingent or otherwise.
“RM ERISA
Affiliate” means each business or entity which is a member of
a “controlled group of corporations,” under
“common control” or an “affiliated
service
34
group”
with RP within the meaning of Sections 414(b), (c) or
(m) of the Code, or required to be aggregated with RP under
Section 414(o) of the Code, or is under “common
control” with RP, within the meaning of
Section 4001(a)(14) of ERISA.
“RM
Financials” has the meaning set forth in Section 8.5.
The RM Financials are attached as Exhibit XVII.
“RM
Intercompany Debt” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.2(b).
“RM
Outstanding Debt” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.2(b).
“RM
Plans” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(e).
“RM
Pre-Closing Taxes” has the meaning set forth in
Section 14.11(a).
“RM
Proprietary Rights” has the meaning set forth in
Section 8.11(b).
“RM
Transferred Benefit Plan” means each RM Benefit Plan
sponsored, maintained, or contributed to by an RM Transferred
Subsidiary.
“RM
Transferred Foreign Pension Plan” means each RM Transferred
Benefit Plan that is an “employee pension benefit plan”
within the meaning of Section 3(2) of ERISA but that is not
subject to Title I or IV of ERISA pursuant to Sections 4(b)(4)
and 4021(b)(7) of ERISA.
“RM
Transferred Pension Plan” means each RM Transferred Benefit
Plan which is an “employee pension benefit plan” within
the meaning of Section 3(2) of ERISA and is subject to Title
IV of ERISA.
“RM
Transferred Subsidiaries” means, collectively, RM and each
Subsidiary of RM listed in Schedule 2-11 hereto.
35
“RM U.S.
Employees” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(e).
“RM 401(k)
Plan” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(e).
“RP”
means Rhône-Poulenc S.A. or any Successor Entity
thereto.
“RP
Adjustment Products” has the meaning set forth in
Section 6.4(b).
“RP
Ag” means Rhône-Poulenc Agrochimie S.A.
“RP Ag
Manufacturing Supply Price Formula” means the Manufacturing
Supply Price Formula annexed as Exhibit 3 to the RP Ag Supply
Agreement.
“RP Animal
Health Executive” means the individual named in
Schedule 2-12 and any duly appointed successor to such
individual, notified in writing by RP to Merck and
Merial.
“RP
Breach” has the meaning set forth in
Section 14.2(b).
“RP
Company” means any of RP or its Subsidiaries.
“RP
Contributed Debt” has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.2(b).
“RP
Finance” has the meaning set forth in
Section 1.3(a).
“RP
Group” means RP, together with all its
Subsidiaries.
“RP
Member” means the Member that is a Subsidiary of RP which
shall, subject to sections 17.1 and 17.2, be IM.
“RP
Restructuring Event” means any transaction or series of
related transactions pursuant to which (i) any of RP Ag, PMSV
or RPR ceases to be a Subsidiary of RP, or
36
(ii) all
or substantially all of the assets of any of RP Ag, PMSV or RPR are
sold or otherwise transferred to a Third Party.
“RPR” means Rhône-Poulenc Rorer
S.A.
“SAS” means société par
actions simplifiée.
“Special
Dividend” has the meaning set forth in
Section 6.2(a).
“Straddle
Period” means, in relation to a Person, the taxable period of
that Person that includes the Closing Date.
“Subsidiary”
means, with respect to any Person (herein referred to as the
“parent”), any corporation, partnership, company,
association, trust or other business entity (a) of which
securities or other ownership interests representing more than 50%
of the equity or more than 50% of the ordinary voting power or more
than 50% of the general partnership or analogous interests are, at
the time such determination is being made, owned, Controlled or
held by the parent and/or one or more other Subsidiaries of the
parent, or (b) which is, at the time such determination is
made, otherwise Controlled, by the parent and/or one or more other
Subsidiaries of the parent; provided that it shall be deemed
that (i) as from the Closing Date, none of the Merial Venture
Companies shall be a Subsidiary of either Merck or RP; and
(ii) none of the Existing Other JVs or Qualified Future Other
JVs shall be a Subsidiary of either Merck or RP.
“Successor
Entity” has the meaning set forth in the definition of Change
of Control above.
“Supply
Agreements” means, collectively, the Merck Supply Agreement
and the RP Ag Supply Agreement.
“Tax”
means any tax, including, without limitation, income (net or
gross), corporations, capital gains, gross receipts, franchise,
estimated, alternative, minimum,
37
add-on minimum,
sales, use, transfer, registration, value added, excise, natural
resources, severance, stamp, occupation, premium, windfall profit,
customs, duties, real property, personal property, capital stock,
social security, unemployment, disability, payroll, license,
employee or other withholding, or other tax, of any kind
whatsoever, and including any interest, penalties or additions to
tax, levied by any Taxing Authority.
“Taxing
Authority” means any governmental authority, including, but
not limited to agencies of the European Union, the United States
federal government, the government of the French Republic, the
government of the United Kingdom, or the government of any other
country, and any political subdivision of any of the foregoing,
having jurisdiction over the assessment, determination, collection,
or other imposition of Tax.
“Tax
Benefit” means any items of loss, deduction or credit or any
other item to the extent such item decreases Taxes paid or payable
including any interest and penalty with respect thereto or interest
that would have been payable but for such item.
“Tax
Matter” means any Tax matter, including any audit,
examination, assessment, notice of deficiency or other adjustment
or proposed adjustment, or administrative or judicial proceeding,
the settlement of any of the foregoing, or the filing of any
amended return.
“Third
Party” means a person who or which is neither a Merial
Venture Company nor a Merck Company nor an RP Company.
“Third Party
Claim” has the meaning set forth in
Section 14.7(a).
“Transactions”
means, collectively, all the transactions contemplated by this
Agreement and the Ancillary Agreements.
“Transferred
Subsidiaries” means, collectively, the RM Transferred
Subsidiaries and the Merck Transferred Subsidiaries.
38
“U.S.”
means the United States of America.
“U.S. Animal
Health Employees” has the meaning set forth in
Section 7.1(f).
“U.S.
Person” means any company or other Person that is formed or
domesticated under the laws of any state of the United States of
America.
39
(a)
Merial as Principal Entity . Merial shall be the parent
company of the Merial Venture. Any entity created by Merial or any
Merial Venture Company in any country to conduct Merial Venture
Business operations shall be a Subsidiary of Merial.
(b)
Location of Offices . The principal office of Merial shall
be in London, England.
SECTION 3.2.
Reorganization of Subsidiaries Prior to Closing
Prior to the
Closing, the following actions shall be taken:
(a) Merck
shall cause each of the Merck Transferred Subsidiaries that is a
U.S. Person to be reorganized as a limited liability company which
is not classified as an association taxable as a corporation for
U.S. federal income tax purposes.
(b) RP shall
cause RM to be reorganized as a SAS, which is not classified as an
association taxable as a corporation for U.S. federal income tax
purposes. RP shall cause such reorganized entity to be wholly owned
by Merial, except for one share therein which will be owned by a
newly-formed single member Delaware limited liability company which
is not classified as an association taxable as a corporation for
U.S. federal income tax purposes, which shall itself be wholly
owned by Merial.
(c) RP shall
cause the share ownership of all the Subsidiaries of Rhone Merieux,
Inc. that are not U.S. Persons to be transferred to Merial or to
Subsidiaries of Merial that are not U.S. Persons, it being
understood that RP shall not be required to cause any such transfer
which would result in an aggregate (for all such transfers)
adverse
40
tax consequence
for the RP Group in excess of [*].
(d) IM shall
cause Merial to elect classification as a partnership for U.S.
federal income tax purposes.
41
Merial is, as at
the date hereof, an English private company limited by shares
governed by the Laws of England and Wales and shall, as of the
Closing, be governed by the Association Documents. As of the
Closing, Merial will, pursuant to the Delaware Act, be domesticated
in Delaware as a Delaware limited liability company governed by the
LLC Agreement and, to the extent applicable, Delaware Laws. To the
extent that the provisions of English Laws governing Merial and the
provisions of Delaware Laws governing Merial are not identical, the
Directors and the Members shall take such steps as are reasonably
required to ensure that Merial complies with both such Laws. Merial
is, in addition, otherwise subject to the relevant provisions of
this Agreement.
SECTION 4.1.
Company Bodies of Merial
The company bodies
of Merial are:
|
|
•
|
|
the
members of Merial acting through a meeting of the Members or a
unanimous written resolution (the “Members’
Meeting”),
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
•
|
|
the
Board of Directors, and
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
•
|
|
the
Executive Officers.
|
SECTION 4.2.
Members’ Meeting
(a)
Members’ Meeting as Ultimate Authority of Merial . The
Members’ Meeting shall be the ultimate authority of Merial.
Certain fundamental decisions affecting Merial shall require the
approval of the Members’ Meeting.
(b)
Resolutions of the Members’ Meeting . The following
actions shall require a resolution of the Members’
Meeting:
42
(i) the
dissolution or winding up of, or any merger, joint venture or
partnership involving, or the acquisition or reorganization of,
Merial;
(ii) any
arrangement for the acquisition of all or substantially all of the
assets or undertakings of Merial;
(iii) any
modification of the Association Documents or the LLC Agreement,
including, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, any
increase or decrease of Merial’s authorized share capital or
the issuance by Merial of any securities or interests, or any
options, warrants or other rights to acquire such securities or
interests;
(iv) the
undertaking of any significant business activities outside the
scope of the Merial Venture Business;
(v) the approval
of the annual financial statements (including income and cash flow
statements and balance sheet) of Merial;
(vi) the payment
or declaration of any dividend or distribution or the entering into
of any transaction by reference to, or which will have the effect
of reducing, Merial’s Distributable Profits, except as
expressly contemplated by this Agreement, and in particular by
Article VI ;
(vii) any request
for capital contributions by the Members;
(viii) the
appointment or removal of the auditor(s) of Merial;
(ix) any matter
put to the Members’ Meeting for its resolution by the Board
of Directors or either of the Members; and
(x) all other
matters required by applicable Laws to be decided or approved by
the Members.
43
(c)
Unanimous Vote in the Members’ Meeting . Decisions of
the Members’ Meeting shall require the agreement of both
Members.
(d)
Selection of Representatives . Each of the Members shall
designate, prior to or at the commencement of the Closing Meeting,
either (A) one representative who shall be authorized to cast
such Member’s vote at all meetings of the Members until
another individual is designated to cast such vote or
(B) several representatives, each of whom shall be authorized
to cast such Member’s vote at the meetings which shall be
specified in such representative’s designation, and, for each
such representative, until another individual is designated to cast
such vote. Each such designation may specify the terms of any
substitution (as in the case of absence or otherwise). A memorandum
in the form set out in the Association Documents recording such
designation shall be made in writing and delivered to the other
Member, and details of the relevant designation may be read into
the minutes of the meeting at the commencement of the meeting and
the memorandum thereafter so delivered. The vote of a
Member’s designated representative or of the substitute for
such representative, if applicable (such designated representative
or substitute being the “Representative”), in the
Members’ Meeting shall in all cases be deemed to be the
decision of such Member. Any appointment by or notification of
either such Representative under this Article IV shall in all
cases be deemed to be the appointment by or notification of the
respective Member.
(e)
Voting by the Members in the Members’ Meeting . Each
of the Members shall at all times exercise or cause to be exercised
all of its powers and votes as a member of Merial such that Merial
shall comply with all obligations under and implement all
provisions of this Agreement, the LLC Agreement and the Association
Documents, as validly amended from time to time.
(f)
Members’ Meetings . Non-voting representatives of
either Member may attend any Members’ Meetings in addition to
the Representatives. A quorum shall exist in a Members’
Meeting if Representatives of both Members are present. Decisions
may also be taken by the Members’ Meeting by unanimous
written resolution of both Members.
44
(g) New
Members’ Meeting in Case of Inability to reach a Decision
. If, with respect to a specific matter, the Members are unable to
reach a decision in the Members’ Meeting, then each Member
has the right to request a new Members’ Meeting to discuss
the same matter. Such new Members’ Meeting shall occur within
thirty (30) days after the date of the last Members’
Meeting.
(h)
Deadlock, Conciliation . If at such second Members’
Meeting, the Members are still deadlocked with respect to said
matter, within seven (7) days thereafter the matter shall be
referred for resolution pursuant to the terms of Section 18.1
to the RP Animal Health Executive and the Merck Animal Health
Executive.
(i)
Discussion of Agenda Prior to Members’ Meeting . At
the request of either Member, the points of the agenda shall be
discussed between representatives of the Members prior to any
Members’ Meeting.
(j)
Calling for a Members’ Meeting . A Members’
Meeting may be called by the Board of Directors or by any Member.
Members’ Meetings shall take place at the registered office
of Merial unless another location is agreed upon by both
Members.
(k)
Annual Members’ Meeting . Subject to the requirements
of the Companies Act, the annual Members’ Meeting shall be
held within six (6) months after the end of each Fiscal Year.
It shall consider the approval of Merial’s annual financial
statements, the allocation (in accordance with the other provisions
of this Agreement) of any Distributable Profits and the appointment
of Merial’s auditors, when required.
SECTION 4.3.
Board of Directors
(a)
Powers of the Board of Directors . The fundamental policies
and the strategy of Merial shall be determined by its board of
directors (the “Board of Directors”). The Board of
Directors shall have responsibility for approving the annual budget
and Business Plan and shall oversee their implementation by the
Executive Chairman and the other Executive Officers. Except for
matters requiring the approval of
45
the
Members’ Meeting and subject to the Members’
Meetings’ decisions, the Board of Directors shall have the
responsibility for making all significant decisions of Merial. In
particular, Merial shall not do, either directly or indirectly, any
of the following with respect to the Merial Venture without the
prior approval of the Board of Directors:
(i) take any
action that affects the ownership or nature of the share capital of
RM or the nature of the share capital of Merial, it being
understood that any change in the ownership of the share capital of
Merial shall be deemed for the purposes of this Section 4.3(a)(i)
not to affect the ownership or nature of the share capital of RM or
the nature of the share capital of Merial (the Directors appointed
by the RP Member being hereby reminded by RP that they should,
prior to participating in such approval or taking any other action
affecting the RP Member’s ownership interest in Merial,
consult with tax counsel and may wish to obtain confirmation from
the French Direction Générale des Impôts of
the effect of such action on the agrément fiscal
described in Section 11.2(b) and any potential for substantial
Taxes to be imposed on RP);
(ii) except as
previously approved in writing in the annual budget, invest in,
acquire or dispose of assets or businesses in any manner, or
encumber assets in any manner, or incur or assume any indebtedness,
enter into long term contracts, or generally undertake any other
matter of extraordinary importance or particular strategic
importance, in one transaction or a series of related transactions,
in each case in excess of [*];
(iii) subject to
Section 4.3(a)(1), acquire, purchase, subscribe for, dispose
of or transfer any shares, debentures, partnership interest or
other interests in or securities of (or any interest therein) any
Person, in one transaction or a series of related transactions, in
each case in excess of [*];
(iv) approve
Merial’s annual financial statements prior to their
submission to the Members’ Meeting;
46
(v) form, sell,
dissolve, liquidate or terminate any Merial Venture Company or take
any company action in connection therewith;
(vi) undertake or
terminate any major research or development program;
(vii) initiate or
settle any significant litigation or provide any undertaking
(except in the ordinary course of business) to a Public
Authority;
(viii) appoint,
remove or replace any of the Executive Officers;
(ix) enter into
any agreement providing for (A) the sale or licensing out of
any potentially significant Intellectual Property; or (B) the
purchase or licensing in of any Intellectual Property involving the
payment or potential payment of more than [*];
(x) change any of
the accounting principles or practices to be applied in the
preparation of financial statements or change Merial’s
accounting reference date;
(xi) determine the
remuneration and other terms and conditions of employment of any of
the Executive Officers of Merial, except as applicable to employees
generally;
(xii) enter into
(except for the Ancillary Agreements to be entered into as provided
in this Agreement) or terminate or amend or waive any material term
or condition under any contract or transaction between any Merial
Venture Company, on the one hand, and either an RP Company or a
Merck Company, on the other;
(xiii) provide any
loan or advance or credit (other than customary trade credit) to,
or incur any guarantee, surety, indemnity, Encumbrance or other
obligation in favor of, any RP Company or Merck Company;
47
(xiv) make
aggregate (across all Merial Venture Companies) charitable
contributions in any year in excess of [*];
(xv) enter into,
or terminate or amend or waive any material term or condition
under, any employment or other contract with any Executive Officer
or with any other employee of Merial whose annual emoluments are
reasonably expected to exceed [*], create or adopt new employee
benefit or general bonus plans or materially amend existing
employee benefit or bonus plans, except as required to comply with
the terms of this Agreement, or make loans or severance payments to
employees except in accordance with policies previously approved by
the Board of Directors or with the terms of this
Agreement;
(xvi) approve and
implement, or disapprove, any corrective, preventive or remedial
plan in response to an Environmental Liability at any site where
the total projected costs of such plan (including all phases of
such plan responding to the Environmental Liability) at such site
are expected to exceed [*];
(xvii) the
issuance by any Subsidiary of Merial of any equity securities or
interests, or any options, warrants or other rights to acquire such
equity securities or interests; and
(xviii) any other
matter required by applicable Laws to be decided upon or approved
by the Board of Directors.
(b)
Formation and Members of the Board of Directors . At the
Closing, a Board of Directors shall be formed for Merial which
shall consist of six (6) members. Three (3) members shall
be appointed by the RP Member and three (3) members shall be
appointed by the Merck Member, each for a term of office of six
(6) years (each, a “Director”, and together, the
“Directors”). The right of the RP Member and the Merck
Member to appoint Directors shall include the right to remove and
to replace Directors they have each appointed.
48
(c)
Executive Officers not Directors . None of the Executive
Officers shall be Directors or shall have the right to vote at any
meeting of the Board of Directors.
(d)
Executive Chairman and CEO to be Observers . Unless the
Board of Directors expressly decides otherwise with respect to a
particular matter or meeting, the Executive Chairman and, for so
long as there is one, the CEO shall be observers of the Board of
Directors, with the right to be notified of, to attend and to be
heard at every meeting of the Board of Directors.
(e)
Agenda for and Chairing of Meetings . The agenda for
meetings of the Board of Directors shall be prepared by the
secretary of Merial and shall include all matters proposed by
either Member. Each meeting of the Board of Directors shall be
chaired by one Director, who shall be named in the agenda for the
meeting. The Closing Meeting shall be chaired by a Director
nominated by IM. The following meeting of the Board of Directors
shall be chaired by a Director nominated by Merck SH and,
thereafter, each meeting shall alternatively be chaired by a
Director appointed by the RP Member and a Director appointed by the
Merck Member.
(f)
Quorum in Meetings of the Board of Directors, Unanimous Vote
. A quorum shall exist in a meeting of the Board of Directors if at
least four (4) Directors, two (2) nominees of the RP
Member and two (2) nominees of the Merck Member, are present
or represented. Resolutions of the Board of Directors shall only be
valid if passed unanimously by all the Directors present at a
meeting.
(g) New
Meeting in Case of Inability to Reach a Decision . If, with
respect to a specific matter, the Board of Directors is unable to
reach a decision in a meeting of the Board of Directors, then any
Director has the right to request a new meeting to discuss the same
matter. Such new meeting of the Board of Directors shall occur
within thirty (30) days after the date of the last
meeting.
(h)
Deadlock, Conciliation . If, at such second meeting of the
Board of Directors, unanimity cannot be reached and the Board of
Directors is still deadlocked,
49
within seven
(7) days after such meeting the matter shall be referred for
resolution pursuant to the terms of Section 18.1 to the RP
Animal Health Executive and the Merck Animal Health
Executive.
(i)
Meetings of the Board of Directors . The Board of Directors
shall meet at least three (3) times per calendar year and at
such other times as may be requested by any Director. Meetings
shall be in person and take place at the registered office of
Merial or in any other manner by which all persons participating in
the meeting may hear and speak to each other, unless all of the
Directors agree otherwise. Alternatively, decisions of the Board of
Directors may be taken by unanimous written resolution of all the
then-incumbent Directors.
(j)
Minutes of Meetings of the Board of Directors . All meetings
of the Board of Directors shall be recorded in minutes reflecting
the place and date of the meeting, the participants therein, the
items on the agenda, the material contents of discussions and the
resolutions adopted by the Board of Directors. The minutes shall be
signed by the Director chairing the meeting pursuant to
Section 4.3(e) and by at least one Director nominated by the
other Member, and a copy of the minutes shall be delivered to each
Director, to each Member, to the Executive Chairman and, for so
long as there is one, to the CEO.
Subject to the
general oversight and authority of the full Board of Directors, the
following committees of the Board of Directors shall be established
and maintained:
(i) an Audit
Committee, which shall consist of four persons appointed by the
Board of Directors, two of whom shall be appointed by each of the
Members and which shall be responsible for (aa) reviewing the
accounts and accounting policies of Merial, (bb) meeting with
Merial’s auditor(s) to review accounting issues,
(cc) discussing potential distributions, and (dd) for
presenting the yearly financial statements of Merial to the Board
of Directors for its
50
consideration,
and shall have such powers as the Board of Directors may delegate
to it from time to time;
(ii) a
Compensation Committee, which shall consist of four persons two of
whom shall be appointed by each of the Members, and which shall be
responsible for reviewing the executive and employee compensation
policies of Merial and for proposing employee benefit plans and
arrangements to the Board of Directors for its consideration, and
shall have such powers as the Board of Directors may delegate to it
from time to time;
(iii) a Financing
Committee, which shall consist of four persons two of whom shall be
appointed by each of the Members, and which shall be responsible
for reviewing the financing policies of Merial, including generally
Merial’s capital and debt structure, capital expenditures and
other matters of a financial and tax nature to be discussed by the
Board of Directors, and for presenting resolutions relating to
financing to the Board of Directors for its consideration, and
shall have such powers as the Board of Directors may delegate to it
from time to time; and
(iv) an Executive
Committee, of two persons, consisting of one Director appointed by
each of the Members, and which shall assist the Executive Chairman,
the CEO, and the Board of Directors in order to facilitate and
expedite decision making by the Board of Directors, and shall have
such powers as the Board of Directors may delegate to it from time
to time.
The Board of
Directors may delegate any of its powers to any other committee,
temporary or permanent, as it deems appropriate.
(1)
Limitations on Directors’ Duties. Merck agrees that it
shall not (and shall cause its Subsidiaries not to), in relation to
any Directors appointed by the RP Member, and RP agrees that it
shall not (and shall cause its Subsidiaries not to), in relation to
any Directors appointed by the Merck Member, take any action
against such Director for negligence, default, breach of duty or
breach of trust on the grounds that such negligence,
51
default, breach
of duty or breach of trust arose by virtue of the Director acting
in accordance with the instructions of the Member appointing such
Director. Merck, the Merck Member, RP and the RP Member agree that,
in the event of any Director acting in accordance with the
instructions, or in the interests of, the Member appointing such
Director, then any resultant dispute shall be considered to be a
dispute between the Parties to be resolved exclusively in
accordance with the provisions of Article XVIII
hereof.
SECTION 4.4.
The Executive Chairman. CEO and other Executive
Officers
(a)
Day-to-Day Management of the Merial Venture . Except for
matters requiring the approval of the Members’ Meeting or of
the Board of Directors, and subject to the decisions of the
Members’ Meeting and of the Board of Directors, the Executive
Chairman of Merial (the “Executive Chairman”) shall
have the responsibility and authority to manage and operate the
day-to-day business of Merial with the assistance of the other
Executive Officers and in accordance with Merial’s current
annual budget and Business Plan.
(b)
Appointment of the Executive Chairman
(i) The Executive
Chairman’s term of office shall have a duration of two
years.
(ii) The Person
designated as initial Executive Chairman (the “Initial
Chairman”) in Schedule 4.4 shall be nominated by the
Merck Member and shall be appointed as Executive Chairman of Merial
as of the Closing Date. At the expiry of his term of office, the
parties intend that the Initial Chairman shall no longer be an
officer or employee of the Merial Venture and at that time may
return to a position within Merck. At the expiry of the Initial
Chairman’s term of office, a new Executive Chairman shall be
appointed by the RP Member, subject to the consent of the Merck
Member (which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld). The RP
Member shall communicate in writing its choice of
Executive
52
Chairman to the
Merck Member at the latest one (1) month prior to the end of
the Initial Chairman’s term of office.
(iii) Subsequent
Executive Chairmen shall be appointed by the Board of Directors,
which shall also have the right to remove and replace the Executive
Chairman.
(c)
Responsibilities of the Executive Chairman . The Executive
Chairman shall be the head of the executive organization of the
Merial Venture and (subject to Sections 4.2(b) and 4.3(a))
shall have the full authority to represent and bind Merial. The
Initial Chairman appointed pursuant to the first sentence of
Section 4.4(b)(ii) shall, in particular, be responsible for
overseeing and managing the research and development and corporate
staff functions and Poultry Genetics Business activities of the
Merial Venture. The Executive Chairman shall also be responsible
for strategic planning, including the preparation and presentation
to the Board of Directors of Merial’s annual budget and its
rolling three (3) year business plan (the “Business
Plan”). The Business Plan shall set forth the goals,
strategies and action plans of the Merial Venture over the current
Fiscal Year and the two succeeding Fiscal Years, and shall include
sub-plans for investment, research and development, manufacturing,
marketing and personnel. The Members may at any time alter the
duration or scope of the Business Plan. The Executive Chairman
shall report to the Board of Directors.
(d)
Appointment of other Executive Officers . Merial shall have
such other executive officers in addition to the Executive Chairman
(together with the Executive Chairman, each an “Executive
Officer” and, collectively, the “Executive
Officers”) as shall be determined by the Board of Directors
after receiving the recommendation of the Executive Chairman (it
being understood that the Board of Directors may nominate Executive
Officers other than those recommended by the Executive Chairman).
The list of initial Executive Officers is set forth in
Schedule 4.4. The Board of Directors shall have the power to
appoint, remove and replace any of the Executive
Officers.
53
(e)
Appointment of the Chief Executive Officer (the
“CEO”) . The person designated as CEO in
Schedule 4.4 shall be nominated by the RP Member and shall be
appointed as CEO of Merial for a two year term of office as of the
Closing Date. At the expiry of such term of office, unless the
Board of Directors expressly decides otherwise, the position of CEO
shall be terminated, and all the responsibilities of the CEO shall
be combined with those of the Executive Chairman.
(f)
Responsibilities of the CEO . The CEO appointed pursuant to
Section 4.4(e) shall be responsible for overseeing and
managing the sales, marketing and manufacturing activities of the
Merial Venture, and shall have other specific responsibilities and
authority as delegated to him from time to time by the Executive
Chairman. The CEO shall report to the Executive
Chairman.
54
CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE MERIAL
VENTURE
SECTION 5.1.
Contributions of Assets and Assumption of
Liabilities
(a) Merck
Contribution . On the terms and subject to the conditions of
this Agreement (and subject specifically to the representations,
warranties and covenants made by Merck in this Agreement) and the
Merck Transfer Agreement, and subject to subsections (i),
(ii) and (iii) below and to Sections 11.2(c) and 11.6,
(x) Merck shall, on or prior to the Closing Date or as soon
thereafter as practicable as provided in Section 5.1(a)(ii),
assign, transfer, convey and deliver (by merger, sale or otherwise)
to Merial or its Subsidiaries, or cause to be assigned,
transferred, conveyed and delivered (by merger, sale or otherwise)
to Merial or its Subsidiaries, all of the Merck Contributed Assets,
and (y) Merial (or its relevant Subsidiary) shall, on the
Closing Date, assume and agree to pay, perform, fulfill and
discharge when due all of the Merck Contributed
Liabilities.
(i) U.S. Assets
and Liabilities . Merck shall, on or prior to the Closing Date,
assign, transfer, convey and deliver to Merck Transitory LLC:
(A) the entirety of the assets and liabilities of Hubbard
Farms, Inc., together with all of Hubbard Farms, Inc.’s
direct and indirect ownership interests in each of its Subsidiaries
except as indicated in Schedule 2-8 (such transaction to be
effected in accordance with Section 1.3(a)(i)(B)), (B) to the
extent indicated in Schedules 10.12 and 10.13, all of the Product
Registrations and trademark registrations and trademark
applications included in the Merck Contributed Assets that are
owned by Merck or a Subsidiary of Merck that is a U.S. Person,
(C) all other Merck Contributed Assets not covered by
(A) and (B) above that are located in or registered in
the U.S., including real estate or personal property, or that are
owned by Merck or a Subsidiary of Merck that is a U.S. Person
(other than the Retained Receivables and the Retained Inventory, as
defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(C)), (D) all of the
contracts included in the Merck Contributed Assets to which Merck
or a Subsidiary of Merck that is a U.S. Person is a party (the
assets
55
listed in
(A) through (D) together being the “Merck
Contributed U.S. Assets”). Merck Transitory LLC shall, on or
prior to the Closing Date, assume and agree to pay, perform,
fulfill and discharge when due all of the Merck Contributed
Liabilities reasonably attributable to the Merck Contributed U.S.
Assets contributed to Merck Transitory LLC or their ownership or
operation. The Parties understand that the contribution of the
entirety of the assets and liabilities of Hubbard Farms, Inc. to
Merck Transitory LLC will result in Merial being engaged in both
the Animal Health Business and the Poultry Genetics Business.
Merial shall create separate divisions within the Merial Venture
for each of these businesses and shall prepare stand-alone
financial statements for each division.
(ii) Non-U.S.
Assets and Liabilities .
(A) Purchase of
Assets and Assumption of Liabilities .
(1)
Valuation. Prior to the Closing, the Principals will agree
on the aggregate fair market value of all the Merck Contributed
Non-U.S. Assets (other than the cash and cash equivalent items
included in such assets) net of the Merck Contributed Liabilities
(other than the Merck Contributed Debt and the Merck Accrued Tax
Liabilities (as defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B)) reasonably
attributable to such assets that will be purchased by Merial or any
of its Subsidiaries (such value, after netting, being the
“Merck Non-U.S. Net Assets Value”). For purposes of
calculating the Merck Non-U.S. Net Assets Value, [*]
56
(2) Purchasing
Entity . Merial or the appropriate Merial Subsidiaries agreed
upon by the Principals (which generally shall be the Merial
Subsidiaries located in the country in which each such asset is to
be used) shall purchase each Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Asset from
the Merck Subsidiary that owns such asset. Merial shall, and shall
cause each of its Subsidiaries that has purchased any Merck
Contributed Non-U.S. Assets to, on the Closing Date, assume and
agree to pay, perform, fulfill and discharge when due all of the
Merck Contributed Liabilities reasonably attributable to
57
such purchased
Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets or their ownership or
operation.
(3)
Consideration for Purchase . The aggregate consideration for
the Merck Non-U.S. Assets shall be cash in an amount equal to the
Merck Cash Contribution Amount as defined in and contributed by
Merck pursuant to Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B) and/or promissory
notes issued to the selling Merck Subsidiaries, in accordance with
the provisions of this Section 5.1(a)(ii)(A)(3). To the extent
the actual aggregate purchase price paid for all the Merck
Contributed Non-U.S. Assets pursuant to clause (1) above
exceeds the Merck Cash Contribution Amount (as defined in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B)), or to the extent the Principals
otherwise agree, purchases of the Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets
by Merial and the Merial Subsidiaries may be made with promissory
notes issued to the selling Merck Subsidiaries.
(4) Timing of
Purchase . Each of the Parties shall (and shall procure that
their respective Subsidiaries shall) cooperate and use commercially
reasonable efforts (x) to give effect to, on the Closing Date,
the purchase and sale of all the Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets
and the assumption of the Merck Contributed Liabilities reasonably
attributable thereto in accordance with this
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(A), and (y) to the extent it is not
possible (including by reason of not having obtained required
approvals from appropriate Public Authorities and/or having
completed workers’ council consultations or similar processes
under applicable Laws) or reasonably practicable to purchase and
sell certain Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets or to assume the
Merck Contributed Liabilities reasonably attributable thereto
effective as of the Closing Date, to give effect to the purchase
and sale of each such asset and the assumption of such Liabilities
(the “Delayed Purchase Assets”)
58
in accordance
with this Section 5.l(a)(ii)(A) as soon as reasonably
practicable following the Closing.
(5) Expenses of
Purchase . Each of the purchase agreements giving effect to the
purchase of Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets (whether concurrently
with or after the Closing) shall provide that all of the costs and
expenses associated with such purchase (other than the specified
consideration for such purchase), including the costs and expenses
of counsel and other advisors, and all registration, transfer or
stamp duties and other comparable duties and Taxes, but excluding
any allocation for salaries, shall be paid by the seller (Merck or
a Merck Subsidiary, as the case may be), and that to the extent any
of such costs or expenses has been incurred by the purchaser or any
of its Affiliates (Merial or a Merial Subsidiary, as the case may
be), the seller shall indemnify the payor thereof for such costs or
expenses.
(B) Merck Cash
Contribution Amount . Merck shall, on or prior to the Closing
Date, contribute cash to Merck Transitory LLC in an amount (the
“Merck Cash Contribution Amount”) equal to the amount,
if any, by which the Merck Non-U.S. Net Assets Value exceeds the
“Merck Estimated Available Contributed Debt”, as
defined below. The “Merck Estimated Available Contributed
Debt” shall be the amount equal to [*] (the “Merck
Negotiated Debt”) plus an estimate of the “Merck
Closing Cash” (as defined below) less the sum of
(w) an estimate of the “Merck Accrued Tax
Liabilities” (as defined below), (x) an estimate of the
“Merck Other Debt” (as defined below), (y) the
value of the Retained Receivables (as defined in Section
5.1(a)(ii)(C)) and (z) the value of the Retained Inventory (as
defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(C)).
The “Merck
Closing Cash” shall be equal to the cash and the fair market
value of cash equivalent items that are included in the
Merck
59
Contributed
Assets, but shall exclude the Merck Asset Sale Proceeds, as defined
in Section 10.9(a).
The “Merck
Accrued Tax Liabilities” shall be the amount equal to the net
(after netting the payables and the receivables) accrued
Liabilities for Taxes (excluding deferred Taxes) to the extent they
are Merck Contributed Liabilities at the Closing Date.
The “Merck
Other Debt” shall be the amount of Debt at the Closing
assumed or otherwise payable by Merck Transitory LLC, Merial or any
Merial Subsidiary (without duplication) in favor of Merck (or
another Merck Company designated by Merck) or the Debt payable to a
Third Party assumed from a Merck Company or owed at the Closing by
any Merck Transferred Subsidiary, other than the amount of Debt
consisting of the promissory notes (the “Purchase Promissory
Notes”) issued by Merial or the appropriate Merial
Subsidiaries to purchase Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets, the
Retained Receivables and the Retained Inventory pursuant to
Sections 5.1(a)(ii)(A)(3), 5.1(a)(ii)(C)(l) or
5.1(a)(ii)(C)(2), respectively.
(C) Retained
Receivables and Retained Inventory .
(1) Retained
Receivables . Merck may (in its sole discretion) elect to
retain (i.e. , not contribute as part of the Merck
Contributed U.S. Assets) certain of its Receivables (the
“Retained Receivables”) selected by it from among the
Receivables that are part of the Merck Contributed U.S. Assets, at
face value. To the extent Merck elects to retain Retained
Receivables: Merck shall deliver to RP at the Closing a list of the
Retained Receivables, which list shall include a description in
reasonable detail including the face amount of each such Retained
Receivable. Merck shall use commercially reasonable efforts to
collect all Retained Receivables within ninety (90) days
following the Closing Date. After such
60
ninety
(90) day period, Merck shall furnish to Merial a list of all
Retained Receivables that remain uncollected, together with all
information and supporting documentation which Merck has for each
such uncollected Retained Receivable; and Merial shall within five
(5) Business Days of receiving such list, information and
documentation, purchase all such outstanding Retained Receivables
from Merck at the face amount thereof (calculated in U.S.$ at the
closing midpoint exchange rates quoted by the London edition of the
Financial Times on the Closing Date). Such purchase shall be
made, at Merial’s option, with cash and/or with promissory
notes issued to the seller.
(2) Retained
Inventory. Merck may (in its sole discretion) elect to retain
(i.e. , not contribute as part of the Merck Contributed U.S.
Assets) certain of its finished goods Inventory (the
“Retained Inventory”) selected by it from among the
finished goods Inventory of the Merck Contributed U.S. Assets. To
the extent Merck elects to retain any Retained Inventory, Merck
shall deliver to RP at the Closing a list of the Retained
Inventory, which list shall include a description in reasonable
detail including a breakdown of the value of such Retained
Inventory. For purposes of calculation in this Section 5.1(a),
the value attributed to the Retained Inventory shall be calculated
in accordance with the Merck Manufacturing Supply Price Formula. On
the Closing Date, Merial shall purchase the Retained Inventory from
Merck with promissory notes at a fair market value price that to
the extent possible excludes any intercompany (between Merck
Companies) margin already included in the book value for such
Inventories as recorded in the accounts of the selling Merck
Company, except for the markup on standard cost and the adjustment
provided for in the Merck Negotiated Supply Price. To the extent
the Inventories cannot be purchased at a fair market value price
that excludes any such margin, the Parties shall
61
use
commercially reasonable efforts and negotiate in good faith to find
and give effect to a solution (which will not include taking
actions that would reduce Merck’s net income below that which
Merck would realize if such Inventories were sold at a price
calculated according to the Merck Negotiated Supply Price) that
will eliminate the effect of the purchase of such Retained
Inventory at a price that includes such margin on the net income of
RP. To the extent the price at which the Merial Venture ultimately
purchases the Retained Inventory exceeds the Merck Negotiated
Supply Price, such excess shall be included in the calculation of
the Supply Price Adjustment Special Dividend, pursuant to
Section 6.7.
(D)
Non-Contributed Subsidiaries . The Parties hereby agree that
none of Merck’s interests in Johnson & Johnson MSD
Consumer Pharmaceuticals (formerly Centra Healthcare (U.K.)) or
Blue Jay CV (Holland) shall be contributed to the Merial Venture.
Merck shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless the Merial Venture
and (only to the extent RP and its Subsidiaries suffer Damages
separate and distinct from Damages suffered by the Merial Venture)
RP and its Subsidiaries from and against any and all Damages
incurred by the Merial Venture or RP and its Subsidiaries arising
out of, based upon or resulting from an action or claim brought by
a Third Party to the extent arising out of, based upon or resulting
from the past, present or future operations of Johnson &
Johnson MSD Consumer Pharmaceuticals (formerly Centra Healthcare
(U.K.)) or Blue Jay CV (Holland).
(E) Delayed
Purchase Assets . Pending the purchase and sale of a Delayed
Purchase Asset and the assumption of the Merck Contributed
Liabilities reasonably attributable thereto in accordance with
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(A) (collectively, a “Delayed
Transfer”):
62
(1) Merck shall
(or shall cause the relevant Merck Subsidiary to) hold all benefits
of such Delayed Purchase Assets to the extent related to the Merial
Venture Business as agent for the Merial Venture and promptly pay
to Merial (or a Merial Subsidiary that is the expected purchaser of
such assets as designated by Merial) without any deduction, set-off
or counterclaim, any and all net sums (after netting any amounts
contemplated by clause (2) below to the extent not previously
paid or reimbursed by the Merial Venture) received by the Merck
Company on account of the operation of such Assets; and
(2) Merial shall
(or shall cause the relevant Merial Subsidiary to) (at the Merial
Venture’s own cost and for its own account) pay, perform,
fulfill and discharge when due all of the Liabilities, costs,
expenses and obligations suffered or incurred by Merck or any of
its Subsidiaries in respect of the ownership or operation of such
Delayed Purchase Asset from the Closing Date until the Delayed
Transfer of such Delayed Purchase Asset; provided ,
however , that Merck (or the relevant Merck Subsidiary)
shall be responsible for any Damages payable to a Third Party to
the extent such Damages result from Merck’s or any of its
Subsidiaries’ negligence, recklessness or willful misconduct
in the operation of such Delayed Purchase Asset, which negligence,
recklessness or willful misconduct occurred prior to the Delayed
Transfer of such Delayed Purchase Asset.
No effect shall be
given to clauses (i) or (ii) above if and to the extent
that there is a significant risk that such arrangements would not
be in material compliance with applicable Laws if effect were given
thereto, in which case the principles set forth in clause
(y) of Section 5.1(a)(ii)(A)(4) shall apply, and the
Principals and Merial shall cooperate to seek an alternative
solution designed to provide the Merial Venture with the
63
material benefits
(or the substantial equivalent of the benefits of) such Assets and
Liabilities.
(iii)
British United Turkeys, Ltd (“BUT”)
(A) Merck shall, subject to the condition specified in
(B) immediately below, assign, transfer, convey and deliver to
Merck Transitory LLC the entirety of the share capital of BUT;
provided , however , that (B) if, as a result of
implementing the “BUT Steps”, as defined below, any
Merck Company would or would be reasonably likely to recognize
taxable gain in excess of [*] with respect to the BUT Steps under
the terms of (aa) any amendment to Code § 355 and/or the
Treasury Regulations thereunder adopted on or after the date hereof
and prior to the Closing, (bb) any proposal of any such
legislation or Treasury Regulations made since January 1,
1997, or (cc) any official notice or pronouncement with
respect thereto made since January 1, 1997, in the case of any
of (aa), (bb) and (cc), indicating that such amendment would
have an effective date that would make it applicable to the BUT
Steps, the Parties agree that BUT will be transferred directly to
Merial by Merck Sharp & Dohme (Holdings) Limited in return for
an issue of fixed-rate preference shares (the “Preference
Shares”) with a face amount of [*]. The Parties acknowledge
that, in either case, BUT shall not be treated as part of the Merck
Contributed Non-U.S. Assets pursuant to clause (ii) above. The
Parties further agree that, if Merial issues such Preference Shares
to Merck Sharp & Dohme (Holdings) Limited, Merial will issue
Preference Shares with a face amount of [*] to IM in consideration
for IM’s contribution to Merial hereunder of shares of RM
with a fair market value equal to the fair market value of the
Preference Shares received. The Parties agree that, after said
issue, and all other Closing Date share transactions and events,
each Principal shall own, directly or indirectly, exactly the same
general ownership interest and Preference Share interest in
Merial.
For purposes of
this Section 5.1(a)(iii), the “BUT Steps” shall
mean all or any part of the following: the distribution of the
shares of BUT by its shareholder(s), followed by additional
distribution to shareholders, followed by a
64
contribution of
the shares of BUT to Merck Transitory LLC, followed by the merger
of Merck Transitory LLC with and into Merial. Whether any Merck
Company would or would be reasonably likely to recognize taxable
gain in excess of [*] with respect to the BUT Steps shall be
determined in the good faith judgment of Merck, after having
provided to RP all material and relevant information which is
reasonably available to Merck.
If Preference
Shares are issued pursuant to clause 5.1(a)(iii)(B) above, the
Preference Shares shall remain outstanding in perpetuity (unless
and until Merial is liquidated). The Preference Shares shall be
entitled to an annual dividend per share such that the aggregate
outstanding Preference Shares shall be entitled to an annual
dividend of: [*], which shall be paid out of Distributable Profits
for each Fiscal Year remaining after payment of the Net Special
Dividend, as provided in Section 6.2, and which dividend shall
be cumulative (but shall be paid in any event after payment of the
Net Special Dividend, as provided in Section 6.2). The
Preference Shares shall have the liquidation rights specified in
Section 6.11. The Preference Shares shall not be entitled to
any voting rights, except any voting rights which are required
under applicable Laws. The Preference Shares shall not be
transferable, except in connection with a Transfer of a
Member’s entire Merial Venture Interest in accordance with
Article XVII hereof. The Association Documents shall be
modified to the extent reasonably necessary or appropriate to
implement this Section 5.1(a)(iii).
(b) RP
Contribution . On the terms and subject to the conditions of
this Agreement (and subject specifically to the representations,
warranties and covenants made by RP, IM and RM in this Agreement)
and the RP Transfer Agreement, and subject to subsections (i),
(ii) and (iii) below, IM shall, on or prior to the
Closing Date, assign, transfer, convey and deliver to Merial or
cause to be assigned, transferred, conveyed and delivered to
Merial, the entirety of the share capital of RM, together with all
of RM’s direct and indirect ownership interests in each of
its Subsidiaries as set forth in Schedule 2-11 hereto. As a
consequence, and without limitation, Subsidiaries of
Merial
65
shall thereby
be obligated to pay, perform, fulfill and discharge when due all of
the RM Contributed Liabilities.
(i) Goubin
. The Parties intend that Goubin shall be sold either (x) by the
Merial Venture, in which case Merial shall (and shall procure that
the other Merial Venture Companies shall) cooperate with RP and
provide any information or assistance reasonably requested by RP to
find a purchaser for Goubin, or (y) by RP, should RP exercise
its call option described in (B) below.
(A) Goubin
Operations Pending Sale . RP hereby represents, as of the date
hereof and as of the Closing Date, to Merck, Merck SH and Merial
that, since December 31, 1996, Goubin has been operated in the
ordinary course of business (including capital expenditures made in
accordance with approved programs) consistent with past practice
and there has not been any material change in the assets or
Liabilities of Goubin (other than the payment of dividends and such
approved programs of capital expenditures), including any material
contribution of assets by RM or ISA of any kind to Goubin, as
compared with the balance sheet of Goubin as of December 31,
1996 set forth in Schedule 5.1B-1. For purposes of this
Section 5.1(b)(i), a “material” contribution of
assets means a contribution of assets in excess of [*]. Merial
covenants that, as of the Closing Date and until the second
anniversary of the Closing Date, or the sale of Goubin if earlier,
it shall not cause Goubin to take any action that is outside the
ordinary course of business consistent with past practice and shall
not cause Goubin to incur any additional Debt, except in the
ordinary course of business, as compared with the Debt of Goubin as
of the Closing Date, provided that Merial may, upon RP’s
request and subject to the consent of Merck (which consent shall
not be unreasonably withheld), cause an action out of the ordinary
course to be taken or a material contribution of assets to be made
if necessary to facilitate the sale of Goubin. RP shall indemnify
the Merial Venture for any costs and expenses incurred by the
Merial Venture in connection with, and shall defend,
66
indemnify and
hold harmless the Merial Venture for any Damages incurred by the
Merial Venture as a result of, any such action and/or material
contribution. RP shall also defend, indemnify and hold harmless the
Merial Venture for any and all Damages (but not for any capital
accounting loss recorded by the Merial Venture in selling Goubin in
accordance with this Section 5.1(b)(i)) arising out of the
operation or condition of Goubin before the earlier of (x) the
sale of Goubin and (y) the second anniversary of the Closing Date
(except for any such Damages payable to a Third Party other than
the purchaser (or its Affiliates) of Goubin, to the extent
resulting from the negligence, recklessness or willful misconduct
of the Merial Venture, including that of the management of
Goubin).
(B) Purchaser
and Timing of Goubin Sale .
(1) At any time on
or prior to the second anniversary of the Closing Date, if a firm
offer to purchase Goubin is received from a Third Party (which may
include the employees of Goubin) at a price that is acceptable to
RP and that is greater than or equal to the Goubin Book Value at
the Closing Date plus any amounts contributed by any other Merial
Venture Company to Goubin pursuant to Section 5.1(b)(i) that
have not been reimbursed by RP, less the sum of [*] (translated
into FF at the closing midpoint exchange rate indicated in the
London edition of the Financial Times on the Closing Date)
and all the dividends paid by Goubin to any other Merial Venture
Company between the Closing Date and the date when such offer is
received, then the Merial Venture shall sell Goubin to such
purchaser.
(2) At any time on
or prior to the second anniversary of the Closing Date, RP shall
have the option to purchase Goubin from the Merial Venture for an
amount equal to the Goubin Book Value at the Closing Date plus any
amounts contributed by any other Merial Venture Company to Goubin
pursuant to Section 5.1(b)(i) that have not been reimbursed by
RP,
67
less the sum of
[*] (translated into FF at the closing midpoint exchange rate
indicated in the London edition of the Financial Times on
the Closing Date) and all the dividends paid by Goubin to any other
Merial Venture Company between the Closing and the exercise by RP
of its call option. If such purchase results in a capital loss to
the Merial Venture, RP shall not sell Goubin to a Third Party at a
profit (to the RP Group) for a period of six months after the
exercise of such option. For the avoidance of doubt, the Parties
understand that the ownership by RP and the operation of the
current business of Goubin in accordance with this
Section 5.1(b)(i) is not within the scope of the Animal Health
Business or the Poultry Genetics Business and is therefore not
subject to the non-competition provisions set forth in
Article XV.
(3) On or within
two Business Days after the second anniversary of the Closing Date,
if Goubin has not been sold to a Third Party or RP as provided in
(1) or (2) above, then Merck will have the option, which
it may exercise in its own discretion (by notice to RP and Merial
sent at any time prior to the end of the second Business Day after
the second anniversary of the Closing Date, which notice may be
conditioned upon the transactions in (1) or (2) above
occurring or not occurring) and will be binding on both Merial and
RP, to require Merial (or the Merial Venture Company that owns
Goubin) to sell Goubin to RP for an amount equal to the Goubin Book
Value at Closing Date plus any amounts contributed by any other
Merial Venture Company to Goubin pursuant to Section 5.1(b)(i)
that have not been reimbursed by RP, less the sum of [*]
(translated into FF at the closing midpoint exchange rate indicated
in the London edition of the Financial Times on the Closing
Date) and all the dividends distributed by Goubin to any other
Merial Venture Company during the two year plus two Business Day
period following the Closing Date. If Merck does not exercise this
put option, Goubin shall continue as an integral part of the Merial
Venture Business after two years and the
68
indemnification
obligations of RP under this Section 5.1(b)(i) in connection
with the sale of Goubin shall terminate.
(C) Goubin Sale
for RP’s Account .
(1) Special
Dividend to RP . In the case of the sale of Goubin pursuant to
(B) above, Merial shall credit to the RP Member in respect of
the year in which the sale of Goubin occurs a Special Dividend
equal to the cash (or the fair market cash equivalent of any
non-cash proceeds) received by the Merial Venture (whether from a
Third Party purchaser or from RP) for the sale of Goubin, less any
costs, expenses or Damages (including Taxes, fees and registration
fees) incurred by the Merial Venture in connection with such
sale.
(2) Purchase
Agreement, etc . The sale of Goubin shall be by means of the
sale of its entire capital stock, the sale of all its assets
subject to all its Liabilities, or any substantially similar
transaction; provided , however , that if the
Principals agree to a partial sale of Goubin, they shall adjust the
mechanism set forth in this Section 5.1(b)(i) as they deem
appropriate. Any sale of Goubin shall be without any recourse
against the Merial Venture except as to title matters and except as
to any Damages payable to a Third Party other than the purchaser
(or its affiliates) of Goubin to the extent resulting from the
negligence, recklessness or willful misconduct of the Merial
Venture, including of the management of Goubin. Subject to the
following sentence, all Damages, Liabilities and contingencies
associated with a sale of Goubin pursuant to this
Section 5.1(b)(i) above suffered or incurred by Merck, Merial
and their respective Subsidiaries shall be for the account of RP.
RP shall (and no Merial Venture Company shall), in any contract for
the sale of Goubin to a Third Party purchaser, undertake to
indemnify the purchaser thereof for all breaches of
representations, warranties or covenants in such contract related
to Goubin and its sale; provided that RP shall have approved
all of
69
such
representations, warranties and covenants prior to the contract
being concluded; and further provided that Merial
shall indemnify RP for any Damages owed to such Third Party
purchaser of Goubin to the extent arising from Damages payable to a
Third Party other than the purchaser (or its Affiliates) of Goubin
to the extent resulting from the negligence, recklessness or
willful misconduct of the Merial Venture, including of the
management of Goubin. Except to the extent Merial has an obligation
to indemnify RP pursuant to the preceding sentence, RP shall
defend, indemnify and hold harmless the Merial Venture and (to the
extent they suffer any Damages distinct from those suffered by the
Merial Venture) Merck and its Subsidiaries for all Damages suffered
or incurred by the Merial Venture or Merck and its Subsidiaries
arising out of, based upon or resulting from such sale.
The “Goubin
Book Value” at any date shall equal the book value of Goubin
on such date in the accounts of ISA, determined according to U.S.
GAAP applied consistently with the principles used to calculate
Goubin’s book value in the December 31, 1996 balance
sheet of ISA. RP represents and warrants that the insurance claim
made by Goubin with respect to damages in connection with a fire at
a hatchway in Plougenast ([*]) was finally resolved and paid to
Goubin prior to the date of this Agreement.
(ii) Certain RM
Liabilities and Receivables Excluded . Notwithstanding Sections
5.1(b) and (c), RM shall, prior to the Closing, (A) assign to
RP (or another RP Company designated by RP), and RP shall assume
and pay, perform and discharge when due, the payable to Sanofi of
RM, which is described on Schedule 5.1B-2 (the “Sanofi
Payable”), and (B) assign to RP (or another RP Company
designated by RP) the related financial receivable of RM due by
RM’s unconsolidated Subsidiary Rhône Mérieux Animal
Health Company Ltd. (China) (“RM China”), which is
described in Schedule 5.1B-2 (the “RM China Financial
Receivable”). In addition, as from the Closing Date, RP (or
another RP Company designated by RP) will be entitled to an amount
equal to the difference between
70
the Sanofi
Payable and the RM China Financial Receivable as of the Closing
Date ([*]), which amount will be paid by RM China to RP over time
only from and to the extent of the proceeds of specific assets that
are part of the current assets held by RM China as of the Closing
Date (the “RP Chinese Assets”). The RP Chinese Assets
shall consist of specific trade receivables, Inventories and/or
other current assets each as existing on the Closing Date in the
books of RM China. At the Closing, RM shall provide Merck with a
list and description in reasonable detail (including book value) of
the RP Chinese Assets. The aggregate book value of the RP Chinese
Assets shall be equal to or less than the difference between the
Sanofi Payable and the RM China Financial Receivable. The Parties
acknowledge that the RP Chinese Assets are specifically allocated
to the reimbursement of RP and that each time any of the RP Chinese
Assets is sold for cash or collected for cash by RM China, the net
proceeds of such asset will be used promptly upon their being
received to reimburse RP to the extent provided in this
Section 5.1(b)(ii). The Parties understand that the only
obligation of RM China is to sell or collect the RP Chinese Assets
in the ordinary course of business, without any extraordinary sale
or litigation and without recourse to, or any other obligation of,
the Merial Venture. RP represents and agrees that, as indicated in
Schedule 5.1B-2, at December 31, 1996, the amount
outstanding under the RM China Financial Receivable is [*]. The
Parties agree that such RM China Financial Receivable is deemed to
be Debt. The Parties further agree that in the event the aggregate
of the values of all the RP Chinese Assets as recorded in the books
of RM China on the Closing Date is less than the amount equal to
the difference between (x) the Sanofi Payable and (y) the
RM China Financial Receivable, the amount (the “RP Chinese
Assets Value Shortfall”) by which the book value of all the
RP Chinese Assets is less than such difference shall become a Debt
obligation payable by RM to RP and such amount shall be deemed to
be Debt. The Parties agree that the proceeds collected with respect
to each RP Chinese Asset that is paid to RP pursuant to this
Section 5.1(b)(ii) shall not exceed the value of each such RP
Chinese Asset as recorded in the books of RM China on the Closing
Date.
71
(iii) Central
Biologics Inc. RM represents that (x) Select Laboratories,
Inc., a Subsidiary of RM (“Select”), is currently in
the process of acquiring Central Biologics Inc. (“Central
Biologics”) for a purchase price of [*] (this acquisition
being the “Central Biologics Acquisition”); and
(y) as part of the Central Biologics Acquisition, [*]. The
Parties hereby agree that both the Central Biologics Acquisition
and the Central Biologics Consulting Agreement are entered into for
the account of Merial. As a result, the Parties further agree that
(aa) any Debt assumed by RM, Select or any other Subsidiary of
RM to acquire Central Biologics, (bb) any cash or cash
equivalents, if any, used by Select or any other Subsidiary of RM
to acquire Central Biologics shall be added to the RM Closing Cash
when determining the actual contributions of the Parties in
accordance with Sections 5.3 and 6.8, (cc) any cash or
cash equivalents included in Central Biologics upon completion of
its acquisition by RM, Select, or any Subsidiary of RM shall be
excluded from the RM Closing Cash, and (dd) any Debt included
in Central Biologics upon completion of its acquisition by RM,
Select or any other Subsidiary of RM, shall not be included in the
RP Outstanding Debt.
(c)
Contributed Assets Free of Debt . The Merck Contributed
Assets, on the one hand, and RM and its Subsidiaries, on the other
hand, shall be contributed to the Merial Venture together with the
assumption of or the continued obligation for the Merck Contributed
Liabilities and the RM Contributed Liabilities, respectively.
Except as set forth in Section 5.2 or as provided for in
Article VII, however, such respective contributions shall be
free of (i) any related financial indebtedness
(“Debt”), including any Liability, contingent or
otherwise, for borrowed money, any obligations in respect of or
evidenced by bonds, debentures, notes, letters of credit or similar
instruments and any obligations under finance lease obligations (as
defined by U.S. GAAP).
(d)
Currency Exchange for Asset Contributions . The respective
contributions of each Group to the Merial Venture shall be
calculated in U.S. dollars as of the Closing
72
Date. The value
of any contribution not denominated in U.S. dollars shall be
converted into U.S. dollars at the closing midpoint exchange rate
quoted by the London edition of the Financial Times on the
Closing Date, or as otherwise agreed upon. Subject to
Section 5.2(c), all other necessary currency conversions in
respect of the value of the respective contributions (e.g.,
to English pounds sterling or French francs) shall also be based on
the closing mid-point exchange rates quoted by the London edition
of the Financial Times on the Closing Date, or as otherwise
agreed upon.
SECTION 5.2
Debt Contributions
(a) Merck
Debt Contribution . On the terms and subject to the conditions
of this Agreement, Merial shall (or Merial shall, in accordance
with the terms of this Agreement, cause one or more Subsidiaries of
Merial to), on the Closing Date, assume on behalf of and/or in
favor of Merck or a Merck Subsidiary, and shall pay, perform and
discharge when due, all Liabilities related to the “Merck
Contributed Debt”, as defined below. The “Merck
Contributed Debt” shall consist of (and its aggregate amount
shall be calculated by adding the amounts of): (i) the
Purchase Promissory Notes, as defined in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B), if any, (ii) the Merck Accrued Tax
Liabilities, as defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B), and
(iii) the Merck Other Debt, as defined in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B). The Purchase Promissory Notes shall be
on substantially the same terms and conditions as the Merck Interim
Financing described in Section 5.2(d) (except that the
Purchase Promissory Notes shall not be subject to reborrowing to
the extent repaid, i.e., not a revolving credit).
(b) RP
Debt Contribution . On the terms and subject to the conditions
of this Agreement, RM and its Subsidiaries shall, on the Closing
Date, have Liability (the “RP Contributed Debt”)
(i) for Debt consisting of (and its aggregate amount shall be
calculated by adding the amounts of) the “RM Intercompany
Debt” (as defined below), the “RM Outstanding
Debt” (as defined below), the RM China Financial Receivable
and the RP Chinese Assets Value Shortfall, if any, and
(ii) for the “RM Accrued Tax Liabilities” (as
defined below).
73
The “RM
Intercompany Debt” shall be RM’s estimate as of the
Closing Date of the aggregate principal amount equal to: [*] (the
“RP Negotiated Debt”) plus the estimated amount
of “RM Closing Cash” (as defined below) and
minus the estimated sum of ( A ) the “RM
Outstanding Debt”, (B) the estimated net amount (after
netting the payables and the receivables) equal to the accrued
Liabilities for Taxes (excluding deferred Taxes) of RM and for RM
Transferred Subsidiaries at the Closing Date (the “RM Accrued
Tax Liabilities”), (C) the RM China Financial Receivable
as described in Section 5.1(b)(ii), and (D) without
duplication of (C), the RP Chinese Assets Value Shortfall (as
defined in Section 5.1(b)(ii)). The RM Intercompany Debt shall
not be subject to any covenants and shall be on substantially the
same terms and conditions as the RP Interim Financing described in
Section 5.2(d) (except that this Debt shall not be subject to
reborrowing to the extent repaid, i.e., not a revolving
credit).
The “RM
Outstanding Debt” shall consist of (x) the sum of the
aggregate principal amount outstanding at Closing and any accrued
unpaid interest or other amounts, calculated as of the Closing
Date, in respect of the Debt owed by RM or its Subsidiaries to
Third Parties as reflected on the December 31, 1996 balance
sheet included in the RM Financials, and (y) without
duplication of any Debt included in (x) above, any other Debt
owed by RM or its Subsidiaries at the Closing Date less
(without duplication) (aa) any Debt owed by Goubin on the
Closing Date, (bb) any Debt incurred by RM, Select or any
other Subsidiary of RM to pay for the Central Biologics
Acquisition, and (cc) any Debt owed by Central Biologics on
the Closing Date. RP shall obtain any consents or waivers required
under the terms of the RM Outstanding Debt to give effect to the
Transactions (so that the RM Outstanding Debt is not and does not
become in default and does not give the counterparty to any of the
RM Outstanding Debt any rights of termination, amendment,
acceleration, suspension, revocation or cancellation) and RP shall
pay any and all costs and expenses, including any increased
interest expenses, penalties or charges, necessary to obtain such
consents or waivers. Subject to the preceding sentence, the
“RM Outstanding Debt” shall continue on its stated
terms and conditions after the Closing.
74
The “RM
Closing Cash” shall be equal to the cash and the fair market
value of cash equivalent items contributed by RM and its
Subsidiaries to the Merial Venture, but shall exclude (aa) the
RM Asset Sale Proceeds, as defined in Section 8.9(a),
(bb) the cash and cash equivalents items owned by Goubin on
the Closing Date, (cc) any cash and cash equivalent items
owned by Central Biologics upon completion of its acquisition by
RM, Select or any other Subsidiary of RM, and (dd) any
proceeds from the Diagnostic Disposal.
In the event
Goubin is not sold pursuant to, and within the time periods
specified in, Section 5.1(b)(i) and remains part of the Merial
Venture, the Parties shall at such time negotiate in good faith to
find and give effect to a solution that will take account of the
Debt of, and the cash and cash equivalent items that were owned by,
Goubin on the Closing Date.
(c)
Currency Exchange for Contributed Debt . The currency
exchange rates used to calculate the U.S. dollar value of any Merck
Contributed Debt, Retained Receivables, Retained Inventory or RP
Contributed Debt not denominated in U.S. dollars shall be the
closing midpoint exchange rates quoted by the London edition of the
Financial Times on the Closing Date, or as otherwise agreed
between the Parties.
(d)
Interim Financing . Both RP and Merck shall provide, or
shall arrange with outside financial institutions to provide, the
Merial Venture with a revolving working capital financing facility
available when needed as from the Closing Date (the “RP
Interim Financing” and the “Merck Interim
Financing”, respectively), with a maximum aggregate principal
amount to be outstanding from time to time of [*] for each such
facility. Should Merial request an increase of the maximum
aggregate principal amount of the RP Interim Financing and the
Merck Interim Financing, RP and Merck agree to discuss in good
faith the terms and conditions of any such increase and whether any
such increase will be provided. The Parties agree that the RP
Interim Financing shall not be included in, and shall be in
addition to, the RP Contributed Debt and the Merck Interim
Financing shall not be included in, and shall be in addition to,
the Merck Contributed Debt. The RP Interim Financing and the Merck
Interim Financing shall have
75
substantially
equivalent terms and conditions, both be available through the
earlier of December 15, 1997 and the date that is six
(6) months after the Closing Date, at which earlier date all
amounts outstanding thereunder shall be due and payable, and bear
interest at the [*] in which the advances that are part of the
interim financing are made [*]. Merial shall use commercially
reasonable efforts to establish its own financing as soon as
practicable after the Closing to be used, first, to repay the RP
Contributed Debt and the Merck Contributed Debt, second, to repay
the RP Interim Financing and the Merck Interim Financing, with the
RP Interim Financing and the Merck Interim Financing being repaid
simultaneously on the same terms and conditions and, third, for
other purpose of the Merial Venture Business. The Principals shall
meet before the Closing to determine further terms and conditions
of the RP Interim Financing and the Merck Interim
Financing.
SECTION 5.3.
Preparation and Audit of Closing Balance Sheets
(a)
Preparation of Closing Balance Sheets — General. As
soon as possible after the Closing Date, and in no event more than
thirty (30) Days after the Closing Date, each of RM and Merck
shall prepare and deliver to each other a consolidated balance
sheet (the “RM Closing Balance Sheet” and the
“Merck Closing Balance Sheet”, respectively, and,
collectively, the “Closing Balance Sheets”) for RM and
the Merck Contributed Business, respectively. These balance sheets
shall include as special purpose line items (i) the RM Closing
Cash and the Merck Closing Cash, (ii) the RM Intercompany
Debt, the RM Outstanding Debt, the RM China Financial Receivable,
the RP Chinese Assets Value Shortfall and the Merck Other Debt, and
(iii) the RM Accrued Tax Liabilities and the Merck Accrued Tax
Liabilities. The RM Intercompany Debt, the RM Outstanding Debt, the
RM China Financial Receivable, the RP Chinese Assets Value
Shortfall, the RM Accrued Tax Liabilities and the RM Closing Cash
shall be used to calculate the “RM Actual Contributed Net
Debt Variance” and the “Contributed Debt Adjustment
Special Dividend”, both as defined in Section 6.8 below.
The Merck Accrued Tax Liabilities, the Merck Other Debt and the
Merck Closing Cash shall be used to calculate the “Merck
Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance” and the
“Contributed Debt Adjustment Special Dividend”, both as
defined in Section 6.8 below. Merck shall also provide RP with
a list
76
of all Delayed
Purchase Assets, which list shall include a description in
reasonable detail of all such Delayed Purchase Assets and an
estimate of the fair market value of all the Delayed Purchase
Assets on an aggregate basis.
(b) Audit
of Closing Balance Sheets and Retroactive Closing Financial
Statements . As soon as possible after the preparation of the
Closing Balance Sheets and the Retroactive Closing Financial
Statements, as defined in Section 6.3, Merck shall send the
Merck Closing Balance Sheet and the Merck Retroactive Closing
Financial Statements to its accounting firm and to RM, and RM shall
send the RM Closing Balance Sheet and the RM Retroactive Closing
Financial Statements to its accounting firm and to Merck. Each of
RM’s and Merck’s accounting firms shall promptly be
provided with any relevant financial data they may reasonably
request. Each of RM’s and Merck’s accounting firms
shall have a maximum of sixty (60) days to conduct an audit of
the Closing Balance Sheets and the Retroactive Closing Financial
Statements of their respective client, which audit shall include,
among other things, (x) an audit of the Debt and the cash and
the cash equivalent items contributed by each Party to the Merial
Venture, (y) at the request and expense of RP, an analysis of
whether or not all the Merck Contributed Assets are fairly
reflected in all material respects in the Merck Closing Balance
Sheet and, to the extent not included therein, have been specified
by Merck to RP as Delayed Purchase Assets, and (z) an audit of
the Retroactive Closing adjustments to ensure such adjustments have
been calculated in accordance with the provisions set forth in
Section 6.3 and in Exhibit XIX.
As soon as
possible, and in no event more than sixty (60) days after
being sent the Closing Balance Sheets and the Retroactive Closing
Financial Statements, each of RM’s and Merck’s
accounting firms shall make available to the other their working
papers, reports and comments on the Closing Balance Sheets and the
Retroactive Closing Financial Statements. In the event there are
any disagreements, the Parties will then have twenty
(20) Business Days to agree on the changes to be made to the
Closing Balance Sheets and/or the Retroactive Closing Financial
Statements and resolve any disputes arising between them. In the
event there is any unresolved dispute at the end of this twenty
(20) Business Day period, the Parties will jointly submit such
unresolved disputes
77
to the Board of
Directors. The Board of Directors shall then have ten
(10) Business Days to resolve such disputes. In the event
there are any unresolved disputes at the end of this further ten
(10) Business Day period, the Board of Directors shall have
five (5) Business Days to engage a “Big Six”
accounting firm to resolve any such dispute, except that
(i) if the Board of Directors cannot reach agreement on the
selection of such accounting firm, then such accounting firm shall
be selected and appointed by the ICE (which selection and
appointment shall be final and binding on the Board of Directors
and on the Principals) and (ii) the firm so selected and
appointed may not be the primary accounting firm for Merck, RP, RM
or Merial. Each of the Principals shall submit to the selected
accounting firm their detailed calculations and such firm shall
promptly be provided with any relevant financial data that it may
request. The selected accounting firm shall act as expert and shall
have twenty (20) Business Days to resolve all the disputes,
and such resolution shall be final and binding on the Parties and
the Board of Directors. The fees and reasonable expenses of the
selected accounting firm shall be split equally between Merck and
RP.
SECTION 5.4.
Alternative Tax Structuring and Tax Planning
(a)
Changes in Law . With respect to Merial or any other Merial
Venture Company, if, due to any change or proposed change in
applicable Law (including, without limitation, actions of any
Public Authority) after the Closing, the continuation of the
structure described in Section 1.3 and Article III
entails (or, in the case of a proposed change, would, if enacted,
entail) materially adverse tax or other legal consequences to a
Principal or its Affiliates, or a significant risk thereof, at the
request of such Principal the Parties shall use commercially
reasonable efforts to agree on an appropriate alternative structure
that will be designed, to the extent possible, to minimize such
adverse consequences to the requesting Principal and its Affiliates
but have no less favorable economic, commercial and legal
characteristics to the other Principal and its Affiliates as the
structure described elsewhere in this Agreement and the Ancillary
Agreements.
(b)
Restructurings to Minimize Taxes .
78
(i)
General . Each Party shall bear the tax consequences of its
transfers to the Merial Venture and (unless otherwise agreed in
writing) the performance of its obligations under this Agreement
and any and all Ancillary Agreements to which it is a party or by
which it is bound. [*].
(ii)
Alternative Contribution of Merck Contributed Non-U.S.
Assets . Without limiting the generality of
Section 5.4(b)(ii) and notwithstanding the provisions of
Sections 1.3(a)(i)(B), 1.3(c), and 5.1, and subject to the
conditions set forth in (t), (u), (v), (w), (x), (y) and
(z) below, Merck may elect to exclude from the Non-U. S. Merck
Contributed Assets to be sold to the Merial Venture and/or from the
Merck Contributed Liabilities reasonably attributable thereto
assumed by the Merial Venture, certain of such assets and
Liabilities [*], provided that (t) intangible assets
included in the Merck Contributed Assets may not be so excluded,
(u) Merck identifies in reasonable detail in writing to RP on
or prior to the Closing Date such assets and/or liabilities;
(v) an arrangement with respect to such assets and/or
liabilities is entered into among the Parties or their Affiliates
and/or other adjustments are made to the terms and conditions of
the transactions contemplated by this
79
Agreement so
that they have, in the aggregate, no less favorable economic,
commercial and legal characteristics to RP, the Merial Venture and
their respective Affiliates as the structure described elsewhere in
this Agreement; (w) RP consents in writing to this alternative
prior to its implementation (which consent shall not be
unreasonably withheld or unreasonably delayed if, in RP’s
reasonable opinion, all the other conditions specified in this
clause (ii) have been satisfied); (x) [*]; (y) Merck
shall be responsible for all out-of-pocket costs and fees
reasonably incurred by RP or any of its Subsidiaries in assessing
the alternative structure proposed by Merck pursuant to this clause
(ii); and (z) no such alternative structure shall be proposed
if such alternative structure would result in such assets and/or
Liabilities being transferred to the Merial Venture after
December 31, 1997.
(iii) Except
as provided elsewhere in this Agreement or in the Ancillary
Agreements, each Party and its Affiliates will, however, ultimately
be responsible for its own Taxes.
SECTION 5.5
. Certain U.S. Tax Matters
(a)
Designation of Tax Matters Partner . The Merck Member is
hereby designated as the “Tax Matters Partner” under
Section 6231(a)(7) of the Code to manage the administrative
Tax proceedings conducted at the Merial Venture level by the IRS
with respect to Merial Venture matters. The Merck Member is
specifically directed and authorized to take whatever steps the
Merck Member, in its sole discretion, deems necessary or desirable
to assure the Merck Member’s designation as the Tax Matters
Partner, including, without limitation, filing any forms or
documents with the IRS and taking such other action as may from
time to time be required under Treasury Regulations. Expenses of
administrative proceedings relating to the determination of Merial
Venture items at the Merial Venture level undertaken by the Merck
Member in accordance with this Section 5.5 will be deemed to
be Merial Venture expenses.
80
(b) Tax
Elections . All Tax elections required or permitted to be made
under the Code and any applicable U.S. federal, state or local Tax
law with respect to the Merial Venture (or any of its Subsidiaries)
shall be made by the Tax Matters Partner, subject to the express
prior written approval of the RP Member, which approval shall not
be unreasonably withheld, and any decision with respect to the
treatment of Merial Venture transactions on the Merial
Venture’s U.S. federal, state or local Tax Returns shall be
made by the Members jointly. The RP Member hereby approves the
election to classify Merial as a partnership for U.S. Tax purposes,
as well as any other election to classify any other Merial Venture
Company (other than BUT) which is an eligible entity as either a
partnership or branch, as the case may be; provided that no
such election shall result in increased Tax Liabilities or exposure
for RP; and further provided that no such election
shall require any restructuring of or other company action
affecting any such Merial Venture Company. The RP Member also
hereby approves any action the Tax Matters Partner may deem
necessary in its sole discretion to give effect to any election
approved pursuant to the preceding sentence. RP will (or cause its
Subsidiaries to) provide to the Tax Matters Partner and sign all
documents necessary to give effect to all elections to be made
pursuant to this Section 5.5(b).
(c)
Allocations of Income, Gain or Loss
(i) Net
Income . For U.S. Tax purposes, net income with respect to any
taxable period shall be allocated as follows:
(A) First, to the
Members in proportion to the excess, if any, of (i) the
cumulative amount paid to each Member pursuant to Section 6.2
through the date the Net Special Dividend is calculated after the
closing of such period in respect of such period, over
(ii) the cumulative amount previously allocated to such Member
in respect of such period pursuant to this paragraph (A) until
such excess has been eliminated;
(B) Second, to the
holders of any Preference Shares (if issued pursuant to
Section 5.1(a)(iii)), proportionately, in an amount equal to
the
81
amount, if any,
of dividends paid thereon during such period (whether such
dividends represent payment of a current or accumulated dividend
thereon); and
(C) Third, 50% to
each of the Members, as set forth in Section 6.1
hereof.
(ii) Net
Loss . For Tax purposes, net loss with respect to any taxable
period shall be allocated 50% to each of the Members, as set forth
in Section 6.1 hereof.
(iii) Tax
Adjustments . In the event that the Merial Venture’s
income, gains, losses, deductions or credits are adjusted by any
Taxing Authority by reason of any transaction between one or more
Members and/or the Merial Venture, including adjustments pursuant
to Section 482 of the Code or similar provisions under state, local
or foreign law (any such adjustment herein being referred to as a
“Tax Adjustment”), the allocation of any item of gross
income, gain, loss, deduction or credit resulting from such Tax
Adjustment (either as the result of a primary or correlative
adjustment) and the treatment of any deemed transfers of value
between or among the Merial Venture and one or more Members
(including deemed contributions to and deemed distributions from
the Merial Venture on account of such Tax Adjustment) shall be
governed by this Agreement. Allocations, including allocations of
items of gross income and the treatment of deemed transfers of
value between or among the Merial Venture and the Members shall be
made, to the extent possible, in an appropriate manner by the Tax
Matters Partner so as to avoid any Tax consequences from a Tax
Adjustment to a Member who is not affected by such Tax Adjustment.
In the event that any Tax Adjustment results in an increase in the
Merial Venture’s gross income, such gross income shall be
allocated as an item of gross income under Code
Section 702(a)(7) to the Member whose income is adjusted in
connection with such Tax Adjustment to the Merial Venture’s
income and the Merial Venture shall be treated as making a deemed
transfer of value that is treated as a distribution to such Member
in the
82
same amount. In
the event that any Tax Adjustment results in an increase in an item
of Merial Venture deduction or loss, such deduction or loss shall
be allocated as an item of deduction under Code
Section 702(a)(7) to the Member whose income is adjusted in
connection with such Tax Adjustment to the Merial Venture’s
income and such Member shall be treated as making in the same
amount a deemed transfer of value that is treated as a contribution
to the Merial Venture. In the case of a deemed transfer of value by
the Merial Venture to a Member that is treated as a guaranteed
payment as a result of a Tax Adjustment that reduces an item of the
Merial Venture’s loss or deduction, the deduction
attributable to such guaranteed payment shall be allocated in the
same manner the item of loss or deduction reduced by the Tax
Adjustment was allocated.
(d)
Capital Accounts . A separate capital account shall be
established and maintained for each Member. Maintenance of capital
accounts is intended for U.S. Tax reporting purposes only and has
no application to any other provision of this Agreement or the
interpretation thereof.
(i) The initial
balance of each capital account shall be zero.
(ii) The capital
account of each Member shall be increased by (x) any capital
contribution by such Member when such capital contribution is made
and (y) the net income allocated to such Member pursuant to
Section 5.5(c)(i).
(iii) The capital
account of each Member shall be reduced by (x) the amount of
any distribution of cash or the fair market value of any property
(net of any liability secured by such property that the Member is
considered to assume or take subject to under Section 752 of the
Code) distributed to such Member when such distribution is made and
(y) the net loss allocated to such Member pursuant to
Section 5.5(c)(ii).
(iv) The capital
account of each Member shall be adjusted to reflect any adjustment
to the value of the Merial Venture’s assets attributable to
the
83
application of
Sections 732, 734 or 743 to the extent required pursuant to
Treas. Reg. § 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(m).
(v) Except as
otherwise provided in this Agreement, whenever it is necessary to
determine the capital account of any Member, the capital account of
such Member shall be determined after giving effect to the
allocations of net profit, net loss and other items realized prior
or concurrent to such time (including, without limitation any net
profits and net losses attributable to adjustments to values with
respect to any concurrent distribution), and all contributions and
distributions made prior or concurrent to the time as of which such
determination is to be made.
(vi) No Principal
or Member shall have any obligation to Merial or any Merial Venture
Company, the other Principal, the other Member or to any other
Person, including, without limitation, any creditors of the Merial
Venture, to restore or otherwise make good any negative balance in
any Member’s capital account.
(vii)
Distributions in liquidation of the Merial Venture shall be made in
accordance with capital accounts; [*].
(e)
Certain Tax Benefits . For U.S. federal Tax purposes, the
Principals, the Members and Merial agree (and Merial agrees to
cause the Merial Venture Companies) to treat the prices charged to
the Merial Venture for products purchased under the Merck Supply
Agreement and the RP Ag Supply Agreement as the Merial
Venture’s “cost” therefor. In furtherance
thereof, the Principals, the Members and Merial agree (and Merial
agrees to cause the Merial Venture Companies to agree) that any
benefits derived under Section 936 of the Code or any
successor Code section thereof by Merck Member or any Affiliate of
Merck Member on the manufacture of any products sold to the
Merial
84
Venture
pursuant to the Merck Supply Agreement shall be for the benefit of
Merck Member and not for the benefit of the Merial Venture, the RP
Member nor any other member of the RP Group.
85
PROFIT AND LOSS ALLOCATIONS;
DIVIDENDS
SECTION 6.1.
General Profit and Loss Principles
As a general
principle, the Parties have agreed that the profits and losses of
the Merial Venture shall be allocated to the Members in such a way
that each Member will be entitled to 50.0% of the profits and
losses of the Merial Venture, subject to the specific adjustments
set forth in this Agreement and to such other adjustments as the
Members’ Meeting may determine.
For accounting
purposes only and for no other purpose, the Members intend that,
for each accounting period, each Member’s share of
Merial’s net income will include fifty percent (50%) of
Merial’s net income (after subtracting Net Special Dividends
and dividends on Preference Shares) plus any Net Special Dividends
and dividends on Preference Shares made to that Member that may be
income or expense to such Member.
SECTION 6.2.
Special Dividends
(a)
Special Dividends Generally. The Parties have agreed to
certain financial arrangements that shall be exceptions to the
general principle set forth in Section 6.1 of a 50/50
allocation of profits as between the Members. Certain of these
financial arrangements (set forth in Sections 5.1(b)(i)(C)(i)
[Goubin], 6.3 through 6.9, 7.1(b), (c) and (d), 7.1(f)(ii) and
(vii), 7.2(c) and (e), 7.4, 7.5(a)(i), 7.5(b)(i), 7.5(c) and 14.19
[Tax Reserves Adjustment] of this Agreement and in
Sections 3.5 and 4.4 of the Merck Employee Leasing Agreement
shall give rise to special distributions or dividends (each, a
“Special Dividend” and, together, the “Special
Dividends”) which shall be calculated and credited to one or
the other of the Members in accordance with the provisions of the
relevant Sections. Each of the Special Dividends is creditable in
respect of one or more Fiscal Years. For each Fiscal Year in
respect of which one or more Special Dividends is to be credited,
all the Special Dividends to be credited in respect of such year
shall be
86
calculated and
netted together in accordance with Section 6.2(b) and the
resulting “Net Special Dividend” shall be paid in
accordance with Section 6.2(c). A numerical example of the Net
Special Dividend is provided in Exhibit XVIII
hereto.
(b)
Calculation of Net Special Dividend. Upon the earlier of
(x) the approval by the Board of Directors of Merial’s
consolidated financial statements for any Fiscal Year, and (y) the
date that is one (1) month after the completion of the
preparation of such financial statements by the management of
Merial (it being understood that preparation of such financial
statements shall be completed no later than the twentieth (20th)
Business Day following the end of the Fiscal Year), but no later
than sixty (60) days after the end of such Fiscal Year, Merial
shall, and if Merial does not, each of the Principals may, promptly
(based upon such financial statements and/or any other reasonably
necessary or available financial information, which shall be made
available to both Principals by Merial upon any request by either
Principal), and in any case within twenty (20) Business Days of
such earlier date, (such deadline being the “Special Dividend
Calculation Date”) calculate each of the Special Dividends
that is applicable in respect of such year. The “Net Special
Dividend” for a particular Fiscal Year shall be the single
payment payable to either the RP Member or the Merck Member that
results from the netting of all such Special Dividends, which shall
be calculated by taking the difference between the sum of all the
Special Dividends, if any, creditable to one of the Members in
respect of such year and the sum of all those, if any, creditable
to the other Member in respect of such year. The Net Special
Dividend shall be calculated in U.S. dollars, using, as necessary,
the exchange rate of the last day of the Fiscal Year, except as
otherwise provided in this Agreement. The Net Special Dividend
shall be payable to the Member to which the greater dollar
aggregate amount of Special Dividends in respect of such year is
payable. Notwithstanding Article XVIII, any disagreements
between the Principals as to the calculation of any of the Special
Dividends or of the Net Special Dividend shall be resolved
exclusively pursuant to Section 6.2(d), but without modifying
or limiting other rights or remedies of the Parties under other
provisions of this Agreement.
87
(c)
Payment of the Net Special Dividend. The Net Special
Dividend in respect of any Fiscal Year shall be paid by Merial out
of Distributable Profits in the form of a preferential dividend. No
other dividends or distributions to the Members shall be paid or
declared by Merial until the entirety of any outstanding Net
Special Dividend has been paid in full. If the Net Special Dividend
to be paid in respect of any year is greater than the Distributable
Profits available for distribution at the time dividends are to be
paid in respect of such year, then the Net Special Dividend shall
be paid to the appropriate Member to the extent of the available
Distributable Profits (with the result that no other dividends
shall be paid in respect of such year), and the unpaid balance
shall be increased by an amount equal to interest calculated at a
rate equal to the [*] accruing from April 15 of the year next
following the year in question until such time as it is paid in
full. In the event a Principal wishes to receive payment of the Net
Special Dividend in a currency different from the U.S. Dollar, such
Principal shall so notify Merial in writing sixty (60) days in
advance of the payment date of the Net Special Dividend, and Merial
shall convert the Net Special Dividend to the desired payment
currency on the actual date of payment (at the then spot exchange
rate). In the event of a dispute between the Principals as to the
calculation of any Special Dividend or of the Net Special Dividend
in respect of any year, the Principals shall follow the procedure
described in 6.2(d) and, when the dispute is resolved, the Net
Special Dividend will, together with the corresponding amount
calculated as interest mentioned above, to the extent of available
Distributable Profits, be paid through a partial Net Special
Dividend payment. In the event any unpaid balance of a Net Special
Dividend payable with respect to any year remains at the time the
Net Special Dividend to be paid in respect of the following year is
payable, such Net Special Dividend in respect of the following year
shall be equal to the amount resulting from netting (or adding, as
appropriate) such unpaid balance (and any accrued amount calculated
as interest thereon) with the Net Special Dividend calculated for
such following year in accordance with Section 6.2(b). Any
undisputed amount in the calculation of the Net Special Dividend
will be paid immediately, and any disputed amount shall be subject
to the Special Dividend Calculation Dispute Resolution described in
Section 6.2(d) below.
88
(d)
Special Dividend Calculation Dispute Resolution. In the
event there is any dispute between the Principals as to the
calculation of any Special Dividend or of the Net Special Dividend
in respect of any year, the Principals shall meet and negotiate in
good faith to resolve such dispute. If the dispute has not been
resolved within thirty (30) days of the Special Dividend
Calculation Date, then either Principal may submit such dispute to
arbitration as set forth below in this Section 6.2(d). In
connection with any such dispute, a “Big Six”
accounting firm acceptable to both the Principals shall be engaged
to resolve the dispute, except that (i) if the Principals
cannot reach agreement on the selection of such accounting firm,
then such accounting firm shall be selected and appointed by the
ICE (which selection and appointment shall be final and binding on
the Parties), and (ii) the firm so selected and appointed may
not be the primary accounting firm for Merck, Merial, RM or RP.
Each of the Principals shall submit to the accounting firm selected
their detailed calculations and such firm shall promptly be
provided with any relevant financial data of the Merial Venture or
of either of the Principals that it may request. In making its
determination, the accounting firm shall refer to the methods of
calculation set forth in this Article VI and to the numerical
examples for calculating each of the Special Dividends and the Net
Special Dividend set forth in Exhibit XVIII. The accounting
firm shall be jointly requested to make its decision within thirty
(30) days of having been selected. The decision of the
accounting firm selected by the Principals or the ICE shall be
final and binding on the Parties on any issue relating to the
calculation of any Special Dividend or of the Net Special Dividend.
The fees and reasonable expenses of the accounting firm shall be
borne by the losing party; if the dispute is not resolved solely in
favor of one party, then the parties shall share such fees and
reasonable expenses equally. Pending such decision of the
accounting firm, Merial, the Members and the Board of Directors
shall continue to fulfill all their obligations under applicable
Laws and this Agreement, including attending required meetings. In
the event the Annual Member’s Meeting is held in accordance
with Section 4.2(k) prior to such decision of the accounting
firm, the Members’ Meeting shall only declare dividends in
respect of the relevant year to the extent that the Distributable
Profits remaining after the payment of such dividends would be
sufficient to pay the greater of the Net Special Dividends claimed
by the Principals under this Section 6.2(d), it being
understood that in any such case the Net Special Dividend decided
upon by the accounting firm (together with an
89
amount
calculated as interest thereon calculated in accordance with
Section 6.2(c)) shall be declared by the first Members’
Meeting following such decision and paid as a partial Net Special
Dividend.
SECTION 6.3.
Retroactive Closing Mechanism
(a) The
Parties shall give effect to a closing adjustment mechanism (the
“Retroactive Closing Mechanism”) pursuant to this
Section 6.3 with the intention of putting the Principals, to
the extent possible, in the same economic position they would have
been in had the Closing occurred on the Economic Effective Date (as
defined below). For the avoidance of doubt, as between the Parties,
the actual commencement of the Merial Venture for accounting and
Tax purposes shall be the first day following the Closing Date. The
Retroactive Closing Mechanism shall not be applied if a change in
Tax Laws occurring between the date hereof and the date of the
Closing causes the application of the Retroactive Closing Mechanism
to have an adverse Tax consequence of [*] for either Principal.
“Economic Effective Date” shall be April 1, 1997.
“The Retroactive Period” shall be the period between
the Economic Effective Date and the Closing Date.
(b) The
Retroactive Closing Mechanism shall be implemented through a
Retroactive Closing Special Dividend, which shall be calculated
based on the Retroactive Closing Financial Statements, as defined
in, and prepared in accordance with, the instructions set forth in
Exhibit XIX. Subject to the instructions set forth in
Exhibit XIX, the Retroactive Closing Special Dividend shall be
credited, in calculating the Net Special Dividend in respect of
Fiscal Year 1997, to the Member whose pro forma cash generated
(used), as calculated in accordance with the instructions set forth
in Exhibit XIX, is lower than its share in the pro forma cash
generated (used) by the Merial Venture during the Retroactive
Period.
(c)
Pre-Closing Preparation of Financial Statements . Each of
Merck and RM hereby represents to the other as of the date hereof
and as of the Closing Date that (i) each of the monthly actual
and pro forma consolidated income statements and
90
consolidated
statements of cash flows that it has provided to the other in
respect of the operations of the Merck Contributed Business and of
RM and its Subsidiaries, respectively, for the first quarter of
Fiscal Year 1997 and for each calendar month since and including
April 1997, and (ii) each of the quarterly actual and pro
forma consolidated balance sheets that it has provided to the other
in respect of the Merck Contributed Business and of RM and its
Subsidiaries, respectively, since and including the consolidated
balance sheets as of March 31, 1997, was prepared,
(x) with respect to the actual consolidated income statements
and consolidated statements of cash flows referred to above,
consistently with the Merck Contributed Business Financials
attached as Exhibit XVI hereto in the case of Merck, and the
RM Financials attached as Exhibit XVII hereto in the case of
RM, and (y) with respect to the pro forma consolidated income
statements and consolidated statements of cash flows referred to
above, consistently with the instructions set forth in
Exhibit XIX; and each of Merck and RM hereby agrees to
continue to provide such statements to the other, prepared in a
consistent manner, for each calendar month and as of the end of
each calendar quarter, as the case may be, until the
Closing.
SECTION 6.4.
Early Year Adjustment
If the actual Net
Reported Sales by the Merial Venture (or by RM and Merck and their
respective Subsidiaries during the Retroactive Period) of certain
products specified below in any of 1997, 1998 or 1999 are less than
the assumed Baseline Net Reported Sales amounts for such products
set forth below, the Principals will give effect in each such year
to an adjustment mechanism (the “Early Year Adjustment
Mechanism”) set forth in this Section 6.4. A numerical
example of the Early Year Adjustment Mechanism is provided in
Exhibit XVIII hereto.
(a) Early
Year Adjustment Special Dividend. The Early Year Adjustment
Mechanism Entitlements of each Principal, if any, calculated
pursuant to this Section 6.4 in respect of each Fiscal Year
1997 through 1999 shall be offset against each other, with the
difference between them being the “Early Year Adjustment
Special Dividend” for each such Fiscal Year. In calculating
the Net Special Dividend in respect of each such
91
Fiscal Year,
the Early Year Adjustment Special Dividend shall be credited to the
Merck Member if the Merck Section 6.4 Entitlement (as defined
below) is greater or to the RP Member if the RP Section 6.4
Entitlement (as defined below) is greater.
Baseline Net
Reported Sales ($ millions)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1997
|
|
1998
|
|
1999
|
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
Merck
Adjustment Products
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1997
|
|
1998
|
|
1999
|
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
Merck
Adjustment Products
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
(b) Merck
Section 6.4 Entitlement. The amount, if any, by which (x)
the sum of actual Net Reported Sales of Biological Products and
Fipronil Products (together, “RP Adjustment Products”),
for any of 1997, 1998 or 1999, are less than (y) the
respective Baseline Net Reported Sales for RP Adjustment Products
for such year, shall be the “RP Sales Shortfall Amount”
for such year. Merck shall be entitled in respect of any such year
to a dollar amount (the “Merck Section 6.4
Entitlement”) equal to the product of (xx) the RP Sales
Shortfall Amount, (yy) the percentage equal to the Gross
Margin Rate set forth above for RP Adjustment Products for such
year, and (zz) [*].
(c) RP
Section 6.4 Entitlement. The amount, if any, by which (x)
actual Net Reported Sales of Avermectin Products (“Merck
Adjustment Products”), for any of 1997, 1998 or 1999, are
less than (y) the respective Baseline Net Reported Sales for
Merck Adjustment Products for such year, shall be called the
“Merck Sales Shortfall Amount” for such year. RP shall
be entitled in respect of any such year to a dollar amount (the
“RP Section 6.4 Entitlement”) equal to the product
of (xx) the Merck Sales Shortfall Amount, (yy) the
percentage equal to the Gross Margin Rate set forth above for
Merck
92
Adjustment
Products for such year, and (zz) [*].
(d) 1997
Partial Year. In calculating the Sales Shortfall Amounts, if
any, in respect of 1997, the relevant Baseline Net Reported Sales
amounts for the full Fiscal Year shall be reduced proportionately
(i.e., multiplied by a fraction the numerator of which is the
actual Net Reported Sales amount during the period from the
Economic Effective Date to the end of 1997 and the denominator of
which is actual Net Reported Sales amount for the full calendar
year 1997) and compared to actual Net Reported Sales during the
period from the Economic Effective Date to the end of
1997.
(e)
Foreign Currency Fluctuation. In order to eliminate the
effects of certain foreign currency fluctuations, the Net Reported
Sales calculated with respect to all sales of RP Adjustment
Products or Merck Adjustment Products denominated in any of the
currencies listed hereafter shall be translated into U.S. dollars
on the basis of the following exchange rates: English pound
sterling .63, French franc 5.00, German deutschemark 1.43, Italian
lira 1624, Spanish peseta 125, Japanese yen 93, and Australian
dollar 1.35. If any of such sales of RP Adjustment Products or
Merck Adjustment Products in one of such countries are denominated
in ecus or euros, the Net Reported Sales in U.S. dollars with
respect to such sales shall be determined by first translating the
amount in ecus or euros, as the case may be, into an amount
denominated in the national currency of such country (the English
pound sterling, French franc, German deutschemark, Italian lira or
Spanish peseta, as the case may be) at the exchange rate in effect
at the date of such sale (or, if the national currency no longer
exists at such time, the last such exchange rate in effect prior to
the elimination of the national currency), and then translating the
resulting national currency amount into U.S. dollars at the
exchange rates set forth above.
(f) Early
Dissolution. The Early Year Adjustment Mechanism shall only be
applied to full calendar years (and to the partial 1997 year
as contemplated in Section 6.4(d)). In the event the Merial
Venture is Dissolved prior to December 31, 1999, the
Principals shall negotiate in good faith at such time in order to
adjust the payment(s)
93
made in
connection with such Dissolution to account for the estimated
present value of the adjustments that would have been made pursuant
to the Early Year Adjustment Mechanism set forth in this
Section 6.4 had such Dissolution not occurred. In the event
such Dissolution occurs pursuant to the purchase by one Principal
of the Merial Venture interest of the other, the adjustment shall
be made to the purchase price. In the event such Dissolution occurs
pursuant to the purchase by a Third Party of all or substantially
all of the Merial Venture, the adjustment shall be made to the
apportionment of the purchase price between the Principals (which
apportionment would otherwise be 50/50, before accounting for any
undistributed Special Dividends or other early Dissolution
adjustments).
(g)
Change of Early Year Adjustment Mechanism Premises. If,
prior to the Closing, the Principals or, after the Closing,
Merial’s Board of Directors, approves a transaction or the
development and marketing of a product that can be reasonably
viewed as changing the premises upon which the Baseline Net
Reported Sales amounts were agreed, then Merck and RP shall
negotiate in good faith to determine appropriate and equitable
modifications to the Baseline Net Reported Sales amounts and until
both Principals agree on such modifications, the foregoing
provisions of this Section 6.4 shall continue to
apply.
SECTION 6.5.
Band Adjustment
If the average
annual actual Net Reported Sales of RP Adjustment Products or Merck
Adjustment Products by the Merial Venture during the four
calendar-year period of 1998, 1999, 2000 and 2001 is more than [*]
the Baseline Net Reported Sales for such products set forth in this
Section 6.5, the Parties will give effect to a band adjustment
mechanism (the “Band Adjustment Mechanism”) set forth
in this Section 6.5. A numerical example of the Band
Adjustment Mechanism is provided in Exhibit XVIII
hereto.
(a) Band
Adjustment Special Dividend. The Band Adjustment Mechanism
Entitlements of each Principal, if any, as calculated pursuant to
this Section 6.5, shall be
94
offset against
each other, with the difference between them being the “Band
Adjustment Special Dividend”. The Band Adjustment Special
Dividend shall be credited to the RP Member if the RP
Section 6.5 Entitlement, as defined below, is greater than the
Merck Section 6.5 Entitlement, as defined below, or to the
Merck Member if the Merck Section 6.5 Entitlement is greater
than the RP Section 6.5 Entitlement, in calculating the Net
Special Dividend in respect of Fiscal Year 2001.
Baseline Net
Reported Sales ($ millions)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1998
|
|
1999
|
|
2000
|
|
2001
|
|
Average
|
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
Merck Adjustment Products
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
|
|
[*]
|
|
(b) Merck
Section 6.5 Entitlement. The amount, if any, by which
(x) the average of the actual annual Net Reported Sales for RP
Adjustment Products, during the period 1998-2001 inclusive, is less
than (y) the average of the annual Baseline Net Reported Sales
for RP Adjustment Products, during such period, shall be the
“Average RP Sales Shortfall Amount”. If the Average RP
Sales Shortfall Amount is greater than [*] (the “RP
Threshold”), then Merck shall be entitled to an amount (the
“Merck Section 6.5 Entitlement”) [*]. The RP Threshold
was calculated [*].
(c) RP
Section 6.5 Entitlement. The amount, if any, by which
(x) the average of the actual annual Net Reported Sales for
Merck Adjustment Products, during the period 1998-2001 inclusive,
is less than (y) the average of the annual Baseline Net
Reported Sales for Merck Adjustment Products during such period,
shall be the “Average Merck Sales Shortfall Amount”. If
the Average Merck Sales Shortfall Amount is greater than [*] (the
“Merck Threshold”), then RP shall be entitled to an
amount (the “RP Section 6.5 Entitlement”) [*]. The
Merck Threshold was calculated [*]
95
(d)
Foreign Currency Fluctuation. In order to eliminate effects
of certain foreign currency fluctuations, actual Net Reported Sales
(with respect to sales made in certain currencies other than U.S.
dollars) shall be calculated using the same agreed upon exchange
rates as for the Early Year Adjustment Mechanism, as set forth in
Section 6.4(e) above.
(e) Early
Dissolution. If the Merial Venture liquidates, sells or
otherwise disposes of all or substantially all of its assets or is
Dissolved prior to January 1, 2002, then the Band Adjustment
Mechanism shall be applied as follows:
(i) if the
Dissolution Date is prior to January 1, 1999, the Band
Adjustment Mechanism shall not apply;
(ii) in the case
of a Dissolution Date on or after January 1, 1999, the Band
Adjustment Mechanism shall be applied as set forth in
Section 6.5(a)-(d) above, except as follows:
The Average RP
Sales Shortfall Amount and the Average Merck Sales Shortfall Amount
shall be calculated on an annualized basis, based on the number of
full calendar quarters from January 1, 1998 through the
Dissolution Date, rather than on the average of the four full
calendar years of actual Net Reported Sales. The Baseline Net
Reported Sales used for the quarters comprising any partial year
prior to the Dissolution Date shall equal the product of the
Baseline Net Reported Sales for such year and a fraction, the
numerator of which is the Net Reported Sales for the relevant
products shown (or implicit) in the Approved Budget (as defined
below) for the full calendar quarters in such year prior to the
Dissolution Date, and the denominator of which is the Net Reported
Sales for such Products shown (or implicit) in the Approved Budget
for the full year in which the Dissolution occurs. “Approved
Budget” means the latest business plan or budget
96
which covers
the year in question that has been approved by Merial’s Board
of Directors (or, if no such plan or budget has been so approved,
then the actual Net Reported Sales for the relevant products during
the corresponding periods in the preceding calendar year shall be
used in place of the Net Reported Sales shown in the Approved
Budget for purposes of the calculation described in the preceding
sentence).
(f)
Change of Band Adjustment Mechanism Premises. If, prior to
the Closing, the Principals or, after the Closing, Merial’s
Board of Directors, approve a transaction or the development and
marketing of a product that can be reasonably viewed as changing
the premises upon which the Baseline Net Reported Sales amounts
were agreed, then Merck and RP shall negotiate in good faith to
determine appropriate and equitable modifications to the Baseline
Net Reported Sales amounts and until both Principals agree upon
such modifications, the foregoing provisions of this
Section 6.5 shall continue to apply.
SECTION 6.6.
Special Poultry Genetics Profit Allocation
(a) Merial
shall, in respect of each Fiscal Year from 1997 to 2001 inclusive,
credit a Special Dividend (the “PG Profit Special
Dividend”) to the Merck Member equal to [*] of the
“Adjusted Poultry Genetics Profits” for such year. The
“Adjusted Poultry Genetics Profits” for each such year
shall be calculated by taking the pre-tax profits before interest
expenses of the Poultry Genetics Business reflected in the stand
alone pro forma financial statements referred to below in this
Section 6.6(a) for the relevant Fiscal Year, [*]. The Parties
acknowledge (i) that the PG Profit Special Dividend shall be
calculated and credited regardless of the proportion of the Poultry
Genetics Business’ profits that Merial actually receives in
the form of dividends in respect of such year, and (ii) that
all dividends actually received by Merial from its Poultry Genetics
Business shall be allocated as between the Members as otherwise
provided in this Agreement. The Parties agree that the impact of
any acquisitions by Merial in the Poultry Genetics Business
after
97
the Closing
Date, which impact shall be determined by the management of Merial
at the time of such acquisitions, shall be excluded from the
calculation of the PG Profit Special Dividend. In the event of a
divestiture by Merial or any other Merial Venture Company of a part
(but less than all or substantially all) of the Poultry Genetics
Business contributed to the Merial Venture (other than Goubin)
between the Economic Effective Date and December 31, 2001, the
Special Poultry Genetics Profit Allocation in respect of the Fiscal
Year during which such divestiture occurred shall be increased by
an amount equal to [*]. Merial shall prepare stand-alone pro forma
financial statements reflecting the operations of the entirety of
its Poultry Genetics Business for each Fiscal Year from 1997
through 2001 inclusive, including profit and loss statements,
prepared consistently with the accounting principles and practices
used to prepare the Merial financial statements (but excluding any
financial or interest charges actually incurred by the Poultry
Genetics Business). In preparing these financial statements, any
expenses for overheads or corporate services shall be allocated on
a fair and equitable basis, based on the actual use of corporate
resources. These financial statements for the Fiscal Year 1997
shall reflect the operations of the Poultry Genetics Business from
the Closing Date to December 31, 1997. The PG Profit Special
Dividend in respect of 1997 shall be based on the profits of the
Poultry Genetics Business during the period from the Closing Date
to December 31, 1997. A numerical example of the Poultry
Genetics Special Dividend is provided in Exhibit XVIII
hereto.
(b)
Deemed Interest Expense. For the purposes of calculating the
Adjusted Poultry Genetics Profits, [*] of Debt shall be deemed to
have been initially allocated to the Poultry Genetics Business. The
“Deemed Interest Expense” for each year from 1997
through 2001 shall equal [*]
98
[*]. For the
calculation of the 1997 Deemed Interest Expense, [*] shall be
used.
(c) PG
Profit Special Dividend. Subject to Section 6.6(d), the PG
Profit Special Dividend calculated in respect of each Fiscal Year
from 1997 to 2001 inclusive shall be credited to the Merck Member
in calculating the Net Special Dividend pursuant to
Section 6.2 in respect of such Fiscal Year.
(d) Early
Disposal or Dissolution. If the Merial Venture liquidates,
sells or otherwise disposes of all or substantially all of its
Poultry Genetics Business or if the Merial Venture is Dissolved
prior to January 1, 2002, then the Principals shall negotiate
in good faith at such time, in order to adjust the payment(s) made
in connection with such disposal or Dissolution to account for the
estimated present value of the remaining PG Profit Special
Allocation (the “PG Profit Allocation Present Value”).
In the event the Principals are not able to agree within
30 days of the closing of such disposal or Dissolution on the
amount of the PG Profit Allocation Present Value, it shall be
determined in accordance with the procedures set forth in
Section 17.2(g)(ii). In the event of an early sale or other
disposition by the Merial Venture of all or substantially all of
its Poultry Genetics Business, Merial shall, pursuant to
Section 6.2, credit the PG Profit Allocation Present Value to
the Merck Member as a Special Dividend in respect of the calendar
year during which such sale was completed. In the event of a
Dissolution of the Merial Venture pursuant to the sale by one
Principal of its Merial Venture Interest to the other, the purchase
price shall be increased (in the case of a sale to RP) or decreased
(in the case of a sale to Merck), as appropriate, by the PG Profit
Allocation Present Value (on a dollar for dollar basis). In the
event of a Dissolution of the Merial Venture pursuant to the sale
of all or substantially all of the Merial Venture to a Third Party,
the apportionment of the sales proceeds to the Merck Member (which
apportionment as between the Members would otherwise be 50/50,
before accounting for any undistributed Special Dividends or other
adjustments provided for in this Article VI) shall be
increased on a dollar for dollar basis equal to the PG Profit
Allocation Present Value.
99
SECTION 6.7.
Supply Price Adjustments
(a) Merck
Supply Price Adjustment. In respect of each Fiscal Year, the RP
Member shall have an entitlement (the “RP Section 6.7
Entitlement”) equal to the product of (i) [*], and (ii)
(x) the sum of all amounts accrued by the Merial Venture to
the Merck Group for such Fiscal Year for the supply of products (or
bulk) pursuant to the Merck Supply Agreement, and (without
duplication) of all amounts paid by Merial or its Subsidiaries
during such Fiscal Year to purchase the Inventories included in the
Merck Contributed Non-U.S. Assets and the Retained Inventory, if
any, less (y) the sum of (AA) all amounts that
would have been so accrued with respect to such Fiscal Year if
calculated in accordance with the Merck Manufacturing Supply Price
Formula and (BB) the Avermectin Products Sales Adjustment for
such Fiscal Year calculated in accordance with Exhibit XXI
[Avermectin Products Sales Adjustment], but only if the amount (the
“Delta”) equal to the amount determined pursuant to
clause (x) above less the amount determined pursuant to
clause (y) above, is a positive amount. The sum of the amounts
specified in (AA) and (BB) shall be the “Merck
Negotiated Supply Price”. If the Delta is a negative number,
then in respect of such Fiscal Year (whether or not the Merck
Supply Agreement is then in effect), the Merck Member shall have an
entitlement (the “Merck Section 6.7(a)
Entitlement”) equal to the product of (i) [*], and (ii) the
absolute amount of the Delta. Merck hereby represents that the
formula for calculating standard direct cost in the Merck Supply
Agreement is on the same basis as the formula used to calculate
standard direct cost in the Merck Base Case and the multiple of
standard direct cost in the Merck Base Case roughly approximates
(on average over the five years following the Closing Date given
the product mix included in the Merck Base Case) the multiple of
standard direct cost provided for in the Merck Manufacturing Supply
Price Formula.
(b) RP
Supply Price Adjustment. In respect of each Fiscal Year, the
Merck Member shall have an entitlement (the “Merck
Section 6.7(b) Entitlement”) equal to the product of (i)
[*], and (ii) (x) the sum of all amounts accrued by the Merial
Venture to the RP Group for such Fiscal Year for the
100
supply of
products (or bulk) pursuant to the RP Ag Supply Agreement, less
(y) the sum of all amounts that would have been so accrued if
calculated at Fully Allocated Cost (as defined in the RP Ag
Manufacturing Supply Price Formula). RP hereby represents that the
purchase price for Fipronil used in preparing the projections set
forth in the RM Base Case was calculated using Fully Allocated Cost
(as defined in the RP Ag Manufacturing Supply Price
Formula).
(c)
Supply Price Adjustment Special Dividend. The “Supply
Price Adjustment Special Dividend” shall be equal to the
difference between the respective Entitlements of the Principals,
if any, in respect of each relevant Fiscal Year, as calculated
pursuant to Sections 6.7(a) and (b) above. The Supply Price
Adjustment Special Dividend shall be credited to the RP Member if
the RP Section 6.7 Entitlement is greater than the Merck
Section 6.7(a) Entitlement plus the Merck Section 6.7(b)
Entitlement or to the Merck Member if the Merck Section 6.7(a)
Entitlement plus the Merck Section 6.7(b) Entitlement is
greater than the RP Section 6.7 Entitlement, in calculating
the Net Special Dividend in respect of such year pursuant to
Section 6.2. A numerical example of the Supply Price
Adjustment is provided in Exhibit XVIII hereto.
(d)
Alternative Upon Dissolution, Sale, Etc. In the event that,
as a result of any Dissolution, any transaction contemplated by
Articles XVI or XVII or otherwise, this Section 6.7 is no
longer operative or no longer effectively gives effect to the
economic principle that on a net basis Merck is selling and the
Merial Venture is purchasing Avermectin Products at the Merck
Manufacturing Supply Price Formula and Merck receives amounts
calculated pursuant to the Avermectin Products Sales Adjustment
Exhibit, the Parties agree that, prior to the effectiveness of any
such event, alternative arrangements shall be entered into by and
among the Parties and/or a purchaser in order to provide the
equivalent economic benefits to the Parties of the arrangements
contemplated by this Section 6.7 that, in the aggregate, have
no less favorable economic, tax, commercial and legal
characteristics to each of the Parties.
SECTION 6.8
Contributed Debt Adjustment Special Dividend
101
(a) From the
Closing Balance Sheets, the Parties shall calculate the “RM
Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance”, as defined below, and
the “Merck Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance”, as
defined below. The difference between the RM Actual Contributed Net
Debt Variance and the Merck Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance,
calculated as set forth below, shall be the “Contributed Debt
Adjustment Special Dividend”. In calculating the Net Special
Dividend in respect of the 1997 Fiscal Year pursuant to
Section 6.2, the Contributed Debt Adjustment Special Dividend
shall be credited to the RP Member if the Merck Actual Contributed
Net Debt Variance is greater than the RM Actual Contributed Net
Debt Variance, and to the Merck Member if the RM Actual Contributed
Net Debt Variance is greater than the Merck Actual Contributed Net
Debt Variance. A numerical example of the Contributed Debt
Adjustment Special Dividend is provided in Exhibit XVIII
hereto.
(b) The
“RM Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance” shall be
equal to :
the RM
Intercompany Debt (as defined in Section 5.2(b)),
the RM Outstanding
Debt (as defined in Section 5.2(b)),
the RM Accrued Tax
Liabilities (as defined in Section 5.2(b)),
the RM China
Financial Receivable (as defined in
Section 5.1(b)(ii)),
the RP Chinese
Assets Value Shortfall (as defined in
Section 5.1(b)(ii)),
the RM Closing
Cash (as defined in Section 5.2(b)),
(c) The
“Merck Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance” shall be
equal to :
the Merck Non-U.S.
Net Assets Value (as defined in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(A)),
102
the Retained
Receivables (as defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(C)),
the Retained
Inventories (as defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(C)),
the Merck Accrued
Tax Liabilities (as defined in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B)),
the Merck Other
Debt (as defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B)),
the Merck Cash
Contribution Amount (as defined in
Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B)),
the Merck Closing
Cash (as defined in Section 5.1(a)(ii)(B)),
(d) The
Contributed Debt Adjustment Special Dividend shall equal the
difference between the RM Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance and
the Merck Actual Contributed Net Debt Variance, which difference
shall be calculated taking into account any negative amounts (for
example, if one amount is -4 (negative four) and the other is 4,
the difference between them shall be 8).
SECTION 6.9.
Delayed Purchase Assets and Liabilities Special
Dividend
The Parties shall
agree on the estimated aggregate fair market value of the Delayed
Purchase Assets, such estimated value being the “Estimated
Delayed Purchase Assets Value”. For purposes of this
Section 6.9, the amount in U.S. dollars to be used in
calculating any purchase price for Delayed Purchase Assets
denominated in a currency other than U.S. dollars shall be
calculated using the closing midpoint exchange rate set forth in
the London edition of the Financial Times on the date the
payment is made.
(a)
Purchases of Delayed Purchase Assets during the 1997 Fiscal
Year . As soon as practicable after the end of the 1997 Fiscal
Year, and in no event later than the
103
twentieth
(20th) Business Day following the end of such Fiscal Year, Merial
shall (i) determine whether all the Delayed Purchase Assets
have been purchased during the 1997 Fiscal Year, and (ii) calculate
the difference between (x) the Estimated Delayed Purchase
Assets Value and (y) the purchase price actually paid for all
the Delayed Purchase Assets purchased during the 1997 Fiscal Year
(the “1997 Aggregate Purchase Price”), which difference
shall be the “1997 Delayed Purchase Assets
Variance”.
(A) If the
1997 Aggregate Purchase Price is greater than the Estimated Delayed
Purchase Assets Value, the 1997 Delayed Purchase Assets Variance
shall be credited as a 1997 Delayed Purchase Assets Special
Dividend to the RP Member, pursuant to Section 6.2 and in
respect of the 1997 Fiscal Year.
(B) If the
purchase of all Delayed Purchase Assets is completed by
December 31, 1997 and the Estimated Delayed Purchase Assets
Value is greater than the 1997 Aggregate Purchase Price, the 1997
Delayed Purchase Assets Variance shall be credited as a 1997
Delayed Purchase Assets Special Dividend to the Merck Member
pursuant to Section 6.2 and in respect of the 1997 Fiscal
Year.
(C) If the
purchase of all Delayed Purchase Assets is not completed by
December 31, 1997 and the 1997 Aggregate Purchase Price is
lower than the Estimated Delayed Purchase Assets Value, no Delayed
Purchase Assets Special Dividend shall be credited with respect to
the 1997 Fiscal Year.
(b)
Purchases during 1998 . As soon as practicable after the end
of the 1998 Fiscal Year, and in no event later than the twentieth
(20th) Business Day following the end of such Fiscal Year, Merial
shall (i) determine whether all the remaining Delayed Purchase
Assets have been purchased during the 1998 Fiscal Year, and
(ii) calculate the difference between (x) the Estimated
Delayed Purchase Assets Value and (y) the purchase price
actually paid for all the Delayed Purchase Assets purchased during
the 1997 and the
104
1998 Fiscal
Years (the “Global Purchase Price”), which difference
shall be the “Global Delayed Purchase Assets
Variance”.
(A) If the
purchase of all Delayed Purchase Assets is completed by
December 31, 1998 and the Global Purchase Price is greater
than the Estimated Delayed Purchase Assets Value, a Delayed
Purchase Assets Special Dividend equal to the difference between
the Global Delayed Purchase Assets Variance and the 1997 Delayed
Purchase Assets Special Dividend credited to the RP Member and
specified in Section 6.9(a)(A) shall be credited to the RP Member,
pursuant to Section 6.2 and in respect of the 1998 Fiscal
Year. If the purchase of all Delayed Purchase Assets is completed
by December 31, 1998 and the Global Purchase Price is lower
than the Estimated Delayed Purchase Assets Value, a Delayed
Purchase Assets Special Dividend equal to the difference between
the Global Delayed Purchase Assets Variance and the 1997 Delayed
Purchase Assets Special Dividend credited to the Merck Member and
specified in Section 6.9(a)(B) shall be credited to the Merck
Member, pursuant to Section 6.2 and in respect of the 1998
Fiscal Year.
(B) If the
purchase of all Delayed Purchase Assets is not completed by
December 31, 1998, the Parties shall meet no later then the
twentieth (20th) Business Day of the 1999 Fiscal Year to determine
the consequences, financial and otherwise, of such a failure, and
such consequences shall be taken into account to determine the 1998
Delayed Purchase Assets Special Dividend.
SECTION 6.10.
Early Dissolution and the Merck Research Payment
No RM Funding
Commitment payments (as defined in the Merck Research Agreement)
shall be made by RM SAS after the Dissolution of the Merial
Venture; provided , however , that if the Merial
Venture is Dissolved before December 31, 2003, the payment(s)
made in connection with such Dissolution to the Merck Member shall
be
105
increased (or
to the RP Member shall be decreased) by an amount equal to the
present value of future RM Funding Commitment payments (the
“Research Payment Present Value”), which shall be
deemed to be [*] for a Dissolution during the calendar year 1997,
and [*]. In the event of a Dissolution of the Merial Venture
pursuant to the sale by one Principal of its Merial Venture
Interest to the other, the purchase price shall be increased or
decreased, as appropriate, by the Research Payment Present Value
(on a dollar for dollar basis). In the event of a Dissolution of
the Merial Venture pursuant to the sale of all or substantially all
of the Merial Venture to a Third Party, the apportionment of the
sales proceeds to the Merck Member (which apportionment as between
the Members would otherwise be 50/50, before accounting for any
undistributed Special Dividends or other adjustments provided for
in this Article VI) shall be increased on a dollar for dollar
basis equal to the Research Payment Present Value.
SECTION 6.11.
Distribution Upon Liquidation
In any liquidation
of the Merial Venture, the assets of the Merial Venture shall,
subject to applicable Laws, be distributed in accordance with the
following priorities:
(i) First,
to the creditors of the Merial Venture (including to any RP
Companies or Merck Companies to whom any Debt or accounts payable
may be owed by the Merial Venture) in accordance with applicable
Laws and any judgments or orders of competent Public
Authorities;
(ii) second, to the extent of any assets
remaining, if there is any unpaid Net Special Dividend balance
outstanding in respect of any prior Fiscal Year, an amount
equivalent to such balance to the Member to whom such unpaid Net
Special Dividend balance is due (together with any interest accrued
thereon);
106
(iii) third, to the extent of any assets
remaining, each of the adjustments contemplated by
Section 6.4(f) [Early Year Adjustment], 6.5(e) [Band
Adjustment], 6.6(d) [Poultry Genetics] and 6.10 [Research Payments]
shall be added or netted, as appropriate, and the resulting net
adjustment amount paid to the Member entitled thereto;
and
(iv) fourth, any remaining assets shall be
distributed as between the Members and/or their Affiliates that
hold the Preference Shares, if any, in the following order of
priority: first, to the Members in an amount equal to the amount of
any Net Special Dividend that would be calculated for the Member
for the Fiscal Year in which the Dissolution of Merial occurs,
treating such Fiscal Year as ending on the date of such Dissolution
(to the extent not duplicative of (iii) above); second, in
respect of any accumulated but unpaid dividends on the Preference
Shares, to the holders thereof; third, in a return to the holders
of the Preference Shares of capital equal to the nominal value of
such shares, to the holders thereof; and fourth, equally as between
the Members in respect of their general ownership interest in
Merial.
107
EMPLOYEES AND EMPLOYEE BENEFIT
MATTERS
SECTION 7.1.
Animal Health Division — U.S.
(a)
Leasing of Merck Employees. The Merck Group employees
employed in the Animal Health Business in the U.S. as of the
Closing Date listed on a schedule to be provided by Merck on the
Closing Date, which list shall include not only employees then
actively employed but also those then on leave of absence,
short-term disability, long-term disability and workers
compensation (the “Merck Leased Employees”), shall be
leased to Merial, or to a Merial Venture Company designated by
Merial, as of the Closing Date pursuant to the terms set forth in
the Merck Employee Leasing Agreement. Each Merck Leased Employee
who is employed by Merck as of December 31, 1997 including not
only employees then actively employed but also those then on leave
of absence, short-term disability, long-term disability and workers
compensation shall be offered employment with Merial, or a Merial
Venture Company designated by Merial, as of January 1, 1998 at
a rate of base salary determined by Merial and shall be eligible to
participate in all employee benefit plans established and/or
maintained by Merial or such Merial Venture Company, as the case
may be. Notwithstanding the foregoing sentence, each Merck Leased
Employee who has commenced, or is eligible to commence, benefits
under the Merck & Co., Inc. Long-Term Disability Plan for
Non-Union Employees (the “Merck LTD Plan”) prior to
January 1, 1998 (a “Merck LTD Employee”) shall
continue to receive medical, dental, life insurance and long-term
disability benefits under the terms and conditions of the
applicable Merck benefit plans, as each may be amended from
time-to-time, and such continuation of benefits shall be at
Merck’s sole cost and expense; provided ,
however , that the costs of benefits provided to a Merck
Leased Employee who returns to work during the term of the Leasing
Agreement or, thereafter, returns to work with the Merial Venture,
shall be borne by Merial. Merck shall reimburse Merial (or the
appropriate Merial Venture Company) for the cost of providing
long-term disability benefits to each Merck Leased Employee who has
commenced or is eligible to commence benefits under the Merck &
Co., Inc. Short-Term Disability Plan for Non-Union
108
Employees prior
to the Closing Date and becomes eligible to receive, on or after
January 1, 1998, benefits under the Merial long-term
disability plan as a result of such pre-Closing disability,
provided such disability is continuous in accordance with the terms
of the Merial long-term disability plan. Those Merck Leased
Employees (including the Merck LTD Employees) who accept employment
with Merial, or a Merial Venture Company designated by Merial,
shall be referred to as the “Merial Merck
Employees.”
(b)
Grandfathered Merck Retirement Benefits. All Merial Merck
Employees shall be 100% vested in the Retirement Plan for Salaried
Employees of Merck & Co., Inc. (the “Qualified
Plan”) and in the Merck & Co., Inc. Supplemental
Retirement Plan, as each such plan may be amended from time to
time, (together with the Qualified Plan, the “Merck
Retirement Plans”) as of December 31, 1997. Each Merial Merck
Employee, the sum of whose age plus years of credited service
(within the meaning of the Qualified Plan) as of December 31,
1997 equals at least 60 (collectively, the “Grandfathered
Merck Employees”) shall receive credit for his or her years
of service with the Merial Venture for purposes of determining
eligibility to receive a subsidized early retirement benefit with
respect to his or her benefit accrued through December 31,
1997 under the Merck Retirement Plans. Unless required by law,
benefits under the Merck Retirement Plans shall not commence until
the Grandfathered Merck Employee terminates employment with the
Merial Venture. The compensation that each Merial Merck Employee
receives from the Merial Venture during the period from
January 1, 1998 to December 31, 2007 will for purposes of
determining his or her final average pay under the Merck Retirement
Plans be treated as if it were compensation received from Merck. An
accounting or actuarial firm mutually agreed upon by Merck and RP
shall determine the present value of the benefits to be provided to
Merial Merck Employees pursuant to this Section 7.1(b) that
are in excess of the benefits they would otherwise be entitled to
receive under the Merck Retirement Plans in the absence of this
Section 7.1(b) (such excess amount shall be defined as the
“Retirement Cost”). The Retirement Cost shall be
determined as of December 31, 1997 using the December 31,
1997 demographics of Merial Merck Employees and shall be based upon
the actuarial assumptions used by Merck for purposes of determining
pension expense pursuant to Financial Accounting Standards
(“FAS”) 87 for the Merck Retirement Plans for 1998.
Merial shall credit to the Merck Member in
109
respect of the
Fiscal Year in which the Retirement Cost is calculated a Special
Dividend equal to the Retirement Cost (as increased by an amount
calculated as interest at [*] from December 31, 1997 through
the earlier of (x) the date on which the Net Special Dividend
in respect of such Fiscal Year is paid in full, and
(y) April 15 of the Fiscal Year immediately following the
Fiscal Year in respect of which the Special Dividend is to be
paid).
(c)
Grandfathered Retiree Medical and Dental Benefits. Each
Grandfathered Merck Employee whose employment with the Merial
Venture terminates and who, at the time of such termination,
(i) is at least 55 years old with at least 10 years
of credited service (as defined under the Qualified Plan and
including service with the Merial Venture) or (ii) if hired by
Merck prior to January 1, 1989 is at least 65 years old
or meets the requirements of the foregoing clause (i), shall be
eligible to receive retiree medical benefits under the terms
applicable to retirees under the Merck & Co., Inc. Medical Plan
for Nonunion Employees as it may be amended from time to time (the
“Merck Medical Plan”) and shall be eligible to receive
retiree dental benefits under the terms applicable to retirees
under the Merck & Co., Inc. Dental Plan for Nonunion Employees
as it may be amended from time to time (the “Merck Dental
Plan”). An accounting or actuarial firm mutually agreed upon
by Merck and RP shall determine the present value of the
accumulated post retirement benefit obligation existing for
eligible Grandfathered Merck Employees (other than those employees
who, as of December 31, 1997 (i) are at least
55 years old with at least 10 years of credited service
(as defined under the Qualified Plan), or (ii) if hired by
Merck prior to January 1, 1989 are at least 65 years old or
meet the requirements of the immediately foregoing clause (i))
pursuant to this Section 7.1(c) (the “Health
Cost”). The Health Cost shall be determined as of
December 31, 1997 using the December 31, 1997
demographics of eligible Grandfathered Merck Employees and shall be
based upon the actuarial assumptions used by Merck for calculating
the expense for the Merck Medical Plan and the Merck Dental Plan
pursuant to FAS 106 for 1998. Merial shall credit to the Merck
Member in respect of the Fiscal Year in which the Health Cost is
calculated a Special Dividend equal to the Health Cost (as
increased by an amount calculated as interest at [*] from
December 31, 1997 through the earlier of (x) the date on which
the Net
110
Special
Dividend in respect of the 1998 Fiscal Year is paid in full, and
(y) April 15 of the Fiscal Year immediately following the
Fiscal Year in respect of which the Special Dividend is to be
paid).
(d) Merck
Stock Options. In addition to any stock option grants made
prior to the date of this Agreement under any Merck incentive stock
plan (all such plans collectively, the “Merck Stock Option
Plans”), Merck may make an additional grant under the current
Merck Stock Option Plan to be priced as of the Closing Date to
selected employees as determined by Merck who shall become Merck
Leased Employees. Merck will provide the shares of Merck common
stock obtained upon exercise of any stock option grants which have
been made by Merck under the Merck Stock Option Plans to any Merial
Merck Employee which are outstanding as of the Closing Date.
Promptly after any such exercise, Merck may invoice on an employee
by employee basis and, if so invoiced, Merial (or the appropriate
Merial Venture Company) will pay to Merck (within fifteen
(15) days after receipt of such invoice), the amount (the
“Spread”) equal to the product of (A) the excess
of (i) the per share market price of shares of Merck common stock
purchased on the exercise of the option, over (ii) the per
share exercise price of the stock option (adjusted for stock
splits, stock dividends, reclassification and similar events
between the date the stock option was granted and the exercise
date, as considered appropriate by Merck), times (B) the
number of shares issued upon such exercise. Merial shall credit to
the RP Member in respect of any Fiscal Year in which it pays a
Spread to Merck, a Special Dividend equal to the aggregate of
(x) all Spreads paid in such Fiscal Year by Merial to Merck
plus (y) any incidental costs associated with the payment of
such Spreads and paid by the Merial Venture (i.e., any employer
taxes paid). The Special Dividend (as described in the foregoing
sentence) that may be credited to the RP Member in any particular
Fiscal Year shall be increased by an amount calculated as interest
at a rate equal to [*] accruing from December 31 of such
Fiscal Year through the earlier of (x) the date on which the
Net Special Dividend in respect of such Fiscal Year is paid in
full, and (y) April 15 of the Fiscal Year immediately
following the Fiscal Year in respect of which the Special Dividend
is to be paid.
111
(e) RM
Plans. Following the Closing and until December 31, 1997,
Merial shall, or shall cause RM or its Subsidiaries to continue to,
maintain the employee benefit plans that were in effect for the
employees of RM or its Subsidiaries employed in the Animal Health
Business in the U.S. (“RM U.S. Employees”) immediately
prior to the Closing, other than any stock option plans (the
“RM Plans”). Prior to January 1, 1998, such RM
Plans shall only be amended (i) as required by law,
(ii) to maintain the tax qualified status of any such plan or
(iii) as determined by the Board of Directors; provided,
however, that the RM/Select 401 (k) Plan (the “RM 401
(k) Plan”) shall be amended as of July 1, 1997 to
provide an employer matching contribution of [*] each $1.00
deferred by a participant under the plan up to [*] of
compensation.
(f)
Merial Plans. Effective January 1, 1998, Merial shall,
or shall cause the appropriate Merial Venture Company to, amend the
RM Plans or otherwise establish such employee benefit plans in
accordance with the terms set forth herein (other than a severance
plan which shall be established as of the Closing Date) in which
Merial Merck Employees and RM U.S. Employees (collectively the
“U.S. Animal Health Employees”) shall participate as
Merial shall deem appropriate subject to the terms and conditions
set forth herein. It is the intention that such plans shall be
initially designed so that the expected aggregate cost for the
plans shall not, on an annualized basis, exceed the total combined
aggregate benefit plan costs of RM and it
|